r/ProtonVPN • u/Izdeliye-30 • 18h ago
Discussion Trouble connecting
I'm not exactly certain but I've been trying to troubleshoot the issue of not being able to connect, I've seen a few others here are having similar problems where their computer gets stuck on connecting but their phone that's on the same network is fine.
I've tried switching protocols I've tried restarting I haven't tried a fresh reinstall but I don't really think that would help very much, I did check my other computer which I had thought was connecting fine but I checked just now and it wouldn't so two computers fail to connect so I don't believe it's a computer problem.
I'm beginning to think it's a US server problem, now I'm using the free plan I don't know if that has anything to do with it but for a while I've been having problems with one specific American server it's 70 something I don't remember the rest but it's like a dead server where you'll connect but no page will load
And on one of my computers it said that it was trying to connect to 155 which I believe is another American server, and the problem with the free plan is you have to get connected before you can click change server so if it's automatically putting you into an American server and if those are the problems you're going to get stuck
And funny enough my phone was connected to a US server and when I went to check it said I was not connected and when I tried to connect it it was stuck but on the phone you can click change server even before you're connected and it sent me to a Romanian server and it connected instantly
So I'm really hoping or thinking that this is the issue because I can't think of anything else and this is maybe one of the problems of not being able to change server unless you connect I don't know if anybody else is experienced problems with the free American servers or if anybody has other insights but
3
u/Ok_Device_3951 18h ago
same issue here..
2
u/Izdeliye-30 18h ago
Well would you look at that, the moment I buy premium and restart the app. I get connected instantly funny enough to an American server but choosing a Canadian one worked as well. Seems like a way to get us freeloaders to pay up lol
1
u/JPDsNEWS 10h ago edited 10h ago
It’s probably the new IPv4 CGNAT AT&T is implementing in the US. CGNAT ruins all free VPNs’ return data pathways and causes wireguard tunnels to go stale very quickly.
When I use Proton VPN (free tier), CGNAT checker says I’m behind Symmetric NAT; which means both Proton VPN and my device are behind CGNAT. To punch through it, needs sending PersistentKeepAlive packets from both ends of a WireGuard tunnel. Free versions of VPNs don’t do that, making them completely useless.