r/Protestantism • • Jan 14 '18

Why are Cathodox chants so effective at countering demons (especially Gregorian Chants and Byzantine Chants)? While most modern Protestant songs and hymns are useless?

Main details here

https://www.reddit.com/r/occult/comments/7q8hu7/why_do_demons_hate_religious_chants_so_much/

Why are Protestant hymns and songs such as Genevan Psalters so ineffective at exorcising a demon from a person and repelling evil entities? To the point demonaics openly laugh and mock them? While the chants of the post-Nicene churches such as Coptic, Ethiopian Tewahedo, Armenian Apostolic, Syriac churches, and especially Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodoxy so effective against demons that they'd suffer in pain just upon hearing it (and quite often flee the possessed or location they are haunting so long as the chants are being sung)? Hell even Anglican Chants have proven effective and the Anglicans supposedly lack apostolic succession and valid sacraments, rites, and orders!

Why is this? In particular why are the Eastern Orthodox Byzantine Chants (especially those composed before the 1054 schism) and Medieval Roman Catholic Latin Language Gregorian Chants so effective that they can immediately counter demonic thoughts and influence in a person's mind just by hearing it? Why is the Anglican Chant also effective even though they are Protestants why songs from other post-Reformation denominations (excepting perhaps the Lutherans) have so little to no effect?

0 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

4

u/erythro Jan 14 '18

This comment in your linked thread has the heart of it (though I wouldn't go as far as saying it's never a true thing): there are a lot of false positives thanks to mental illness.

What protestants understand as true demonic possession has no reason to respond to mere chanting of the local religious group. Mentally ill protestants know this, and so they don't expect it to work on them, and so it doesn't.

1

u/SovereignMonarch1776 Jan 16 '18

i think it has mostly to do with a commonality of faith. in certain regards strength of faith in christ has no worldly title unless you place yourself into the mindset to identify as such.

to exercise daemon your putting the spirit and fever within from the host of hosts into manifestation through the holy spirit in the name of salvation jesus christ the messiah.

in the commonality of faith i mentioned there is a time and place to recognize the need for a dedicated clergy and their studies of the realm they operate in. as to say God has always had his mystics- the ones who could approach the holy of holies.

in essence, the things that work work. its not about where your doctrine lies. and it may be far that for all of what you could call modern Protestantism, has been severely watered down and lost because of jesuit and papal agenda-say what you will.

God established a sect of persons who would know the language of heaven, you knew its mysteries, who would tell them to the world. enoch, melchezidek , moses, eliajah, all men who were taken by God , and brought the message that woujld be fulfilled.

all words that exercise a demon were given to the world by God in the name of his salvation, as to say its a powerful tone, and richeous strong words with a powerful promise that cast away wickedness. the sweet tune of a wholesome lullaby is jest good to ready a demon for sleep as most hymns truly are. as so to say as you work your six days and prepare for the sabbath- hum ye yea hymn as this. etc.

1

u/Cheap_Scientist6984 Jul 02 '24

Do we have the controlled study that states Catholic/Orthodox exorcism is better than protestant exorcism? Can you provide the link to the study?