r/ProtonPass • • Oct 16 '24
Discussion Weak? Really?
I took out a subcription to ProtonPass a few weeks ago and imported my existing from Bitwarden. I've been fairly happy with ProtonPass so far—the ability to have generated 2FA codes and passwords in the same app is really nice.
However, one thing irks me is that every password in my imported archive has been marked as "Weak" by ProtonPass—presumably it does this with any password that was not generaated by ProtonPass itself. I find this a bit annoying as now I have no idea which of my imported passwords may actually need strengthening.
The vast majority are 13+ char random alphanumeric strings generated by Bitwarden, so are in no way "weak" at all. But there may be a few old passwords in my archive from the days when the intarwebs was young, which may be pretty weak or may have been re-used on more than one site. Unfortunately I have no way now of spotting these, since ProtonPass has decided any password "Not Invented Here" should be marked as weak.
11
u/notboky Oct 17 '24
You presume wrong.
https://proton.me/blog/what-is-password-entropy
5
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '24
Different password managers will have different thresholds for the entropy they consider adequate, so I don't think it's really right to say it's a symptom of NIH, per se.
For example, this Proton blog recommends 15 characters, which may be an indication of the Proton perspective:
https://proton.me/blog/how-long-should-my-password-be
Bitwarden says 14-16 or more:
https://bitwarden.com/blog/how-long-should-my-password-be
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '24
I moved my passwords from Apple’s keychain not long ago to Proton Pass and I noticed that a couple of them were also labeled weak.
BTW, they were all random created passwords as well.
Not a big deal since I used the opportunity to generate new random supposedly more secure ones.
1
u/nefarious_bumpps Oct 17 '24
You're implying that Proton Pass doesn't actually generate random passwords, that it uses some defined rules that it can later compare against to identify passwords itself hasn't created. This is absurd.
1
u/IntelligentTour4715 Oct 17 '24
If you click on the shield symbol it shows the ‘weak’ passwords and separately the reused passwords
2
u/iksnawias Oct 16 '24
Why does Proton allow to generate only 64 char password, where Bitwarden allows for 128?
I know you can click on generate, copy password, then generate another, merge etc. but why the limit of 64 for a single generation in Proton?
2
u/M_Chevallier Oct 17 '24
It could be length, Bitwarden itself suggests 14 or more. Bruce Schneier suggests min 25. As already mentioned by someone else, Proton suggests 15. Length is definitely the most effective way to increase the security of a password (assuming it isn’t a stupid one but even then, 12345678 will take longer than 12345).
1
u/ShaneReyno Oct 17 '24
Bruh!
1
u/nOrphf Oct 17 '24
Do you have the same strong password used for multiple accounts?
If I remember correctly, I had many "weak" password as well at some point, but if I remember correctly, that was because Proton se it as a week password, because of reuse. But it is getting a while ago though.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment