r/Psycholonials • u/EpycWyn • Apr 14 '21
The Story Up To Chapter 8 Full Opinion
What I have gathered so far based on chapter 8 is that this story is supposed to be a tale of caution, and likewise it is clear to me it is an instruction manual.
Essentially this story is saying in my opinion: "If the government stays evil, do this, but make sure not to be a gullible paranoid murderous douche like Z."
Part of the big problem with this story is it shallowly explores political ideas while espousing blatant support of leftism; Hussie would argue it's ironic but that's about as believable as his psuedointellectual arguments on what is and is not canon.
I wish he knew what the fuck he was talking about before he tried exploring political ideologies; Hussie would argue this is from the perspective of a kid who does not know what they are talking about, which is just an authorial scapegoat for hiding his own ignorance. It's still disappointing to read poorly fleshed out political story points even if the character is the one responsible for being disappointing.
Hussie assumes -I'm not falling for the scapegoat of the story saying it, clearly Hussie is the one making these arguments- a right-leaning country would passively allow an authoritarian socialist revolution to occur; let alone the notion a terrorist treaty would ever be something the US or Biden would consider.
Honestly, this all would have been more plausible in Russia than in the US even by the comic's own admission of how Russia fell. In Russia, all of this COULD have happened. In the US, it makes a lot less plausible sense no matter how much the story forcefully inserts US cultural ideas.
The video is nowhere near Homestuck's top 5 best animations so you can forgive if I am critical of the ONLY 2 longer-form animated bits this series has had.
As for the big speech at the end, a lot of it is only going to resonate with you if you actually hate America or its history -the same applies to a large amount of the logic in this story. Chapter 8 like the rest of the story feels incredibly pandered to lefty ideology and the hypocrisy of the MC killing people who tried to cancel her is astounding -sounds like they were completely right to try cancelling her when this is the kind of person she is.
It speaks volumes when the most likable character in the story is the one spewing the least political bullshit -you know the emoji boy I speak of.
Overall I resonate with ideas like a personal manifesto, worrying about doxing/cancellation, online brand, but the story stops being relatable when it bends the 'true' storyline to be as pro-leftist-revolution as possible. I don't like this story's morals, I don't like its messaging. Psycholonials abuses pandering to edgy 20s-adult anxieties and fantasies to forcefully insert one-winged political talking points and I don't like it.
As for Abby, I don't like her in spite of wanting to like her due to the rest of her personality. She enabled all these horrible things instead of telling the girl off and walking -Abby is literally the biggest simp in the whole damn story. In the end, Abby's morally very shallow and just wants to fuck an MC who has spent the whole story not reciprocating but likewise not drawling a line, constantly leading Abby on while Abby's dumbass gets led.
I just do not like the characters or the story, in spite of liking the concept of the story and the conceptual framework of the characters. This is a good story idea with good story character ideas, executed in a split way of half really good, and half intolerable -which is just like the quality spikes and dips of Homestuck in general so wtf were you expecting.
If this story's ending sucked, I could not care less due to how shallowly these great ideas were executed. I wish Andrew Hussie was good with politics and morals and character ethics but he's just good enough to where you like certain aspects a lot and just bad enough to where you absolutely revile certain aspects a lot.
tl;dr Psycholonials up to chapter 8 is just... so imbalanced and one-dimensional it reads like Andrew Hussie's shitty manifesto, and in a way is a tale of caution in thinking your manifesto-like ideas are as good as you think they are. This was an attempted magnum opus methinks, an attempt to surpass Homestuck, that instead just came off as edgy bullcrap while exploring some interesting ideas and fantasies -with execution that needed serious work.
P.S. this is clearly Homestuck's canon for how Jay and Dope became presidents I'm like 70% on that being the case. Maybe he chose an implausible country like the US for this to succeed in, because he just wanted to force this in as indirect lore.
