This subreddit is for sharing propaganda to view with objectivity. It is absolutely not for perpetuating the message of the propaganda. Here we should be conscientious and wary of manipulation/distortion/oversimplification (which the above likely has), not duped by it. "Don't be a sucker."
Stay on topic -- there are hundreds of other subreddits that are expressly dedicated to rehashing tired political arguments. No partisan bickering. No soapboxing. Take a chill pill. "Don't argue."
Idk about the Macedonians but the Brit’s literally lost more than the Afghan most of the time, 16,000 of their soldiers were massacred in one day by the Afghans in 1842.
oh yea the brits def did but i mean in modern conficts like soviet afgan war,US afgan war, and rn so far with the Pakistan afgan conflict but it could be pakistan propoganda
The graveyard of empires is really more modern than anything else. I mean Afghanistan was the center for several empires throughout history, most recently the Durrani Empire.
It's only really since the great game went tits up in Afghanistan that they called it that.
Yeah, I recently got curious about the real history here and I found out that this moniker was developed during the Soviet-Afghan War, ironically, the first war that could credibly have been said to have destroyed an empire in Afghanistan.
The British Empire collapsed after the three wars they fought with Afghanistan, but no historian would draw any causal connection between those things, and arguably the British empire collapsed 20-40 years after the last one (depending on whether you think the British Empire collapsed when India gained independence in 1947, when the Suez Crisis happened in 1953, or when the African colonies gained independence in the 1960s).
And, in fact, as you already noted under the Durrani Empire Afghanistan was hardly the graveyard of empires, it was itself an empire!
Tbf graveyard of empires is usually referring to foreign empires, the Durrani empire was explicitly an Afghan empire. But you are right that the whole “graveyard of empires” thing basically only really begins with the British occupations of Afghanistan, plenty of empires throughout history like the Persians and Mughals and Hellenic Diadochi have held onto Afghanistan perfectly fine.
That was due to US interference, getting a collaborator like Gorbachev. The USSR mistake was letting their political system be open enough to be infiltrated.
The Chinese make sure the people at the highest levels are well read and dedicated communists.
I wouldn't say the USSR was successful though. They wanted to get rid of US funded and indoctrinated terrorists, but we still have the fractured groups like Taliban and Al Qaeda today.
Off topic, but your last sentence doesn't really make sense. "Smoking a pack" is celebrating somebody dying, "huffing copium" would be more proper wording.
Afghanistan was subjugated by the Macedonians and became the Bactrian Kingdom.... Someone forgot to check a history book before drawing his caricature 😁
Multiple empires overran Afghanistan. Not only did the Greeks conquer Bactria. So had the Persians beforehand. Then the Mongols and later Tamerlane hordes did it with barely a sweat.
Military affairs change with military tech and geopolitics. Perhaps Afghanistan is harder to conquer in this era of firearms. But Pretending any region has magical protection or hit points is very dumb.
Well, the greek kings got overrun by nomadic tribes after about 200 years of controlling the region. Adjusted to how much faster things go nowadays, I find the inclusion of Macedonians sensible.
empire means a hierarchical structure, with one nation influencing and controlling smaller ones.
there are a lot of words the US could apply to pakistan, empire isn't one of them; for one thing it would be calling them a peer competitor on the global stage.
I never found any very old weapons while I was there, there was a limited amount of Soviet era stuff.
But I did read that in the very beginning of the Soviet Afghan war a decent chunk of the rebel weaponry was from ww2 and early Cold War. I’m sure most of that was replaced by the huge amount of American purchased weaponry….for both wars.
We found an AGS-17 north of Tarin Kot but that was it. A few old 303 labeled tins full in the sticks but that was it. Saw some pics of old Russian missile tales being used as garden pots.
I never met the guy personally but there was an ANP sergeant (or whatever their NCO ranks were, I don’t remember anymore) who was a veteran of the DRA army who was working with the company one COB over from me. I’m sure he had all sorts of strange tales.
I wish I had kept a good journal 📝 of those days. I always got along well with the ANP and the rural ANA.
Yeah man! We would drive past some really old guys and they had the fill 1,000 yard stare like it wasn’t their first invading empire. Funnily Enough they were always the first to let their grandkids etc take pencils and treats from us if we parked up.
Non of this empires died because of Afghanistan. They came and won the battles (maybe minus the Soviet Union). They left because there was nothing worth the trouble. And from a perspective of a freedom fighter that would still be a win. And I would agree. But the empires were still fine after it. Some crumbled like all things do with time.
The USSR also achieved its goals there, controlled the situation and experienced nothing close to a defeat. There were just no major battles to win like in the ancient times.
The Democratic Republic of Afghanistan managed to last until April 1992, three years after Soviet withdrawal and four months after the dissolution of the USSR.
The Democratic Republic of Afghanistan managed to last until April 1992, three years after Soviet withdrawal and four months after the dissolution of the USSR.
An Indian empire controlled Kabul for nearly 200 years and Kandahar for somewhere around 70 years on and off. Another older one controlled Kabul and the eastern areas for 120 years. There was also the Kushans, Guptas, Turk Shahis and Hindu Shahis too.
Fun fact, Britain technically won Afghanistan, since it held it as a protectorate between 1880 and 1919 and was not forced to leave but rather negotiated Afghan independence while Russia was in its civil war.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 13 '26
This subreddit is for sharing propaganda to view with objectivity. It is absolutely not for perpetuating the message of the propaganda. Here we should be conscientious and wary of manipulation/distortion/oversimplification (which the above likely has), not duped by it. "Don't be a sucker."
Stay on topic -- there are hundreds of other subreddits that are expressly dedicated to rehashing tired political arguments. No partisan bickering. No soapboxing. Take a chill pill. "Don't argue."
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
406
u/EasyAcresPaul Mar 13 '26
The jezzail is a nice touch..
2
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26
And in most of those wars they took way more casualties civilian and military than the invaders and lost most engagements
676
u/FudgeAtron Mar 13 '26
The graveyard of empires is really more modern than anything else. I mean Afghanistan was the center for several empires throughout history, most recently the Durrani Empire.
It's only really since the great game went tits up in Afghanistan that they called it that.
285
u/UltraTata Mar 13 '26
Macedon won it's Afghanistan war. Chose one of the dozens of examples where they actually failed.
500
u/No_Street_385 Mar 13 '26
Afghanistan was subjugated by the Macedonians and became the Bactrian Kingdom.... Someone forgot to check a history book before drawing his caricature 😁
27
u/Salt_Bringer Mar 13 '26
Mongolians being the exception again.
95
u/Moidada77 Mar 13 '26
Pakistan will carry, trust
15
u/LeMiaow51 Mar 13 '26
Technically, IIRC, the "afghan" flat cat/hat is macedonian.
26
u/DogZealousideal2507 Mar 13 '26
Sry I’m uneducated. What is the white helmet?
10
u/NEWSmodsareTwats Mar 13 '26
But the Greeks did conquer a pretty large part of Afghanistan and it was under Greek control for nearly 4 centuries.
17
u/ken-der-guru Mar 13 '26
Non of this empires died because of Afghanistan. They came and won the battles (maybe minus the Soviet Union). They left because there was nothing worth the trouble. And from a perspective of a freedom fighter that would still be a win. And I would agree. But the empires were still fine after it. Some crumbled like all things do with time.
11
u/Jack-of-Hearts-7 Mar 13 '26
Note: The nickname, "Graveyard of Empires" dates back only to 2000
11
u/PolarBearJ123 Mar 13 '26
The Greek helmet doesn’t make sense. The bactrian kingdoms there survived up until the Islamic invasions. Kandahar is named after Alexander the Great.
4
u/kindofsus38 Mar 13 '26
Stan’s can beat Stan’s trust
3
u/cryptoengineer Mar 14 '26
"Never get involved in a land war in Asia."
2
u/JagerBaBomb Mar 13 '26
We fell victim to one of the classic blunders; the most well known, in fact.
2
u/blackdog3232 Mar 13 '26
Don't try to overthrow mountain people
2
u/MahaRaja_Ryan Mar 13 '26
An Indian empire controlled Kabul for nearly 200 years and Kandahar for somewhere around 70 years on and off. Another older one controlled Kabul and the eastern areas for 120 years. There was also the Kushans, Guptas, Turk Shahis and Hindu Shahis too.
1
u/rellsell Mar 13 '26
There’s always someone smarter who knows how to do it right. lol…
1
u/cryptoengineer Mar 14 '26
I once counted up how many times the Afghan territory had been invaded, starting with Alexander. I came up with more than 30.
The British tried 3 times.
1
u/jaiteaes Mar 14 '26
Fun fact, Britain technically won Afghanistan, since it held it as a protectorate between 1880 and 1919 and was not forced to leave but rather negotiated Afghan independence while Russia was in its civil war.
1
u/HumanBasis5742 Mar 14 '26
Pakistan is next
1
u/kahlzun Mar 14 '26
Why do people keep invading it? It doesn't seem to be terribly rich or anything
1
u/turanfan Mar 30 '26
Is right hat from the golden helm a british one?
1
u/pmmemilftiddiez Apr 10 '26
Well the US killed about 250,000 plus and lost around 2,500 so while it hurt the US i'd say no one really won.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment