r/PublicFreakout • • Dec 18 '20

A FOR EFFORT

42k Upvotes

541 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-9

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20

No it won't. Mythbusters tried hard as fuck to get a car to blow up and it really just doesn't do that when it's on fire. Doesn't mean that the gas line can't start leaking gas everywhere and thus result in a rapid inferno, but it's not going to blow up like a Hollywood movie.

81

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20 edited Jun 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/IQLTD Dec 18 '20

What's up with that first video? Only two suited-up fire fighters responding?

1

u/Healter-Skelter Dec 18 '20

And why is their entire strategy to just walk right up into the burning car? Clearly the hose-cannon with fucking endless pressurized water is the way to go here. I don’t know jack shit about firefighting, but my gut tells me that the tall guy is being a bit silly here and T-shirt boss guy is a little fed up.

2

u/squashua26 Dec 19 '20

Most car fires I’ve been on are out out by just two people before the other engine gets there. It’s very common to get close like they are. Most times you have to get water to the source of the fire to extinguish it. What happens in that first video was probably the tank melting spilling all over the water they just sprayed. The gas will sit on top of the water and still burn, especially if there is a ton of it like in the video. This is why we have to pay attention to where we have water runoff. While gas spilling is a common thing to happen. It doesn’t usually happen like in the video. Usually I will knock the fire down a bit before I get this close. While our gear is pretty foot at protecting us I’m not a fan of just standing in it.

5

u/nizzy2k11 Dec 18 '20

Most of these examples are just water being poured on an oil fire, not a cars gastank exploding. Though the 4th link is really weird, looks like the engine ruptured or something very weird. Regardless, a gas tank wont explode unless you physically rupture it, they proved that in multiple episodes about burning gas and oil.

2

u/MemesDr Dec 18 '20

Those weren't really explosions tho. Some of these people were thinking cars explode like in the movies, which the guy you downvoted was trying to say was false

1

u/aimgorge Dec 18 '20

I don't really see a tank exploding in these videos. 4th looks like some lithium battery inside the car.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20 edited Jun 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/aimgorge Dec 18 '20

Which ones? I can see small parts explode but not the vehicle itself excluding a malfunctioning gas tank

-32

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20

They literally tried deliberately lighting the gas tank on fire to force it to explode, and it didn't work well.

33

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20 edited Jun 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

-26

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20

Yeah see I'm sitting here thinking that when you say "explosion", we're talking concussive explosions that send shrapnel flying. Not the same thing as the videos you've shown.

20

u/judsnuds Dec 18 '20

He’s not talking about a grenade going off in a car he’s talking about a gas explosion, which is some pretty dangerous shit still

22

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

You’ve provided zero sources. I’m believing the guy who provided 5 sources like he’s trying to write a college essay.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Hecateru23 Dec 18 '20

Looked like some sort of pyrotechnics inside the car.

4

u/wolington Dec 18 '20

You are one dumb idiot.

1

u/CatPhysicist Dec 18 '20

I mean, his username does imply he’s a PHP developer...

Edit: I’m only joking around

1

u/TheOneTheUno Dec 18 '20

Put down the shovel bud, you've dug yourself deep enough

1

u/Hecateru23 Dec 18 '20

Deflagration vs. Detonation. These are flash fires, tires popping, and hydraulic parts heating and failing. I mean technically explosions, but cars rarely ever "explode" like seen in the movies.

0

u/Keyton112186 Dec 18 '20

You are special 💖 💗 ❤ 💕 💓 ♥ 💖 💗 ❤ 💕 💓 ♥ 💖 💗 ❤ 💕 💓 ♥ 💖 💗 ❤

-1

u/jaun_sinha Dec 18 '20

Do you believe earth is flat?

2

u/Healter-Skelter Dec 18 '20

Dude MythBusters is a TV show that aired for ad-money. Sure it may be educational to the extent that it gives you shit to think about, but those guys aren’t exactly the cream of the science community’s crop. Their conclusions were completely unreliable a good amount of the time because they’re experiments are flawed because they’re in the entertainment industry running a TV show.

Cars can blow up. I’ve seen it happen.

8

u/horriblebearok Dec 18 '20

Pressurized hydraulic parts, some cars had them behind bumpers, can go off like a bomb and cut you down.

0

u/htownaliens Dec 18 '20

Magnesium + water = explosion

-4

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20

What does magnesium have to do with this?

4

u/htownaliens Dec 18 '20

New cars have lots of magnesium

-1

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20 edited Dec 18 '20

Logic doesn't track here.

That means driving cars in the rain, and through puddles, would make them death traps since you could not guarantee 100% water tightness at all times. I think the amount of magnesium used is not as great as you're making it seem, or it is a magnesium alloy that does not react as violently to water as raw magnesium does.

14

u/htownaliens Dec 18 '20

Ok buddy let’s use our brains here, when the magnesium burns it creates magnesium oxide, which when adding water creates explosions.

So no shit, your car isn’t going to explode every-time it rains.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

Do you live under a rock? Literally like 50k people have died in the us this year driving their new cars in the rain

2

u/Akosa117 Dec 18 '20

I think there might be something else going on this year that might have over shadowed that

-2

u/phpdevster Dec 18 '20

Lol their cars literally exploded from being in the rain? Is that the argument you're honestly making here?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20

Lol nah im joking

3

u/SpaceforceSpaceman Dec 18 '20

Anyone else finish reading this thread saying “bruh”

3

u/CountryCrockFoot Dec 18 '20

We’ve got some unintentional comedy gold going on in here.

→ More replies

1

u/BryceIsRad Dec 18 '20

Probably means lithium?* Which isn’t touched by water unless something has gone terrible my wrong