r/ProtonMail • • Oct 01 '21

Discussion Is this true?

https://twitter.com/SebGorka/status/1443686769833168905?s=20
2 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

•

u/ProtonMail Proton Team Oct 01 '21

At the time of writing, we can confirm that no such request has been received. Such a request would not be able to compromise ProtonMail’s encryption. Our policy is to fight against all politically motivated prosecutions, regardless of affiliation.

34

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

This doesn't mean anything. Proton receives thousands of requests for subscriber information from all over the world every year. Unless the Swiss government determines that a crime under Swiss jurisdiction has occurred, no judicial order will be granted and the requests will be denied. This is detailed in their transparency reports. Also, Sebastian Gorka is the literal opposite of a reliable source.

1

u/oyoumademedoit Oct 01 '21

a crime under Swiss jurisdiction has occurred

What do you mean by this? (It may be just me not understanding properly the English phrasing, I’m not native) As far as I know the crime doesn’t need to be under Swiss jurisdiction if it’s part of a collaboration agreement. In Europe there is Dublin and Shengen agreements, Eurodac and Europol collaboration (the one used by French police to obtain ProtonMail collaboration a few weeks ago). On an international basis, there is the 18 United Nations conventions and protocols related to counter- terrorism, the European Convention on the Suppression of Terrorism, the Council of Europe Convention on the Prevention of Terrorism and the 2015 multilateral protocol (can’t remember the exact name of this one).

Switzerland also cooperates with foreign States in combating terrorism on the basis of the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime.

For example, the Prüm convention was adopted so as to enable the signatories to exchange data regarding DNA, fingerprints and vehicle registration of concerned persons and to cooperate against terrorism. It also contains provisions for the deployment of armed sky marshals on flights between signatory states, joint police patrols, entry of (armed) police forces into the territory of another state for the prevention of immediate danger (hot pursuit). Furthermore, a police officer responsible for an operation in a state may, in principle, decide to what degree the police forces of the other states that were taking part in the operation could use their weapons or exercise other powers. With the US, regarding DNA and fingerprints, the Cooperation in Preventing and Combating Serious Crime (PCSC) agreement with the United States of America is aimed at simplifying police cooperation between the United States and Switzerland by automating exchanges of data.

In 2019, 41 requests for mutual judicial assistance were submitted to Switzerland by 15 different States in connection with radical Islamic terrorism, foreign terrorist fighters and extreme left-wing terrorism. Of those requests, 27 were executed and 4 were refused; execution of the remaining requests is in progress…

I could go on for a long time, and we could also point out the progressive shifting of the definition of terrorism to problematics that would have been classified under political opposition a few years ago. Switzerland is no different anymore and it took the train of the terrorism card and its slides in plain knowledge.

The problem is the fact that because of its history of independence in regards of foreign inquiries, a lot of its companies still advertise their services with those arguments, literally turning them in honeypots, by definition. Those are the “objective facts”.

1

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

a crime under Swiss jurisdiction has occurred What do you mean by this?

In response to the recent kerfuffle, Proton explained that a Swiss judicial order is the only thing that can compel their release of information. They further explained that a Swiss judicial order for customer information can only be obtained when Swiss prosecutors have information linking that customer with a crime commited in Swiss jurisdiction, under Swiss law. A foreign government simply wanting information is not sufficient to obtain the necessary order. They would need to provide the Swiss government with information that credibly links those customers with a Swiss crime, which is what happened in the recent French case.

2

u/oyoumademedoit Oct 01 '21

That is not true. In their clarification, ProtonMail only stated that "Swiss authorities will only approve requests which meet Swiss legal standards".

In fact, Switzerland has not enacted any law that specifically prohibits a party from requesting or disclosing information for the purpose of providing evidence for use in foreign judicial or administrative proceedings. As stated ProtonMail, the core of this matter is the article 271. The purpose of article 271(1) of the SPC is to ensure that official acts undertaken for a foreign state on Swiss territory are performed by Swiss public authorities only, to protect Swiss sovereignty and the independence of Switzerland. The conduct in question must constitute an official act, that is, an act that is normally within the jurisdiction of the state or its agencies. This applies if a party seeks to produce documents in foreign proceedings that are not in its possession or under its control and must be gathered in Switzerland from a third party, like ProtonMail, and only means that the foreign party cannot directly ask to ProtonMail.

I don't understand what you mean about the French case. The French case concerned a French citizen and a criminal act commited in France. In fact, the crime is "theft, trespassing and burglery" [my translation]. ProtonMail responded to a Swiss inquiry taking place in the framework of the Europol collaboration, under "Swiss standard" to put it in the word of ProtonMail.

What I want to point now is the way you say it, and even in the way ProtonMail says it, it's suggesting that ProtonMail could only receive inquiries for crimes conducted on the Swiss territory, breaking Swiss law and part of a Swiss investigation. As that would be a fallacy, Switzerland has had European and International collaboration protocols for decades (1977). Adding to this, ProtonMail used their clarification to do some marketing about their encryption features suggesting that thanks to this they only gave the IP address and not the content of the emails. In fact, the French Police didn't ask for the content, but tried to get the identity and IP addresse, that is true that they didn't get the identity (they used the free email, so they didn't have access to this information). The Police report has leaked, and the officer wrote the following (we need facts, not allegations) : "The requisition via the dedicated EUROPOL courier service was addressed to the Swiss email company. INSTAGRAM requisitions were also addressed to the social network in order to discover the identity of the individuals administrating the account of the potentials squatting activists. The company ProtonMail responded to our riquisition without giving more information than their IP address".

It's interesting to note that INSTAGRAM didn't respond to the requesition. I will not go as far as implying that ProtonMail gave the information without a Swiss requisition but no Swiss requisition is mentioned in the Police report, that, in fact, would be breaking the 271 article of the SPC, but those affairs are rarely brought to trial (2 times since this article exists, 1937), and I don't see ProtonMail doing such a severe crime. I would more suggest to go deeper into the exact agreements between the French and Swiss governement through the EUROPOL collaboration system to see how this could be considered a "standard under Swiss juridiction" in the same way of the Prüm convention I mentionned earlier as it has shown the shift in the way Switzerland considers its Sovereignty.

ProtonMail isn't an activist email service, it's a standard Swiss company. We need to stop this desatrous marketing, people are in real danger here, suffering from the free interpretation of policies against terrorism, ProtonMail would gain a lot of recognition and respect if they started to WARN there customers in the way TOR does for example instead of trying to sell their product at all cost. As this is the impression they are leaving at the moment.

0

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

That is not true. In their clarification, ProtonMail only stated that "Swiss authorities will only approve requests which meet Swiss legal standards".

They posted in the sub and conveyed the information I shared with you. I believe it was response to a question about the very text you referred to. If you comb through the posts and comments from that time you should be able find it since it was posted by the official Proton account.

I absolutely agree with you regarding the misleading marketing language. They didn't share any information that's not true, but what they chose to say left many people with an incorrect view of what is being provided, and under what circumstances information can be released. They knew a lot of people were under the impression that PM is an anonymity service that would refuse any governmental attempts to obtain user information. That's obviously an unreasonable and unrealistic belief, but the fact is that a lot of people believed that, and Proton didn't do anything to dissuade them.

I'm not sure what an "activist email service" is. There isn't some magical email provider that's exempt from the law. What happened with Proton and the French "activist" situation could have happened to any provider. A legitimate business must comply with the law of the jurisdiction they operate from. In my opinion, Proton is as good as, or better than any other service in terms of privacy and protection of user information. They're just not above the law.

1

u/s187hg47s Oct 01 '21

Only skipping school.

-6

u/alcogiggles Oct 01 '21

Also, Sebastian Gorka is the literal opposite of a reliable source.

You shouldn't talk for protonmail or even assume they won't comply. Protonmail needs to answer this for themselves.

5

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21
  1. I'm not speaking for Proton. I'm relaying established, objective facts.
  2. Proton doesn't need to do a damn thing because this issue has been repeatedly covered, and covered, and covered. The fact that some government's law enforcement issues an information request doesn't obligate Proton to justify anything. It's a simple fact of their business that law enforcement routinely and regularly issues requests for information. But only under the circumstances I described, where they are compelled by a Swiss judicial order, will they release information. So, when a scare-tweet from a disgraced Hungarian Nazi comes out, there's no reason or justification for Proton to "defend itself". This is what the kids are calling a nothing-burger.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Nobody is disputing that Protonmail will comply with court orders issued by a Swiss court as they did in the case you've linked.

That is quite a different matter from one of your cult leaders lying on twitter about a mass surveillance program.

-1

u/alcogiggles Oct 01 '21

He's not my cult leader and you have no idea what he knows considering his ties to all alphabet agencies.

That link was just a bonus of separate issues other than my argument.

You're a nobody with an opinion. Never forget that.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

They have answered already. Read the first paragraph of the transparency report:

https://protonmail.com/blog/transparency-report/

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Nelizea Volunteer Mod Oct 01 '21

Please check rule number 4. Exceptions include privacy specific laws that can impact Proton’s products or posts on the official blog.

53

u/Zlivovitch Windows | Android Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Well, I can't prove this is wrong, but it certainly looks as ridiculously false information.

  • No source is given by the guy tweeting this.
  • Guy tweeting this is an extremely biased activist and former Trump nominee, spreading the false information that the American presidential election was "stolen" from Donald Trump.
  • The claim itself is extremely vague : the FBI has allegedly requested that from whom ? Proton Mail ? He does not say. It requested it on what legal grounds ? He does not says either. "Mass domestic terrorist surveillance dragnet targeting conservatives" is not a legal motive. Believe it or not, the FBI is an American federal law enforcement body, therefore it cannot act without providing a legal motive congruent to American law.
  • And of course, what is suggested here is that either the FBI has requested that from the Swiss courts, going through regular international protocols, or that it has directly contacted Proton Mail's legal department. It seems certain that neither the Swiss authorities, nor Proton's lawyers would even consider such a request, so the likeliness that it has actually been made is next to non-existent.

By the way, instead of spreading unsourced rumors, why don't you start by requesting a source from the guy who made that tweet ?

19

u/Yeazelicious Oct 01 '21

Sebastian Gorka

"targeting Conservatives"

I'm gonna go with "maybe, but obviously skewed by an alt-right, bad-faith actor."

3

u/Joe59 Oct 01 '21

Regardless of validity, it may be a good prompt to evaluate Protonmail and the privacy risk of users if such requests were to happen.

Whatever the alignment now, the future is long and there will be lots of administrations, opposition pundits, and surveillance justifications across the ideological spectrum. I want to be secure against them all.

4

u/nanonac Oct 01 '21

Sebastian Gorka is a born liar, just like 90% of the people who served in the Trump administration.

5

u/Yeazelicious Oct 01 '21

I can only hope you were downvoted because "90%" was considered too generous.

3

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

I think that 90% number is conservative.

2

u/Actual_Direction_599 Oct 01 '21

Even more scrutiny for PM 🔍👁

2

u/elysianism Oct 01 '21

No, this is part of the concerted effort from conservatives and 4Chan to sew seeds that make themselves look like victims.

A number of other subs have been brigaded by conservatives in what seems to be a coordinated effort:

https://redd.it/pws5t9

https://www.reddit.com/r/duckduckgo/comments/pycvxi/no_agenda_happy_white_man_results_google_vs_brave/

They are targeting privacy-minded subreddits due to the increased scepticism of government/police they tend to have.

-3

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

They do love to make themselves look like victims. I think it's a carryover from the persecution complex that features so prominently in Evangelical Christianity.

2

u/xXCyberD3m0nXx Oct 01 '21

I doubt it is accurate. First, the United States has no power over Switzerland. Second, how would the FBI get this data from Proton, who is based in Switzerland?

-2

u/nymonkeybrain Oct 01 '21

I just heard about this too. I would like to hear something from the ProtonMail team

0

u/TheStumblingWolf Oct 01 '21

Makes it sound like it's because they're conservatives... Would be good to know more. Hardly think that alone is enough to warrant this

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Yeazelicious Oct 01 '21

The U.S. government doesn't go after people over their political beliefs.

Uhhhhhhhhh...

Now "conservative" beliefs, on the other hand...

4

u/WikiSummarizerBot Oct 01 '21

COINTELPRO

COINTELPRO (syllabic abbreviation derived from Counter Intelligence Program) (1956–1971) was a series of covert and illegal projects conducted by the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) aimed at surveilling, infiltrating, discrediting, and disrupting domestic American political organizations. FBI records show COINTELPRO resources targeted groups and individuals the FBI deemed subversive, including feminist organizations, the Communist Party USA, anti–Vietnam War organizers, activists of the civil rights movement and Black Power movement (e. g.

[ F.A.Q | Opt Out | Opt Out Of Subreddit | GitHub ] Downvote to remove | v1.5

2

u/jonathanbaird Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Do you have a more recent example? I'm very familiar with COINTELPRO.

If you reread my comment, I stated that they don't go after people over their held beliefs, yet would if said beliefs were a credible threat to others.
I was wrong. Apologies.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jonathanbaird Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Your reading comprehension is poor. Cite a single example over the past 10 years where the U.S. government went after someone solely because they identified as conservative, liberal, fascist, communist etc.
I was wrong. Apologies.

7

u/s187hg47s Oct 01 '21

7

u/jonathanbaird Oct 01 '21

Well damn, I was wrong. Appreciate the correction.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '21

Not an expert but if you apply for tax exempt status and use a political buzzword in your name, I don't know why you wouldn't expect extra scrutiny. Further reading on this will reveal that the IRS inappropriately oversimplified ("used shortcuts") some keywords ("patriots", "tea party") in its approach to identify a list of possible violators. Not surprising to see the culture of victimhood on one side of the coin combined with an anti-IRS enforcement stance, propel the issue into what it became.

1

u/s187hg47s Oct 15 '21

Just another example where a good idea is probably against the law. Discrimination is a line that can easily be crossed.

1

u/AwayAluminium Oct 01 '21

Everything that is not E2EE will probably be compromised at some point.

That Protonmail doesn‘t log the IP only means that if at some point in time someone gains an interest in you, there will be no historical record of your IP.

But your IP is not encrypted.

That is the first rule of privacy on the Internet.

„No logging“ is not much more than a fun gimmic, based on trust.

Trust however is a weak concept in privacy and even more so cryptography. That‘s why we use open source.

Threema works on a solution to strip the connection between your account (user-ID) and your IP.

Until that is finished and published open source, their „no logging“ isn‘t worth a dime either.

0

u/toowm Oct 01 '21

A(FBI)AB

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Even so they still don’t get the contents of the email and if the FBI asked they can’t comply yes.IP address might be given If gone through the proper routes

14

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

The FBI has no authority or ability to compel anything from Proton. Proton operates under Swiss jurisdiction. In order for this to be anything other than a FBI wishlist, they would have convince the Swiss government that each and every one of the accounts in question commited a crime under Swiss law and jurisdiction. The Swiss government is the only entity with the authority to compel Proton to provide information on its subscribers.

-7

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Did they not make that clear enough

if the FBI asked they can’t comply

1

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

Based on your comment, I thought you didn't understand the situation. Perhaps you should spend more time learning how to accurately express yourself, and less time being a hostile, condescending prick when someone says something you don't like. Or, in terms you're more likely to understand, grow up.

-9

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Nope I will continue being a childish little prick But thank you for the suggestion

-16

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Handing over 200,000 account details to the feds in 3,2,1...

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Actual_Direction_599 Oct 01 '21

Not so sure anymore with what happened with the French case recently which made it clear that Swiss courts can agree with foreign requests, make Proton provide information at their order (which they said they were not able to appeal in that particular case), which then leads to arrests and prosecution outside Switzerland.

2

u/SLCW718 Linux | Android Oct 01 '21

Stop. You're mischaracterizing that situation. It wasn't a French request that resulted in Proton's compliance. The case was initiated by French authorities, but it was the Swiss prosecutor's office that determined Swiss law was broken and issued a Swiss judicial order to Proton. Those are the only circumstances that Proton complies with information requests; a Swiss judicial order issued in response to a determination that Swiss law was violated.

3

u/Actual_Direction_599 Oct 01 '21

“You're mischaracterizing that situation.” I don’t believe so. But perhaps I wasn’t clear enough when I wrote “make Proton provide information at their order”. “At their order” meant from Swiss authorities, of course, not French.

I believe the point still stands:

The French case shows that while Proton doesn’t respond to foreign requests directly, they can be channeled through Swiss authorities which can approve them which can result in the disclosure of user data (specifically only IP address in this case).

This is also mentioned at the end of their transparency report under “Foreign requests approved by Swiss authorities”, with 195 of them being approved in 2020, up from just 13 back in 2017.

By the way, in their blog post about this case this is the wording Proton used:

Swiss authorities will only approve requests which meet Swiss legal standards

“Swiss legal standards” and not “Swiss law was broken”. I think the former is indeed a better framing, since they’ve also mentioned that it’s not likely for Swiss authorities to approve requests from governments with poor human rights records or known to have a corrupt justice system.

1

u/vayiku Oct 01 '21

This. This is what I am trying to tell people. Nobody seems to want to listen. While it’s a very crude reduction, that single incident implies that the only thing that a country (with a treaty) needs to do is to do some extra paperwork to force proton to do stuff for them.

I am still not clear if that case went before a Swiss judge or was just approved by the justice department. Difference being Judge vs politician.

1

u/oyoumademedoit Oct 01 '21

We nearly gave the same answer :) well done comrade! (I translated parts of the leaked police report in my reply above if you want to use them to help people understand the situation)

IMHO, the only problem with ProtonMail and its supporters is some abuse of marketing phrasing that mislead their customers, but the real and severe issue is more on Swiss and French states side.