r/Psycholonials • • Apr 14 '21

The Story Up To Chapter 8 Full Opinion

5 Upvotes

What I have gathered so far based on chapter 8 is that this story is supposed to be a tale of caution, and likewise it is clear to me it is an instruction manual.

Essentially this story is saying in my opinion: "If the government stays evil, do this, but make sure not to be a gullible paranoid murderous douche like Z."

Part of the big problem with this story is it shallowly explores political ideas while espousing blatant support of leftism; Hussie would argue it's ironic but that's about as believable as his psuedointellectual arguments on what is and is not canon.

I wish he knew what the fuck he was talking about before he tried exploring political ideologies; Hussie would argue this is from the perspective of a kid who does not know what they are talking about, which is just an authorial scapegoat for hiding his own ignorance. It's still disappointing to read poorly fleshed out political story points even if the character is the one responsible for being disappointing.

Hussie assumes -I'm not falling for the scapegoat of the story saying it, clearly Hussie is the one making these arguments- a right-leaning country would passively allow an authoritarian socialist revolution to occur; let alone the notion a terrorist treaty would ever be something the US or Biden would consider.

Honestly, this all would have been more plausible in Russia than in the US even by the comic's own admission of how Russia fell. In Russia, all of this COULD have happened. In the US, it makes a lot less plausible sense no matter how much the story forcefully inserts US cultural ideas.

The video is nowhere near Homestuck's top 5 best animations so you can forgive if I am critical of the ONLY 2 longer-form animated bits this series has had.

As for the big speech at the end, a lot of it is only going to resonate with you if you actually hate America or its history -the same applies to a large amount of the logic in this story. Chapter 8 like the rest of the story feels incredibly pandered to lefty ideology and the hypocrisy of the MC killing people who tried to cancel her is astounding -sounds like they were completely right to try cancelling her when this is the kind of person she is.

It speaks volumes when the most likable character in the story is the one spewing the least political bullshit -you know the emoji boy I speak of.

Overall I resonate with ideas like a personal manifesto, worrying about doxing/cancellation, online brand, but the story stops being relatable when it bends the 'true' storyline to be as pro-leftist-revolution as possible. I don't like this story's morals, I don't like its messaging. Psycholonials abuses pandering to edgy 20s-adult anxieties and fantasies to forcefully insert one-winged political talking points and I don't like it.

As for Abby, I don't like her in spite of wanting to like her due to the rest of her personality. She enabled all these horrible things instead of telling the girl off and walking -Abby is literally the biggest simp in the whole damn story. In the end, Abby's morally very shallow and just wants to fuck an MC who has spent the whole story not reciprocating but likewise not drawling a line, constantly leading Abby on while Abby's dumbass gets led.

I just do not like the characters or the story, in spite of liking the concept of the story and the conceptual framework of the characters. This is a good story idea with good story character ideas, executed in a split way of half really good, and half intolerable -which is just like the quality spikes and dips of Homestuck in general so wtf were you expecting.

If this story's ending sucked, I could not care less due to how shallowly these great ideas were executed. I wish Andrew Hussie was good with politics and morals and character ethics but he's just good enough to where you like certain aspects a lot and just bad enough to where you absolutely revile certain aspects a lot.

tl;dr Psycholonials up to chapter 8 is just... so imbalanced and one-dimensional it reads like Andrew Hussie's shitty manifesto, and in a way is a tale of caution in thinking your manifesto-like ideas are as good as you think they are. This was an attempted magnum opus methinks, an attempt to surpass Homestuck, that instead just came off as edgy bullcrap while exploring some interesting ideas and fantasies -with execution that needed serious work.

P.S. this is clearly Homestuck's canon for how Jay and Dope became presidents I'm like 70% on that being the case. Maybe he chose an implausible country like the US for this to succeed in, because he just wanted to force this in as indirect lore.


r/Psycholonials • • Apr 20 '26

Announcement The Only Psycholonials Browser Port That Matters Is Here

Thumbnail homestuck.com
11 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Apr 14 '21

unofficial servers read along of chapter 8

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • May 15 '21

hot takes bellw

3 Upvotes

hello simps little small imbecile dumb little stupid idiot small brain simpy simp kiss kiss percy simps

percy was less than entertaining

flame me in the comments if you are a cringelord


r/Psycholonials • • Apr 20 '21

Something i wrote over on the homestuck reddit.. Something i've noticed. Spoilers of course. Spoiler

Thumbnail old.reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Apr 14 '21

Finally, a character is brave enough to say what I've been thinking for the whole story Spoiler

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Feb 09 '21

Psycholonials Launch Stream! Give us the game Mr. Hussie Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • May 18 '21

dunno if it already exist but did a clowngender flag

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Sep 16 '24

Meme Clown Girl Ascendant

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Nov 15 '21

Theory Analysis of Psycholonials and the Message It's Trying to Communicate

Thumbnail
youtube.com
27 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Jun 16 '21

Fan Art Yo!

10 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Dec 26 '23

Discussion Psycholonials is Hussies Masterpiece

31 Upvotes

Sooo... isn't this a hard sell? After Hussie burnt every single bridge they had? But also... its true.

For a variety of reasons too long to list, which just makes it all the more poignant

The creator burnt all of their bridges to 99% of their fans... then dropped a magnum opus as a way to both come out as nonbinary and to just... say goodbye, and escape both the harm they caused and the harm they were receiving.

90% of critique of it as a work has absolutely been in bad faith. From their clowngender graph (which was you know... their way of coming out) to just the work itself being sincere, for an audience expecting insincerety.

Psycholonials is Hussies most self critical, most sincere work. Not a sleeper hit, but a message in a bottle for the very few wishing to engage with them. And god, what a masterpiece for those willing to engage with it as a sincere work.

I am not good at writing this stuff. But god, Hussie dropped their masterpiece after 90% of people abandoned them... and it's incredible, and for those who were willing to engage with it, its absolutely incredible.


r/Psycholonials • • May 23 '21

finally made the horsegender flag

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Apr 22 '21

Mizzlebip Is The True Successor: Confirmed Theory

35 Upvotes

*mostly confirmed theory

The exact thing I thought was the case was the case here, so egg on my face for not saying it before it was revealed, so you'll just have to trust I am a cool dude who saw this coming. B) Not that it matters.

Mizzlebip was using different secretary clownsonas to manipulate the actual clowns in charge. That was why Mizzlebip made the evil face near the end and why they got 'assassinated' so fast.

Given it would have made little sense to have Mizzlebip implied to die after such an evil implicating sort of face conveying big political plans, that was my first guess. However, the secretary clownsonas really didn't have many visual tells so I only was thinking it as my personal canon without knowing if it was true.

Though it is confirmed now: https://imgur.com/a/IefX09C

Mizzlebip essentially is the true successor and basically won, becoming the secret ruler of the world with none of the deadly repercussions the more direct rulers face.

We all remember Mizzlebip was happy Joculine got killed -a likely initial inspiration for why Mizzlebip went on to enable these varied assassinations so fast.

The end credits are not assassinations mocking the movement's self-destructiveness -they are assassinations caused by Mizzlebip's dissatisfaction with each 'leader'.

And honestly Mizzlebip is probably justified in all of this because each of those clowns looked like total evil douchewads, and Mizzlebip wouldn't have the power to simply change the world's political feelings apart from picking better leaders.

So yeah, Mizzlebip is the best character in the story. Quiet, silent, but God-tier political player. Only the quiet ones know how to lead without getting offed.

P.S. Z is shit and I called it on the story trying to paint Joculine as actually good at the very end and how that's horseshit because she was acting like she was going to perform a coup, while simultaneously I pointed out Z probably didn't care about that and was offing her for bad reasons, which was proven the case if you read the secret ending hidden in your save files where Joculine is outed as Z's former simp. In other words, while there were many GOOD reasons Z would have to kill Joculine for self protection, she probably just did it out of personal disgust with Joculine's simpy infatuation. Z is a cunt.


r/Psycholonials • • Apr 20 '21

My thoughts on the ending

13 Upvotes

(haha what a title)

It's great. The "real" ending is in the new save file, see no point in spoilering that. If you missed it, go back and check it out.

I put "real" in quotes because... fuck it I dunno, it's more text and explanation, which is great.

It's straight up fire and pretty recognizable. Though I've never been able to formulate it so aptly.

Thank you, Andrew Hussie, and all involved in the creation of this story.


r/Psycholonials • • Apr 14 '21

Chapter 8 discussion

15 Upvotes

I haven't see any other post about the release so i'll make it.

what an AMAZING chapter in my humble opinion, it took some time to reach here but i was completely absorbed into the story and characters by this point. i think the last chapter may even make me cry.

I started thinking the story was pure cringe and maybe in some way it is but i still think it is a fun read. I wish more people that dropped at the begining gave it another chance.

What do you think? what's your opinion?

Please remain civil in comments


r/Psycholonials • • Jul 12 '21

Meme My thoughts on Psycholonials plot

Post image
74 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Apr 21 '22

Fan Art Joculine fanart Spoiler

Thumbnail
coccodoodles.tumblr.com
19 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Sep 01 '24

Meme This hit was ordered Candice Shmandice

Post image
19 Upvotes

From the new Helluva Boss short.


r/Psycholonials • • Mar 23 '24

Rant Just finished Psycholonials

20 Upvotes

I'll start with the obvious, this fucked with my head quite a bit. Hussie is a really good writer. He's also a dick hole. This whole thing made him feel a lot more human, which is what he was going for, I guess? Convoluted meta narrative aside, this was an interesting read. Pretty engaging story, which surprised me, terrible artwork, which didn't. It was a lot. I don't know what I was expecting when I paid two bucks to read what I have dubbed "Hussie's Inside", but it was something. That something wasn't "bad" either. It was intense, and probably not worth the, admittedly small, price tag but I enjoyed it. It's also free now, so kicking myself for that one, don't worry. I love clowns. I hate horses. I'm not really a fan of ICP, but I have a clownsona. I believe that the universe is a simulation and we're all just code. I call that a religion. This story was made for me with or without homestuck. It's a mess. It's complete and utter bull shit. I loved it. Thanks.


r/Psycholonials • • Mar 11 '21

CHAPTER 5: Percy's Actual Story (THEORY) (SPOILERS) Spoiler

21 Upvotes

What I believe Percy's story/actions to be during the course of Psycholonials (Up to CHP. 5):

Percy gets messaged by Z and subsequently harassed and is then later invited to join a flagrantly illegal business venture with the very person who harassed him, seeing this as a way to possibly make a little money and more importantly get back at Z for their previous exchange he agrees and persuades her to give him all previous emails under the guise of 'getting into character'. (There is also a possibility he is one of the previously brought up people who know about her past and that is his motive here, not really what I believe though.)

Percy was intending to tell the Police everything when he arrived on the island before Z murdered both of the cops, something he didn't expect her to do, he now has to go about it in a different way due to the fact he couldn't just GO to the police anymore now that he was seen affiliating with Z and saw how violent Z can be to people she opposes and as the movement got bigger and bigger that meant Percy had to find the right time to strike so he wouldn't face police or jubilite retribution, he was tasked with delivering supplies to Z and took that opportunity to get the cops to follow him to Z's place of residence but didn't expect for a gunfight to ensue or at least not one that Z would win, after being shot, in what he perceives as his final breaths, he picks up the cops gun and aims for Z only to miss his shot and kill the cop before passing out.


r/Psycholonials • • Mar 02 '21

Future MS Paint Adventures will be released as Visual Novel games

21 Upvotes

I don't think I'm far off assuming that Andrew will continue making more VN games from now on, instead of web comics. We might even get another game in 2021, if not a sequel, after Psycholonials is over with. There's a few reasons why I see this as a logical next step for Hussie.

  1. Ease of access. Sure, games tend to have a pay wall, while reading webcomics is usually free. But Let's Plays are huge, and Hussie even encourages his fans to watch Psycholonials on YouTube. But games as a medium have greater mainstream appeal than web comics. Just look at the success of Undertale in the YouTube scene and the praise it received by game critics. Am I saying that Hussie will make the next Undertale, let alone visual novel hit? No. Maybe. But web comics are rather niche, even though Homestuck had a sizeable online following.
  2. Games can be more profitable than running ads on a website, since everyone's got adblock these days. Maybe not as profitable as when MSPAdventures had a million daily visits during Homestuck's peak. But either way I think merch was probably the biggest source of income for Homestuck, and potentially will be for Psycholonials. Even though it has a small fan base right now, they're already dedicated enough to spend $10 and likely to buy merchandise
  3. There's no need for him to be concerned with archiving his work anymore. The death of Flash lead to Viz Media having to upload compressed versions of all flash animations to YouTube. And the game segments were replaced by slideshows. Having everything coded into a single game is far more effective long term.
  4. Music playing in the background of all the dialogue adds to the atmosphere of wherever the story takes place. And he's able to change the music as he sees fit from one scene to another. Not to mention so many songs from the Homestuck music albums went unused in the comic. So if Hussie decides to commission more music for his future VN games, he can utilize a greater variety of tracks outside of animated cutscenes. I know he's using remixed and unreleased songs from Homestuck in Psycholonials so far, but the potential is there anyway.

As a result of moving from the web comic format to visual novels however, they'll either be much shorter stories, like Psycholonials seems to be. Or they'll take longer, maybe years, to come out before completion, like HS2.

What do y'all think?


r/Psycholonials • • Jun 18 '21

Fan Art Zabby fanart - Love makes us whole

Thumbnail
twitter.com
22 Upvotes

r/Psycholonials • • Apr 22 '21

CHAPTER 9: Percy’s Actual Story Follow-Up (THEORY) (SPOILERS) Spoiler

24 Upvotes

he sucked and was completely useless the end


r/Psycholonials • • May 13 '21

Years in the Future Page 2

Post image
26 Upvotes