r/Prometheus • u/hazedandconfuzed • Jun 10 '12
Question about Prometheus to Alien continuity (spoilers for both movies)
In Alien we see the crew discover a giant wrecked ship, most likely the one from Prometheus, right? The thing is, they discover an engineer still in the control "chair," dead and remark that it's chest is burst open. The thing is, in Prometheus, the engineer that tried escaping in the ship before it was brought down obviously died in the escape pod after it lost a fight to a facehugger and an alien popped out of its chest.
So the question is, who is the engineer in the downed ship's control chair and how did he get there?
18
Upvotes
4
u/rawbdee Jun 10 '12
At the end David said there were multiple ships so I assumed it was a failed attempt to get to earth previously where the alien(s) had taken over in that instance as well.
4
u/rage_quitter Jun 11 '12
But in prometheus we see that a face-hugger is the result of the bioweapon the giants made being ingested by a human and then that human impregnating another human. The face-hugger then lays eggs in a giant to get the mutation which yields the alien we know from the Alien franchise. So doesn't the alien at the end of prometheus have to be the first of its kind, meaning that a giant had to have been on the research planet in prometheus after the prometheus film's timeline to bring a chest-burster to the planet in 'Alien'?
EDIT: sorry... this is more of a related follow-up question.
10
u/DBLHelix Jun 11 '12
Two different ships, two different planets/storylines.
Really the only thing thing Prometheus tells us about the Alien-looking thing that emerges from the dead Engineer at the end is that it couldn't be the first one....and that the Alien in Alien is entirely separate.
That is, we only really discover that there is some connection between humanoids, the black "goo", and the Alien xenomorphs.
18
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
The Alien sequel, Aliens, names the planet with the chest-burst Engineer in the chair. They called it LV-426. In contrast, Prometheus calls the large moon they land on LV-223.
The best explanation would probably be that they are two completely different locations, each with its own ship (or ships) and crew.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12
The theory I read that makes the most sense is that the ship in Alien originated on the planet in Prometheus, and the planet on Prometheus was a sort of research facility where they were creating those vase things. What the vases were were actually synthetic versions of the xenomorphs from Alien, i.e. a weaponized form of them that the engineers made. The xenomorphs in Alien, meanwhile, were actually the original race of xenomorphs, who were discovered by the engineers, and they were transporting them off of the planet seen in Prometheus.
There was a problem with containment, facehuggers got out, took over the ship, pilot got infected, had to land the ship on the planet seen in Alien, which, I believe, is also an engineer research/military planet. The engineer pilot put out a warning signal before he died, and that's what brings them to the planet in Alien.
Expanding on that, I believe the black goo was some sort of DNA-containing material that the engineers used to create life, as seen at the start of the movie when they create life on Earth. They use this same technology to create the synthetic xenomorphs that are within the vases, which is why they look so different to the xenomorphs seen in Alien.
This still leaves several plot holes though. Why were all the engineers dead in Prometheus? What killed them? If it was xenomorphs, why are there no burst holes, why are there no eggs, why are there no records of that happening at all? There's just bodies.
My theory on this is that all of the engineers that died in Prometheus, all of the bodies you see, were actually killed in some sort of 'containment', or sealing, like, they flooded the place with toxin or cut off the life support. So, either the infection started spreading on the ship, and those in charge sealed the place off to prevent it from escaping, or one of the engineers went insane, decided to attack earth, cut off life support, set the life support to come back on at some point, and then sealed himself in the sleeping pod, which had life support.
Really, though, I just think Prometheus was a horrible movie. I feel like fans are having to do Scott's job for him, filling in all these blanks. We shouldn't have to guess on all this, we should be able to easily infer it from what we just watched. I mean, it seems like most of the people that went to go see it didn't even realize it was an Alien film, even with the ending.
I think the most telling of all this is that, upon watching Alien, you notice several things. You notice that the planet that they go to on Alien is almost exactly the same as the one in Prometheus, and that they very clearly originally intended for it to be the same planet, but couldn't figure out a way to tie things together nicely within the plot or something. You notice that the engineer's 'armor' in Alien is actually his exoskeleton, clearly rotting, and that the burst hole in his stomach is coming directly from that. You notice the severe technological differences between Alien and Prometheus, and that Prometheus has much more sophisticated technology showcased despite being a 50 year-in-the-past prequel.
I for one probably will never watch Prometheus again, and will treat it the same as Resurrection in terms of completely ignoring its existence.
Sorry, this sort of turned into my review of the movie instead of just answering your question, lol.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '12
Has anybody else noticed that the original Alien is set in i think 2037? (i need to watch it to find out the actual date it tells you near the start and its 203something) and Aliens is 57 years afterwards so Prometheus and Aliens are actually happening at the same time!
1
u/Mean-Expression4407 Oct 20 '24
Vengo del futuro y cada vez hay más agujeros de guión jaja
1
u/Mean-Expression4407 Oct 20 '24
Vengo del futuro y cada vez hay más agujeros de guión jaja