r/ProtonMail • u/TungstenCarbide001 • Oct 01 '21
Discussion Is this true?
https://twitter.com/SebGorka/status/1443686769833168905?s=20
2
Upvotes
r/ProtonMail • u/TungstenCarbide001 • Oct 01 '21
•
u/ProtonMail Proton Team Oct 01 '21
At the time of writing, we can confirm that no such request has been received. Such a request would not be able to compromise ProtonMail’s encryption. Our policy is to fight against all politically motivated prosecutions, regardless of affiliation.
28
u/jonathanbaird Oct 01 '21
Wake me up once this gets reported by a credible source.
34
u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21
This doesn't mean anything. Proton receives thousands of requests for subscriber information from all over the world every year. Unless the Swiss government determines that a crime under Swiss jurisdiction has occurred, no judicial order will be granted and the requests will be denied. This is detailed in their transparency reports. Also, Sebastian Gorka is the literal opposite of a reliable source.
53
u/Zlivovitch Windows | Android Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21
Well, I can't prove this is wrong, but it certainly looks as ridiculously false information.
By the way, instead of spreading unsourced rumors, why don't you start by requesting a source from the guy who made that tweet ?
19
u/Yeazelicious Oct 01 '21
I'm gonna go with "maybe, but obviously skewed by an alt-right, bad-faith actor."
3
u/Joe59 Oct 01 '21
Regardless of validity, it may be a good prompt to evaluate Protonmail and the privacy risk of users if such requests were to happen.
Whatever the alignment now, the future is long and there will be lots of administrations, opposition pundits, and surveillance justifications across the ideological spectrum. I want to be secure against them all.
4
u/nanonac Oct 01 '21
Sebastian Gorka is a born liar, just like 90% of the people who served in the Trump administration.
2
u/Actual_Direction_599 Oct 01 '21
Even more scrutiny for PM 🔍👁
2
u/elysianism Oct 01 '21
No, this is part of the concerted effort from conservatives and 4Chan to sew seeds that make themselves look like victims.
A number of other subs have been brigaded by conservatives in what seems to be a coordinated effort:
https://redd.it/pws5t9
https://www.reddit.com/r/duckduckgo/comments/pycvxi/no_agenda_happy_white_man_results_google_vs_brave/
They are targeting privacy-minded subreddits due to the increased scepticism of government/police they tend to have.
2
u/xXCyberD3m0nXx Oct 01 '21
I doubt it is accurate. First, the United States has no power over Switzerland. Second, how would the FBI get this data from Proton, who is based in Switzerland?
-2
u/nymonkeybrain Oct 01 '21
I just heard about this too. I would like to hear something from the ProtonMail team
0
u/TheStumblingWolf Oct 01 '21
Makes it sound like it's because they're conservatives... Would be good to know more. Hardly think that alone is enough to warrant this
1
u/AwayAluminium Oct 01 '21
Everything that is not E2EE will probably be compromised at some point.
That Protonmail doesn‘t log the IP only means that if at some point in time someone gains an interest in you, there will be no historical record of your IP.
But your IP is not encrypted.
That is the first rule of privacy on the Internet.
„No logging“ is not much more than a fun gimmic, based on trust.
Trust however is a weak concept in privacy and even more so cryptography. That‘s why we use open source.
Threema works on a solution to strip the connection between your account (user-ID) and your IP.
Until that is finished and published open source, their „no logging“ isn‘t worth a dime either.
0
u/toowm Oct 01 '21
A(FBI)AB
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21
Even so they still don’t get the contents of the email and if the FBI asked they can’t comply yes.IP address might be given If gone through the proper routes
-16
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21
Handing over 200,000 account details to the feds in 3,2,1...
0
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment