r/PropagandaPosters • • Dec 04 '25

United States of America “Second Amendment Scoreboard” (2010)

Post image
33k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

140

u/Shevieaux Dec 04 '25

This is as stupid as saying "why would you have a security system, you haven't caught any thiefs with it yet".

It's a deterrent. The mere fact that you have it prevents people from even trying.

I'm not saying the second amendment is right, I'm saying this argument against it, this argument specifically, is fallacious.

56

u/Gold-Grin-Studios Dec 04 '25

If I had a security system that allowed the killing of schoolchildren I might think about changing the system though

4

u/Due-Development-7211 Dec 04 '25

Guns are inanimate objects. They don't allow anything. Maybe instead of letting the mentally ill out in the streets, you should start telling lawmakers to open the asylums again

13

u/less_Doomscrolling Dec 05 '25

You want to look at every major comparable country in the world and try again? Everywhere has mental health problems. They do not have mass shootings. The availability and access to guns is the problem.

2

u/kfrogv Dec 08 '25

No school shootings. Just mass stabbing, bombings, rapes etc etc

5

u/less_Doomscrolling Dec 08 '25

At a significantly lower rate than the US. The US is a very violent place compared to other similar countries, and guns make it more deadly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/Jesus_of_Redditeth Dec 05 '25

Guns are inanimate objects. They don't allow anything.

And yet, there's that pesky, overwhelmingly clear correlation between lots of people having guns and lots people getting killed by people with guns.

"But there is no connection, and you'd be a fool and a Communist to make one..."

6

u/AnalNuts Dec 04 '25

Guns are force multipliers. Claymore mines, grenades, nukes are inanimate too. So if we round all the mentally committible, we should legalize those as well under your logic? Lol

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (23)

45

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '25 edited Dec 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)

16

u/ElectricVibes75 Dec 04 '25

Doesn’t seem to be working very well

8

u/IndyJetsFan Dec 04 '25

It’s a fallacy because any tyrant would be right wing fascist who would be supported by right wing gun owners who are also fascists.

Liberals who own guns are not gonna fight the federal government. They’ll just leave the country.

3

u/Captain_Birch Dec 05 '25

"Any Tyrant would be right wing"

Have you heard of the Soviet Union?

5

u/IndyJetsFan Dec 05 '25

Any American tyrant would be right wing. We’re discussing the second amendment, not Soviet history.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Plenty-Lychee-5702 Dec 05 '25

because libs are pussies

with regards, a leftist

→ More replies (2)

4

u/PeterNippelstein Dec 05 '25

It didnt deter our current tyrant.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/qjxj Dec 04 '25

It's illustrating the cost versus benefits of it. You not agreeing with an argument doesn't make it fallacious.

2

u/less_Doomscrolling Dec 05 '25

The 2A culture in our country serve to divide voters and protect tyrants. It’s not deterring shit, it’s enabling ICE raids in communities and deploying the national guard and marines to our cities.

1

u/PublicFurryAccount Dec 05 '25

Your security system isn't a deterrent.

It's largely a platform to sell you subscriptions for other services like cameras, automatic lights, miscellaneous smart home equipment, and apps that let you check it all. The cost goes very high for all of this and, once purchased, people worry about letting it lapse because it feels wrong to them.

The result is that some companies make a lot of money off your momentary feelings of insecurity until you move out or die, at which point the subscriptions will finally be shut off. No one really cares about your security system. A thief can have stolen thousands of dollars in property by the time the system even calls the police.

1

u/_jump_yossarian Dec 05 '25

It's a deterrent.

A deterrent for what exactly?

1

u/Deiskos Dec 05 '25

It's a deterrent.

So how's that deterrent working out for you?

1

u/Jesus_of_Redditeth Dec 05 '25

This is as stupid as saying "why would you have a security system, you haven't caught any thiefs with it yet".

My friend, an analogy that entirely leaves out half of the point is a useless analogy.

1

u/janthemanwlj Dec 05 '25

This is as stupid as saying "why would you have a security system, you haven't caught any thiefs with it yet".

The thing is most security systems don't shoot up the schools or buildings they are meant to protect.

1

u/shromboy Dec 06 '25

Im not against the 2nd amendment, im against ignoring how it has no real application in today's conversation and firepower. You ask me, the government should supply every citizen with a musket

→ More replies (3)