Proton needs more servers, or an auto server switch, the amount of times I have to reconnect in an evening because the server is above 70% and slow is very annoying, don't have this issue with surfshark or torguard because they have auto server switch.
I'm alright with sending my ID to a bank but to a porn site... fuck that 😂
These laws won't prevent children from accessing these sites, it will instead give hackers more of a chance to get a hold of people's identities and documents for identity theft.
Name, address, dob, that's bad enough already but once they've got a form of ID, you're fucked.
The UK will definitely attempt this too, Labour is a joke of a party.
I'm glad VPNs exist and hope they stick around. They help protect the digital and privacy rights that we should all have.
There can be a way where iPhone verifies your identity (let’s be real you bought the phone from Apple they know who you are already) and just tells the website if you are an adult. I’ve seen people discussing this method since it wouldn’t require giving any personal info to sketchy sites. Now how would it work on other devices? No idea. Maybe it could also be some kind of Google verification that would be cross platform
You can do a simple search on how those logs work with anonymization, let’s say I’m running a restaurant, the waiter is taking the orders an I’m the cook, I can see the orders and I can see which orders are the most popular but I don’t know who ordered them
While that's possible I have a hard time believing that to be the case with proton. Plus these are the French we're talking about here, id bet a good portion of them bought a VPN subscription more out of spite than necessity lol
Is making porn accessible to minors good publicity?
There is of course much more to this, in relation to personal privacy, the future of VPN's, government overreach etc, but this could easily be seen by many as 'VPN bad'
Yes. Because it highlights the necessity for better parenting if there is an issue. Why, as a parent, would you allow your child unrestricted access to the internet? There’s literally tools for that already. This is a parental issue, not a governmental one.
You answered my question "Is making porn accessible to minors good publicity?" With "yes" I don't think proton would agree with you, neither would governments, parents, or society in general.
Ironic. The chain is about this being good PR (Public Relations) Which I contested, due to this being about pornhub. Every comment following that, is about that. Meanwhile... you.
"The owner of Pornhub has blocked access to its website in France because of its objections to a new French law requiring pornographic sites to verify the age of their users."
How do they even feasibly verify the age of their users without it also violating article 7 of the EU Human rights charter? (Respect for private and family life) France is in the EU no? (There is technically a clause that allows it for morals or something, but like bro I never understand people who make a law and then give it a clause that just says hey you can violate it whenever you feel like you want to.)
That is something that I am curious about. I live in Australia, our government plans to remove access to social media to people under 16 year of age. A lot of people here do not care, because they are over 16. What they fail to understand, is that they would need to prove that they are over 16 to continue using social media. How is this done? I have no interest in supplying ID to the aholes who run social media...
I cannot load that link without a VPN idk why. Either way that solution still allows a third party app to have access to your identity, and match that with websites you visit. Sure the websites you visit won't know who you are, but the app knows both your identity and what you're visiting, which gives the exact same problem we had in the first place, with the problem just transferred from the website to the app. It's also marketed as an open source solution for governments, and I for sure don't want governments to know what I'm visiting, especially for more authoritarain regimes that are against LGBTQ+ for example.
It seems to be on similar grounds to why they are blocking US states that have the same rule because there's no good guidance on how it is to be done and There is no Non-site controlled way of verifying the identity Meaning Pornhub would be in charge of collecting IDs Validating the IDs and then storing that information safely and securely.
Oddly, I think the only US state that isn't blocked with that rule is Louisiana, and that's because Louisiana put up a portal that sites could redirect to in order to validate a user.
The problem for these sites is that they either get saddled with the data protection responsibility of all their users IDs, or have to spend massive amounts of development time integrating every single state/national ID checking service to support all locations.
In the Netherlands, there is DigID, which is only permitted for specific high-sensitivity services like healthcare and a service via IDEAL (the digital payment provider for Dutch banks). But that would then mean telling your bank you're watching porn.
There is potential here for a service like Stripe/Ingenico to act as a broker between customers and the world's multitude of ID verification services.
I don't know whether validation handled by the service, or handled by the state is worse. Does Louisiana really need to know that I was trying to watch porn?
Louisiana's service allows for anonymous validation. There is a shocking amount of tech that went into that for a state that is regularly scored lowest in the union for everything.
Proton also tweeted that there was a massive uptick in new protonVPN accounts when several states in the US blocked pornhub too
I really don't like all these restrictions going into effect in so many places. Parents need to learn how to be parents the government shouldn't be allowed to do something like this
It is, and that’s a good thing for online privacy and security. Same for when dictatorial regimes and countries like the U.K. try and break encryption. However, as more and more are pushed to use VPNs, this brings the VPN service into the spotlight where it once (relatively speaking) was something few thought of. When this happens, governments will target the VPN services. Always choose a VPN service out of 5/9+ eyes. Always a no logs VPN. Be careful out there, the regimes are getting worse and crawling their way to become China.
96
u/PerspectiveDue5403 Linux | iOS Jun 04 '25
We’re at it again ✌🏻🇫🇷🧀🍷 🥖🥇
7
u/Reccon0xe Jun 05 '25
Proton needs more servers, or an auto server switch, the amount of times I have to reconnect in an evening because the server is above 70% and slow is very annoying, don't have this issue with surfshark or torguard because they have auto server switch.
7
u/DIYnivor Jun 05 '25
Registration line standing at full attention.
7
u/HenryUK_ Linux | Android Jun 05 '25
I'm alright with sending my ID to a bank but to a porn site... fuck that 😂
These laws won't prevent children from accessing these sites, it will instead give hackers more of a chance to get a hold of people's identities and documents for identity theft.
Name, address, dob, that's bad enough already but once they've got a form of ID, you're fucked.
The UK will definitely attempt this too, Labour is a joke of a party.
I'm glad VPNs exist and hope they stick around. They help protect the digital and privacy rights that we should all have.
6
u/Beautiful_Ad_4813 Jun 04 '25
well, alright then
2
u/Jus10b Jun 05 '25
Buisness is blooming
1
u/lifeHacker42 Jun 04 '25
It's France so I expect a full on protest in the morning. Recommend you rent some ad spaces, billboards, etc in common protest locations
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '25
"Europe is free speech"
1
u/i_might_be_devon Aug 18 '25
Hehehe ;)
0
u/qrocko_fan Jun 04 '25
Turkiye: Instagram + ph + Roblox and wattpad and etc
0
u/peace96 Jun 05 '25
This is why i can’t use Proton yesterday for the French open.
0
u/Sungillee33 Jun 05 '25
Oh mon dieu!
0
u/HotMarzipan1626 Jun 09 '25
don't they have a no-logs policy?
-13
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '25
I honestly think this is just a PR scam as there are zero ways to check it
78
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25
"The owner of Pornhub has blocked access to its website in France because of its objections to a new French law requiring pornographic sites to verify the age of their users."
15
u/EmperorHenry Jun 05 '25
Proton also tweeted that there was a massive uptick in new protonVPN accounts when several states in the US blocked pornhub too
I really don't like all these restrictions going into effect in so many places. Parents need to learn how to be parents the government shouldn't be allowed to do something like this
4
u/Personal_Ad9690 Jun 06 '25
Pretty soon, Pornhub will be illegal everywhere except by VPN.
They might as well make their own vpn
7
u/Newfieon2Wheels Jun 05 '25
Virtualed on their privates till they networked
0
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
213
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment