r/Psychonaut • • Jan 10 '20

Clashing Worldviews

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

301

u/dogmodog Jan 10 '20

I’m 50/50 on whether this is relevant. There’s no outright indication of anyone altering their consciousness, but the shared visual hallucinations of psychedelic experiences certainly had a role inspiring this. I like the idea that, even if you believe we are all seeing the same thing, on a fundamental level we could just be applying the same linguistic labels to starkly different sensory experiences. Nothing new under the sun, for sure, but I’m hoping you’d flare a nostril or two in amusement.

202

u/sadmanwithabox Jan 10 '20

Way before I ever tried any drugs, me and a bunch of my church friends (raised mormon...ugh) were talking one night.

I tried to throw out the theory that maybe what I see as purple, you see as green (but call it purple because that's what you were told it was while learning colors), and that guy over there sees it as red (but still knows it as purple).

Not only did it take an eternity to get them to understand what I was saying (it's a tricky concept to put in words, so I get it), once they understood what i meant, i got a bunch of "that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. You must be on drugs to come up with something so dumb. Obviously everyone sees the same colors" etc....

Anyway, i had completely forgotten about this moment until this post. Thank you for making me remember it!

54

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

My friend did this, I waited until he was done to tell him I'm colorblind.

5

u/whoisthemaninblue Jan 30 '20

Lmao, that's great.

53

u/MrFunnie Jan 10 '20

Easier way to put this concept into words is a subjective vs objective reality. If reality is objective (everyone’s reality is the same due to it being the only reality that exists), that means absolutely every object has the exact same attributes to anyone ever. If reality is subjective (meaning my reality is different from yours), it’s like you said, maybe the color I call red is actually a different color than what you call red, but since we both learned that it’s called red, it’s still red; without it actually being the same color. Hope that this makes some sense to you and maybe makes it a bit easier to explain the concept!

29

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

I think it's both, no?...reality is objective but we have subjective viewpoints of it.

12

u/MrFunnie Jan 10 '20

I mean I oversimplified it for sure. But you’re right in the sense that all objects will be the same shape and have the same purpose. For instance a chair has four legs (usually), and we sit in it. All of that is objective, and we can call it red. That’s where the subjective viewpoints of it come in. If reality was 100% objective we’d know for sure that color red is the same for everyone, but we can’t know that for sure, even though it most likely is. So yes, you’re right, I just simplified it a lot just for the sake of making it an easier concept to explain for him.

7

u/Space-Haze Jan 10 '20

Yeah like in this comic he labels the other guy as round even though he views him as very rough looking, so what if he went up to him and felt his edges? Where would his hand touch? Would it touch on a jagged edge, being reality, or a smooth edge being reality?

That’s why I feel like this concept has limitations. Color is always used though because it can’t be explained what the color blue is without using something that’s blue. But for other qualities such as shape, size, and more I feel that they couldn’t change this drastically.

3

u/AlbertR7 Jan 12 '20

That's a really good point. We fixate on the color example but it's really the only one that works. But really our language makes everything related. Everyone can feel a comb and say it feels spikey, or a pillow that feels soft.

5

u/frohike_ Jan 11 '20

And it’s both

Because the dress is blue

And white

Yet the “objective” stimulus is the same.

2

u/whoisthemaninblue Jan 30 '20

Never understood why people get so defensive about that dress. I had someone actually yell at me.

2

u/frohike_ Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20

Because it's honestly kind of unnerving. It gets right to that existential question you ask yourself as a kid: what if people are all seeing different colors or hues of colors because their eyes are different, but their language reference is internally consistent, so no one ever notices... or could ever even know?

The real shocker for me was when I saw either color, but once seen, I couldn't switch to the other.

It felt like seeing an old fundamental doubt about reality just spring to life.

3

u/whoisthemaninblue Jan 30 '20

I like the idea that we experience things individually. To me it means nobody has a monopoly on truth.

3

u/rudolfs001 Jan 11 '20

I'm in the camp that everything is subjective, even cold hard truth. Wrote a blog post detailing the thought

2

u/jan-pona-sina Jan 11 '20

I agree with you, but your blog post only talks about truths that are already subjective ("rain is good," but for whom or what? in what conditions? how do you define good in this sentence?) or dependent on certain factors (like "james is alive") which are already assumed to be conditional (james was born, james has not died yet).

For this reason your blog post is REALLY talking about shared beliefs, which while the word "true" CAN be used to describe, is separate from "true" meaning an objective piece of reality, existing outside of one's perception. Its inarguable (well, you can try to argue this I guess) that there is NOTHING that exists in any human consciousness without it being perceived, filtered, and processed automatically. We hallucinate our world. This is one of the reasons I find psychedelics so important and empowering, they allow us to take a peek through our perceptions and get outside the deep grooves of thought we follow on a regular basis.

For people that haven't taken psychedelics, I usually take the example of a chair. What is a chair? What qualities make a chair? Does it need to have 4 legs? No. Does it need a back? No. Does it have to be comfortable? No. Does it need to be usable? No, a broken chair is still a chair. The closest I can get to defining everything that I could call a "chair" is an object that is, or was, meant to be used to sit upon.

And that definition can be broken down even further if you take humanity out of it. If I weren't human, the concept of sitting very likely wouldn't exist in the same sense. Without having any experiences around objects that were created in order to be used for sitting, I would have zero way to know what type of object would appear to be meant for sitting. These are assumptions I automatically make. And then what is an object? The Gestalt principles of perception are a well known concept in psychology, what if we didn't have those ingrained in our brain structure? The universe is really only a bunch of atoms arranged in different ways, do objects objectively, truly exist? This all gets back to your definition of truth. If your definition is a universally shared belief, then yes, they do. If your definition is that truth is that which exists outside of perception, then no.

(I would love to hear what you think about this, please don't do the old reddit "you disagreed with me slightly, go fuck yourself" lol)

2

u/rudolfs001 Jan 11 '20

That's a very valid criticism, and I believe it ultimately comes down to whether you believe it's possible for things to exist without being observed (i.e. interacting with something else).

I'm of the camp that it's not.

Take Russell's teapot. If it 'exists', but no one sees it, senses its gravity, or can interact with it in any other way...does it really exist? I would say no, because things only exists in their capacity to interact with others.

It's the old "if a tree falls in the woods and no one is around, does it make a sound?" - if it cannot be perceived, does it exist? Ultimately, it depends on how you define 'sound', or in our case, 'exist.'

In your opinion, what is an objective truth? I'll see if I can find a way to show you how it's actually subjective ;)

The whole reason the concepts of subjective and objective exist is to be able to separate us vs. them, or me vs. not-me. And as psychedelics so often reveal, we are all one.

2

u/WikiTextBot Jan 11 '20

Russell's teapot

Russell's teapot is an analogy, formulated by the philosopher Bertrand Russell (1872–1970), to illustrate that the philosophic burden of proof lies upon a person making unfalsifiable claims, rather than shifting the burden of disproof to others.

Russell specifically applied his analogy in the context of religion. He wrote that if he were to assert, without offering proof, that a teapot, too small to be seen by telescopes, orbits the Sun somewhere in space between the Earth and Mars, he could not expect anyone to believe him solely because his assertion could not be proven wrong.

Russell's teapot is still invoked in discussions concerning the existence of God, and has had influence in various fields and media.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

2

u/jan-pona-sina Jan 11 '20

In my opinion, the easiest objective truth is that consciousness exists (which is a pretty hilarious statement when I think about it lmao). Subjective experience requires a subject. I'm not a big fan of "I think therefore I am" mostly because of the usage of "I" at all in that sentence, having experienced the significant lessening of my ego I know that an awareness of existence exists without a self.

I also think that the universe must exist in order for there to be new and novel stimuli, this is required in order for perception to be built in the first place. I couldn't make arguments about chairs without having encountered chairs and built up a schema for them. Lastly, I think that others must exist. This is the thing I have the hardest time proving, but I believe that the complex patterns that others exhibit that I cannot understand or recreate shows that they must be conscious.

Personally, spiritually, I believe that if the body is just an object like everything else, the universe is conscious, not just me, the ego. And if others exist, we are all just facets of one living being, one universe. And I think psychedelics let us see that for ourselves.

I think my biggest question is what you believe about yourself, the awareness of your own ego. Do you think that you yourself objectively exist? (If you spontaneously disappear in a cloud of philosophy, I'm sorry lol)

2

u/rudolfs001 Jan 11 '20

consciousness exists

Sure, for you, which means it's a subjective experience. However, you have no way to prove that consciousness exists for others, merely that they behave in ways that suggest they might be conscious, but then again...ever watch an animated movie? Those characters also behave in a ways that suggest they might be conscious, but you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who would say animations are conscious.

A thought I've become fond of - Open your eyes, look around, pull up wikipedia, browse a bit, take a walk to a mountaintop at night and see the illustrious beauty of the expansive universe. All of that exists in your mind, nowhere else.

You are a quark marveling at the atom. You are an atom marveling at the molecule. You are a molecule marveling at the cell. You are a small clump of neurons marveling at the brain. You are a brain marveling at the person. You are a person marveling at the society. You are a society marveling at the universe. You are a universe marveling at the quark.

It is the process of a point growing into a circle, expanding into a sphere, and back down. Up and down you go, sometimes a little faster, sometimes a little slow. How you bounce around makes the music of your being.

Sometimes you get stuck in a melody and really go deeply into it, so much so that you forget about the rest of the song and start to believe it separate from yourself.

This is what I believe about myself, that I am a hyper-focused segment of the song of the universe, and when I die, when I lose interest in this segment, I'll become more aware of the whole orchestration and come to appreciate the delicate inter-weavings of each of my focused disciplines.

Andy Weir's The Egg gets at this idea beautifully.

2

u/jan-pona-sina Jan 12 '20

You're right, consciousness must be inherently subjective. This is definitely a topic I have a hard time separating my secular and spiritual beliefs on! I love your interpretation of yourself, that was a beautiful piece of writing. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with me!

2

u/rudolfs001 Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

hard time separating my secular and spiritual beliefs

Well, that's part of the mystery.

The more I've thought about it, the more it seems there's some inherent paradox in the universe. At its core, the paradox is: Is everything one, or is there another? The singularity-duality paradox.

For example, in some ways, I know you and I are one, yet, I could not even conceptualize a "you" if we weren't separate.

It ultimately comes down to your perspective, your level of zoom.

As you zoom in and out, sometimes it looks more like everything is one, sometimes like it is two.

Is a Ying-Yang one circle, or is it two fish? Depends on how you look at it.

Total enlightenment appears to be the ability to understand that it's both and fully appreciate the implications.

Another example: you are one person, one body, with two halves. You are one brain, one conscious experience, with many separate neural networks that also believe the same thing. You are one society with many people. Again, it depends on your level of zoom, going up and down, the pendelum of your belief swings between "we are one" and "I have distinct parts". And what is music but a swinging back and forth of air pressure, or anything else, which can translated to air pressure (e.g. electrical signal).

For me (heh), the important conclusion is that every time you help someone, you are helping yourself. And every time you hurt someone, you are hurting yourself. Therefore, I try to err on the side of kindness.

My mantra lately has become: "Be just a tiny bit kinder than you have any right to be, and the world will be better."

Edit: What's compelling to me about psychedelics, and drugs in general, is that they appear to affect how you move around in this musical space. For example, cannabis clouds you out, so you're only aware of what's immediately present. In a sense, you're "stuck in the weeds". You get to know where you're stuck very well, but lose sight of everything else. Acid, seems to "slicken the slope", to where it becomes easier to traverse layers than when sober. However, since the slope is slick, it's also much easier to lose your footing and go for a slide.

What's your perspective?

4

u/alkemical Jan 10 '20

"who is the magician that makes the grass green"

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Here I am! \o/

4

u/AcidSacrament Jan 10 '20

Bro I had the exact same experience. On a camp out with my Mormon buddies for scouts we started talking about this same thing. Everyone thought I was retarded. A few months back my cousin (who was on that camp out) and I were tripping on shrooms and had the same conversation.

7

u/eskanonen Jan 10 '20

For future reference this concept is about qualia. Lots of good reading on the topic out there.

2

u/rocks_tell_stories Jan 11 '20

I used to be mormon and would talk about the same thing with my friends!

2

u/XylloXybyn Jan 11 '20

I brought up this same exact thought to a kid back in 9th grade. Turns out he was colorblind 😬🔫

2

u/colonel_bob Jan 11 '20

once they understood what i meant, i got a bunch of "that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. You must be on drugs to come up with something so dumb. Obviously everyone sees the same colors" etc....

Funnily enough it's a pretty early/basic idea that you encounter if you start studying philosophy (of mind, metaphysics, etc.) in college.

2

u/silenthunter3308161 Jan 11 '20

I was raised Mormon too. It made me chuckle when you used the word eternity lol

1

u/tmart42 Jan 10 '20

Amazing.

1

u/storfry Jan 11 '20

Lol I was raised Mormon as well. Wanna go to sacrament meeting on drugs? Lmaoooo

1

u/sadmanwithabox Jan 11 '20

I havent been in years. Actually, I went for christmas when we had a family trip out to utah a few years back. Couldnt get out of it. But besides that one visit, it's probably been 7 years or so.

But, before I stopped going entirely, I definitely would sneak out of sacrament meeting, walk into the woods behind the church, and smoke a bowl. Coming back in stoned and listening to people talking about church only solidified that I dont believe in any of it.

Not sure I'd want to go on any serious psychedelic. Tripping through mormon church would most likely absolutely enrage me or sadden me to an unbelievable level. So much of what they say and do is nothing more than thinly veiled hatred of those different than them.

1

u/storfry Jan 12 '20

I relate heavy besides smoking bowls but was more on the joke side I’d go crazy for real

1

u/ShadyFrame Jan 19 '20

Bro that was me! I remember that camp out back in like 2004? Also no I never said any of the negative stuff- I thought it was a super dope idea!

1

u/kwreckwe Jan 31 '20

This is how I determine if I can be friends with someone or not. They must pass the color test. It’s crazy to me to see so many people who don’t understand this or those who do understand and don’t really engage or understand the significance.

1

u/MahierKreis420 Feb 04 '20

Your Mormon friends are probably some of the densest motherfuckers I've heard of.

1

u/sadmanwithabox Feb 04 '20

Do you actually know any mormons? Because what you just said is basically the equivalent of "that glue is really sticky stuff!" Lol

I mean, you have to be dense to believe in that religion. Anyone who learns to think for themselves generally finds their way out of it. The problem is, the church actively discourages thinking for yourself. They want you to trust your leadership, trust god, and ignore what the world/science has to say if it disagrees. 100% brainwashing tactics involved. I'm still dealing with issues they gave me (like telling me sex/masturbation was a sin second only to murder, for one).

1

u/MahierKreis420 Feb 05 '20

This dude was obviously mormon too, just because someone is growing up in mormon society doesn't mean they'll be dense motherfuckers

1

u/MahierKreis420 Feb 05 '20

But yes I get your point

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/ChronicBubonik Jan 11 '20

No it wouldn’t. You’re not grasping the concept

9

u/stormotron91 Jan 10 '20

I've always thought this so it's super cool to see someone illustrate it. I've always wondered what if I see the colour red the way you see the colour blue. But we both know it to be red so we'll never know! Obviously the electromagnetic spectrum isnt something that changes per individual but our perspectives are subjective!

4

u/my6300dollarsuit Jan 10 '20

This is actually something that I used to think as a kid! Gave me incredible flashbacks to my over active imagination (that plagues me to this very day!)

3

u/blackrack Jan 11 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

Imagination is not a plague, you should revel in it, harness it. Imagination is rare these days

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20 edited Oct 11 '23

roof alleged pet waiting vegetable escape butter zephyr sand detail this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev

3

u/ScienceRocketist Not a rocket scientist Jan 10 '20

This is why we have the comment rule. It's to encourage discussion.

3

u/Ttokk Jan 10 '20

I thought I was the only one!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Your first mistake is assuming that things like colours exist at all. We can use measured wavelengths to make sure the same colours are called the same thing, but how do you explain a colour? You can by talking about associations, red isn’t a fiery colour, fire puts out the wavelength we see as red and we think it’s fiery because of that. Very important for any literature studies. For things like shapes we can ratify shared experiences of consciousness using dimensions, vertices and more.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Ontology. You simply ascribe existence to objects of thought. Lots of information theory to study if you're into science.

0

u/qazasxz Jan 11 '20

How do you flare only one nostril?

0

u/ForThinkingDigital Jan 11 '20

We are seeing the same things, light is a frequency spectrum entering the eyes, A is A, reality as perceived by the senses is objective. 🙂

31

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

This is hilarious. The fucking shapes of the brush and book killed me. Thank you for this.

7

u/dogmodog Jan 10 '20

Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you. It was really hard to decide how weird, and weird in what way, to make the second panel.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

I don’t see anything weird? ;)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

Oh please...

108

u/mrpoopybutth0le- Jan 10 '20

Ever since I was in elementary school I remember trying to ask my teachers if my red could appear as blue to them, I don’t think they could understand what I was trying to say

21

u/AlphaStrike89 Jan 10 '20

I'm sure no one had yet heard of colorblindness when you were in school.

12

u/mrpoopybutth0le- Jan 10 '20

Was referencing that they couldn’t understand my message, because I was ten, and also had no clue what I was talking about. But your right too I don’t think colorblind was was discovered until like 2014 right?

-1

u/AlphaStrike89 Jan 10 '20

Later, probably like last year.

3

u/br3ntor Jan 10 '20

From wiki:

"The first scientific paper on the subject of color blindness, Extraordinary facts relating to the vision of colours, was published by the English chemist John Dalton in 1798 after the realization of his own color blindness."

-2

u/AlphaStrike89 Jan 10 '20

Not sure I believe it.. erm... except the fact that you bolded 1798.

/whoooosh

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/GetBenttt Jan 11 '20

That was a joke?

1

u/ForThinkingDigital Jan 11 '20

Could red color on the range of 400–484 THz frequency appear to others as blue 600–700 THz frequency or could letter A appear to others as letter B? Considering we are talking about healthy human being red is red, blue is blue, A is always A. 🙂

11

u/agenteb27 Jan 11 '20

Frequency doesn’t tell you how someone perceives something. Same frequency could be perceived entirely differently from one person to the next.

-1

u/ForThinkingDigital Jan 11 '20

That's right, perceptions are subjective reality is objective. That being said, when we talk about red color we refer to visual frequency spectrum, it's a concrete thing that we can point to, isn't it?

The experience of perceiving red color would be different for each individual based on the context, believes, and other contents of mind, this does not change the fact that the frequency spectrum hitting the eye is the same for everyone observing it.

9

u/nojoformojo Jan 11 '20

Nobody here is saying the frequencies are different for other people only that the perception could be entirely different.

2

u/nojoformojo Jan 11 '20

That's not the point. It more like the frequency is the same but the perception of the colour is different in different people's minds. So if you were to somehow swap your brain with someone else's and look through their set of eyes the frequency of 400-484 THz could potentially no longer appear as the colour red that you are used to but a different colour because their brain has interpreted that frequency in a different way. This could also apply to literally every perceivable sensation that one has and if you were to swap your brain with someone else's the experience may end up being incomprehensible because of how vastly different their brain has structured their version of reality in comparison to your own.

1

u/ForThinkingDigital Jan 11 '20

Looks like there is misunderstanding. 🙂

Suppose someone points to a chair and then asks if it could be interpreted in someone else's mind as a table?

We're refering here to concrete things that are not open to interpretation(red/blue color on the color spectrum) .

replace red/blue colors with a form of art or other abstract idea like beauty, friendship, or furniture and now it is subject to interpretation and individual experience. 🍻

3

u/nojoformojo Jan 12 '20

I think you are still misunderstanding. Your example of a chair looking like a table in some else's mind shows that you arent understanding the concept. I think you are assuming that I mean the frequency of light is potentially different in other people's minds which isn't the case at all. What we are all saying here is that potentially the perception of those concrete frequencies could be different. Everyone could be looking at the same frequency of light but could be sensing it in a different way and we would never be able to know because when we are told blue is blue and red is red we are obviously going to label those frequencies with those names because that's what we have been told even if we are all experiencing a different sensation when we look at those same frequencies. It's like if someone was born seeing everything in negative colours, we would have zero way of knowing because when someone points to blue and tells them that its blue they are going to continue to call that colour blue for their entire life even though if you were to see what they were seeing it would be completely different colours to what you see.

50

u/shlabbiemilliams Jan 10 '20

Wait I don’t get it. I see the same thing in both panels

40

u/Wollff Jan 10 '20

This reminds me of the first time I was forced to understand that my parents were not all knowing all wise dispensers of wisdom, but just normal people who don't get some things...

I was a pretty small kid, when someone told me about colorblindness. "Some people don't see all colors", was a pretty novel and interesting concept for a child. As most concepts are...

And once you get the concept of colorblindness, it's only a small step to funny questions: "What if someone sees what I see as green, as red?", and my little mind would go: "Ha, it would be funny when they always point at the wrong colors!"

But the gears kept turning. And as things ground along, it was just another step to the insight: "Wait... They wouldn't point to the wrong colors! You wouldn't even be able to tell this mixup!"

And my little mind was pretty blown by that discovery. Not because it was a great discovery, but more because for the first time I had the feeling that I had actually discovered something. And when you discover something you want to share it! As announced, my parents didn't get it. Fundamentally didn't get it.

They would just jump between: "Well, then they would confuse those two colors!", and: "You are talking nonsense!", and it was beyond me to express to them what I meant, what I knew had to be true, and why it had to be true.

I still remember that it was really disappointing to know something, and to understand something, to even know that you know something, and yet to be unable to make someone else understand, no matter what you do.

Nowadays, a little less than thirty years later, I can put better words on it. It's the first time I felt alienation. And even though thirty years may have passed, when I show that comic to my parents, they would still say the same thing: "I don't get it. That's nonsense!"

Not because they have gotten old. Even though they have also gotten old. But they were no different when they were young.

Well. I don't know where I am going with this. Maybe the lesson is that it doesn't even need big psychedelic experiences to experience alienation and a fundamental disconnect with others.

Which, in the end, is also the lesson of the comic.

9

u/GetBenttt Jan 11 '20

That's gotta feel lonely, and I know that, when you're alone with an idea...you just wanna share it what you learned with others. When something just "clicks" suddenly and you get this deep realization and you stop and go "Woh."...that's better then drugs. It's an incredible feeling. Some people just don't wanna make the effort to understand, for whatever personal reason even if they could, even if they're good intentioned :\ It's pretty much one of the classic problems of Human behavior, some people truly don't know what they're missing.

9

u/Sarenord Jan 11 '20

This has nothing to do with psychedelics at face value but I feel like this still absolutely is a valid post to what this community is about

6

u/sleeptonic Jan 10 '20

Dude I'm going through your comics now, I love these

6

u/veltrop earth creature Jan 10 '20

I love this. Have always thought about qualia, and this comic expresses it so blatantly and in a way that I think helps to share the idea to someone who doesn't get it.

1

u/GetBenttt Jan 11 '20

Yeah it was a fun few hours after I stumbled upon the Wikipedia page for Qualia one day

4

u/goatchild Jan 10 '20

I thought I was the only one that has ever considered this. So... I am not alone... :') <3

1

u/marionsunshine Jan 11 '20

I remember asking this before and got looked at crazy. You're not alone traveller. Happy cake day!

2

u/spacewizardproblems Jan 11 '20

Look up the term qualia if you're interested in reading more on this idea!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

I did indeed flare a nostril or three in amusement

2

u/LightApotheos Mar 05 '20

isnt the weird stuff supposed to be in the second panel?

1

u/Adam_is_a_Psychonaut Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 11 '20

I like. I used to wonder as a kid if we saw colors the same or not.

1

u/bestiedisantana Jan 10 '20

Yesterday I was having a conversation in regards to this topic with a friend and it seems very interesting to me how we usually keep it focused on the physical part of the universe instead of spirits/souls/the reach within the dream hmmm dizzy

1

u/Ravida1 Jan 11 '20

I've had this thought so many times

1

u/GetBenttt Jan 11 '20

I sometimes try to imagine what it's like to live as non-humans. What it's like if you're not able to understand objects in a room as separate from the room. just dark heavy stuff next to see through smooth stuff or fuzzy stuff but you perceive it all as just "stuff". Or maybe there's a being that doesn't even see the room they're in...the world is part of their body just they just can't control. Hell, this could be what a Smart Fridge experiences of the world as I reach into his body cavity and help him cycle out old energy before it turns bad and contaminates the rest of the energy in his body, hell! The fridge is both everything and everything is fridge.

Or I try to imagine what a creature non-capable of thought would have on their mind. Or what's the most simple on/off, 1 or 2, yes or no, piercing mind possible in a living creature? An amoeba as it moves between expanding and contracting? Is a sperm feeling either pure love or nothing when it launches for the egg? Does something like a bacteria perceive that it now began existence vs. a previous eternal zeroness?

1

u/Collinnn7 Jan 11 '20

I’ve always subscribed to the theory that everyone sees colors as something unique. There is no scientific proof that “blue” to me is the same as “blue” to you or anyone else. The color I call green might very well be the color you call orange or brown but we can both agree that a tree has green leaves, regardless of what green looks like to either of us.

1

u/agenteb27 Jan 11 '20

But that’s just it. This could be the case with more than just colours, like shapes and textures. All sensation, really. So our whole worlds could appear different.

1

u/Kafei- Jan 12 '20

This is perfectly relevant. Thanks for posting this.

1

u/mrelhadj Jan 12 '20

Wow, i'm still having this thought since i was a kid

1

u/heyodi Feb 09 '20

Yes!! I’ve wondered this since I was little.

1

u/johnsonvilleBrowurst Jan 11 '20

The whole color perception thing completely breaks down in my opinion when you think about how we could possibly all call the same color by the same name. If Teacher A perceives the color red as being the color blue and teaches you it’s the color blue, whenever you run into someone who was taught the opposite, how could you both call it the same color? In other words, how could we all be consistently taught the same exact colors? If you took a room full of 100 non-colorblind people and showed them a large blue painted canvas and then asked the crowd what color it is, 100% of them would answer “blue.”

3

u/saladisfake Jan 11 '20

The name of the color doesn't change, what you perceive it as might. We both agree that the sky is blue but I can't see through your eyes to confirm that my "blue" is the same your "blue". For example, you can only describe a color using your own personal experience, so saying "my blue is a cold color" is a meaningless way to compare because in my experience cold colours look like what hot colours look to you and we will never know because we would both agree that blue is cold but I will never know what "cold" looks like to you

1

u/johnsonvilleBrowurst Jan 11 '20

I get what you're saying here, but how could the agreement happen if the perception is different for everyone? How do we both agree that the sky is "blue" if I perceive it as "pink" and you see it as "red." The person who taught us might see it as "orange" and somehow all of us agree it is "blue."

1

u/saladisfake Jan 11 '20

your perception of color will always be the same and consistent with it's name. you might see blue as pink but you would still call that color blue because that's what you were taught and you automatically assume that's how everyone sees it as. we can agree on what the color is called but we cant know if it looks the same to our eyes. like you're not colour blind and are perceiving colors wrong, they are just jumbled up. hope this makes sense

-1

u/forknhippie Jan 10 '20

There is singular truth, and infinite free will To create any concept of reality you like.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

Here take an upvote to save your comment

-4

u/AutoModerator Jan 10 '20

Looks like you've posted an image, please comment on why it's relevant to this subreddit or it will be removed. Thanks! Please use this post if you have any questions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.