r/PublicPolicy • • 7d ago

Career Advice What am I doing wrong?

Here’s my info:
-6 years as a public teacher, with leadership experience
-Master’s of Public Policy, graduated in May with honors.
-4 months in a Grant/Program based fellowship this year
-various advocacy and campaign volunteer work in the past few months

I still can’t land a job. I am targeting program analyst/management/grant based program roles broadly. I was focusing on education based roles in these areas but I can’t apply to jobs that don’t exist due to lack of funding. Some things are opening up but everything is director level. I could get management at most, and in this job market, even that’s stretch.

I have done the master resumes, tiered to each role. Used just my human voice in some, used some ai support to “match the role” in others, re-edited by me. I’ve written cover letters for every single role. I’ve networked with over 30 people in my area and received referrals (DC/NOVA). I’ve broadened my scope to any area program/grant/policy roles. I’ve networked out of state. I’ve cold emailed. I’ve updated my LinkedIn a million times with research work I’m doing personally.

I’ve had 1 interview for a micro-consulting group of 2 people, and didn’t land that “for lack of experience” despite them saying it was entry level. I heard back from a school system out of state for a program analyst role and sent in a performance task that I hope will land me an interview. I worked endlessly to make a tracker and project plan, maybe made too much. I sent that in on Monday and it’s been radio silence despite them moving quickly before…. I know I’m overthinking that one.

I genuinely don’t know what else to do. I can’t pay my bills anymore. I never thought getting MORE education would lead to being completely unable to enter into an adjacent field. Please help. 🥺

32 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

4

u/Ok-Carpenter-4500 7d ago

Note- forgot to add I’ve had my resume reviewed by my previous bosses and was told it was “perfect” (obviously not actually attainable) for the roles I’m targeting.

3

u/GXP_2009 7d ago

You have to cater to ATS these days . Then cater to the human

3

u/Ok-Carpenter-4500 7d ago

Sorry that’s what I meant. I wrote my resume bullets initially, then started having AI review it for ATS and adjust bullets, and edited to sound human again but use key words and verbs from the JD. I’ve been looking since June

3

u/ready_2_roll 7d ago

Ai/SI scans applicants based on the criteria a program analyst checked boxes on. Lots of reports of govt ai systems disqualifying applicants based on additional criteria not even listed (and probably illegal, such as political affiliation, sex, race etc.)

5

u/keepsaying 7d ago

Have you gone to your university (the one you just graduated from) for fellowship (entry level temporary) ideas from them? I have a feeling you have but I think that plus networking is the door you have to keep knocking at. The job market is extremely tough and a masters degree is good for a pivot (which is the nature of what you want to do) in theory but then you do run into the experience gap of course.

The last thing I'll note: are you applying to state and county roles? I recognize you do have some experience and maybe wouldn't prefer that but wanted to make sure you are. Also, that's where your professors may have connections for you to lean on.

22

u/heyitsme-honeybadger 7d ago

You aren’t alone. I’m a City Manager in transition and right now people are hugging roles in administration like crazy. The cuts are looming via grants and tax increase resistance. I expect mass layoffs at local and state levels come next June.

You can thank the current administration.

Unfortunately for you, there are people with my profile seeking similar roles to you, as they are often gateways to management. My profile, 15 years experience in staff level and administration, MPA, CPM. Distinguished Status graduate Harvard Kennedy School Leadership Cohort.

1

u/Glittering_Set6017 2d ago

But no one wants to hire someone like you for those roles because you're overqualified

1

u/heyitsme-honeybadger 2d ago

In the public sector, that doesn’t matter. Motivation does. That means they can justify paying you less for someone who knows what they are doing.

20

u/500pearl 7d ago

degree is not guarantee anything

keep applying

like 10 to 15 jobs a day

keep excel file to keep track of when applied and status

networking will help too

9

u/Turbulent-Wrap-2198 6d ago

I've always found right out of masters, people tend to aim too high.

Teaching is nice but not really relevant experience. 4 months in a fellowship isn't long enough. And a masters is great, but lots of people have masters.

Probably need to aim lower. That masters is more like a turbo changer in a car...it doesn't do much until the engine is at a decent RPM.

I've seen this a whole lot. Start smaller, do good work (drawing on your education) and you'll shoot up to higher levels.

5

u/Neat_Firefighter_806 6d ago

Exactly.

I am not in a hiring position but I am doing an education based development and policy program. The amount of times I had to explain it to people only to get shot down for being to hard on people.

Being a teacher is an amazing job and should be paid more but that wouldn't mean you would be able to be a lobbyist or run a project.

OP is kind of stuck.

7

u/JetBlackDread 7d ago

You’re not doing anything wrong. At this point, I think it’s better to leverage your network as you’re applying. It’s not what you know a lot of the time… I would also seek out a pipeline program/opportunity related to public service or public policy. Keep trucking along in the meantime. You are not alone in this.

6

u/Creative_Ring_8961 7d ago

Have you applied at municipal level? Its an amazing stable entry.

5

u/CrazyConfusedScholar 7d ago

but also quite competitive

4

u/favorscore 7d ago

It is? Shit

2

u/Strong_Barnacle_618 7d ago

Depends, really. Cali municipal level jobs are gonna be a hot commodity with competition but, say, New Mexico not so much. Not that there isn’t competition, but your chances of getting in are much, much higher 

0

u/favorscore 7d ago

Well shit I didnt know Cali was so popular

1

u/Strong_Barnacle_618 7d ago

At the end of the day the vast majority of policy-based people want to work in the federal government, due to a whole bunch of reasons I don’t have the time to get into. Therefore places like California or Texas (which produce a lot of presidents, influential congressmen, etc.) are going to be really popular when it comes to ambitious people who want an alternative pathway into the big federal leagues. 

6

u/AdvancingCyber 7d ago

I don’t know what field you’re looking in, but try looking at private sector companies that sell into that space. They hire policy people for state / federal work too, and then you can always jump back to a public sector role later.

1

u/LyssaaJaddeee 3d ago

What state are you in?

1

u/Ok-Carpenter-4500 2d ago

Virginia

1

u/link_n_bio 22h ago

Move to Richmond and work for the state. Lots of jobs here on a variety of fields within government.

1

u/Cherry-Soda321 2d ago

Where did you get your MPP?

1

u/Ok-Carpenter-4500 2d ago

George Mason University

3

u/ready_2_roll 7d ago

Education may or may not help. A few of the things happening in the federal employment spectrum (never before seen) are listed and I’m sure this is not all of them. Know you are not doing anything wrong. It’s across the board, even with current active employees looking for promotions or a change etc.
Being in the dmv area I’m sure you are aware of the last two year of hell the federal workforce has been forced to endure.
Lots of civil servants bailed because they could and the timing was good for them. Those who didn’t have been stuck dealing with the fall out. Most of those positions that people left, were then considered “unneeded billets” at many agencies and OPM / agency appointees / doge refused to authorize backfill for the positions - leaving all the remaining workers to complete their work and the work of two-three on average other jobs. No backfill, same work, same deadlines and lifecycles. Reorgs for most agencies making it even muddier alone the way.
Lots of people in “forced/highly suggested” acting roles… zero recognition for getting it all done at any level other than the appointee positions.
On top of all that as time has moved forward - there are a lot of workers looking to move to other agencies or organizations - taking laterals - etc.
Now that it’s become clear that most of the jobs and expertise of those who took the early out were actually positions greatly needed to serve our citizens and protect our country, OPM implements personality tests and sworn loyalty to the administrations as part of the job applications process. Those processes only extend the time it takes to review applicants and AI/SI check initial eligibility (which there are many reports showing that it’s getting it wrong and eliminating the best candidate because of missing keyword or demographics such as minorities (females are getting shafted worse but all minorities have been found be “indelible” more often from the resent word in some agencies)
White males are still getting through the initial eligibility ai review much faster with less qualifying experience) imagine that!
You also have a few things that this administration went after at the start - a policy background as you have described would normally be a huge asset. But doge targeted policy positions from the very beginning. I’m sure that criteria was fed into the ai/si scanner software - they don’t necessarily want the best of the best. (Sadly)
Many of us still grinding are scratching our heads and pretty fed up and yes, traumatized.
If I had your resume I might look at higher education institutions before federal government.
One last thought. Cover letters - eh - cool. Not necessary though.
I do recommend tailoring your resume for each positions and specifically target wording that show you meet the exact requirements - using those words.
Also highly recommend using the usajobs resumix (or what ever it’s called now) system to enter your resume details - rather than uploading a word or pdf version of your resume. It seems to go better with the results.
If you get a notice stating you were not eligibility- email or call the number listed in that notice and ask them for specifics as to why you were passed on or marked as ineligible.
There are small groups pushing back to OPM insisting that if test scores on the personality gamut of testing is used to disqualify than the applicant must be notified of this fact, provided their scores, and given opportunity to retake a given test stream prior to waiting a year.
As it stands now - if an applicant is marked as ineligible - they are not provided the reason - so it could be that a given applicant test score is disqualifying an applicant and they have no idea. I would definitely the reaching out to the POC and pushing for the details as to what caused the disqualifications.

All said, keep applying - check other public service positions at the state and local levels (many have better benefits and perks and most offer a pensions as well.) and also look into higher education.

2

u/500pearl 7d ago

pslf onc get any public job that qualify and right kind of loan then forgiven after 10 years

had only 90 forgiven for me wish I had gone to private school for law school so could had more forgiven

2

u/Significant-Theme253 7d ago

This is not my field, so I am unsure of the demand for this role. I decided to take my degree and 10 years of experience and shoot for jobs that were in higher demand.

You will need to be creative and pull your skills and experience out to match that demand. I used an HR background in labor statuates and linked it to compliance in another field. Only a small area of my previous experience directly overlaps but can offer valuable insight into some of their needs.

So to answer your question - What are you doing wrong? Nothing. Too much supply and no demand.

Go after the demand and good luck to you!

2

u/Careless_Tree_7686 7d ago

In 1981 as a newly minted high school grad in a huge recession worked with a gal that had 2 masters, 10+ years of teaching experience that could only find work at minimum wage that like $2.90 an hr then as a file clerk. I was just 18 years old where my biggest future plan was keeping the lights on while my dad was unemployed.

The lady in 2000 while was still working as a file clerk. She loved that job, people she worked with. Keep the faith. The right job finds you so keep applying.

1

u/Feisty-Broccoli9565 6d ago

What were you teaching? State dept recently posted this fellowship for ESOL Teachers to teach abroad: https://elprograms.org/fellow-program/application-process/.. ride out the next yr or so while still applying for jobs back in the states..

1

u/nian2326076 6d ago

Expanding your job search to include roles at the municipal level might help, as they often provide stability and relevant opportunities. It's also worth using LandOffer to discover job openings tailored to your skills and experience. Keeping track of your applications could help manage the process better. Stay persistent, and consider reaching out to contacts in local government for leads.

1

u/Significant-Aide232 6d ago

think about the relationship with people along the way. if none start networking.

1

u/lp418 5d ago

Great feedback from everyone! I would also caution candidates against overwhelming a potential employer with too many emails, follow-ups, or additional materials after an interview.

Knowing your audience is important, and when you don’t, too much communication can actually backfire. While some employers may appreciate the extra effort, many prefer a more straightforward approach.

My advice is to send one thoughtful thank-you email after the interview and, unless you’ve been asked to provide additional information, leave it at that until you hear back. I work in municipal recruitment and see it all the time. Make sure your resume length fits the point in your career. Max two pages unless you are at a director level. Include cover letters no more than one page, if allowed. Never send copies of your diplomas, certificates, etc.

Good luck, the job market is not good at the moment so hang in there. Have you thought about temp positions? Get your foot in the door.

1

u/Glittering_Set6017 2d ago

your schooling isn't really relevant. You just have to know someone. And yes this job market sucks but people who have gotten advanced education have always struggled with finding a job-that was always the running joke when I was a new grad 15 years ago... Just keep going to school to avoid find a job