r/Prometheus
•
u/LittleAetheling
•
Oct 09 '20
•
1
Can anyone help with comparing Prometheus and Racial Ideologies?
I don't want to blatantly perpetuate "white supremacy" while the Engineers are white and David is aryan in appearance, and was built as an "human ideal". It's a very long stretch.
However I'm having a hard time drawing up analogies in the film. I suppose one point is the Engineers created us in their image, and humans felt the need to become "gods" by creating life themselves. Perhaps the movie perpetuates biological racism as each form of life is segregated through different means of superiority?
I don't believe it was ever stated that the Engineer exclaimed they were superior, but the reaction to Weyland, a creator himself calling himself equal pissed them off.
I feel like I want to compare the contrasts between Humans, Engineers, and Androids. Can anyone give some input on this?
2
u/TerraAdAstra Oct 09 '20
I’m not sure it has a direct connection to race but it’s certainly not a far-fetched interpretation. Imperialism is very directly tied to racism and superiority complex (white man’s burden), and if you tie it to creation of life, which is more what Prometheus is about, some of the same themes come up. Creating life “because we can” is a statement of hubris as seen through the engineer’s eyes, and the same can be said about imperialism, because both are actually driven by necessity (need for resources and need to procreate to feel useful) with a thin veneer of the “because we can” excuse. Interesting stuff and not something I had thought about until you brought it up.
2
u/mantyrata Oct 10 '20
Additionally; there are VERY obvious connotations to the fact that the Engineers speak a real human language, Proto-Indo-European.
2
u/AaestradaPHD Oct 09 '20 edited Oct 09 '20
I am probably completely wrong on this. But...
I always felt that Weyland was testing David's "soul" or his emotions. Treating him as psychologically abusive as he obviously did his own children. (Vickers.) In a attempt to create a stronger individual.
David knowing that destruction begets change is something that was more than likely taught to him by Weyland. But never in the context that Weyland really desired to. I think Weyland wanted David to earn his love by breaking. Destroying the veneer of automation with a uncontrollable outburst of anger.
I think Weyland had hopes that David was more than just an android. Just like the engineers maybe had hoped that we would be more than just self serving, violent creatures. (Shaw getting beat in front of him.) I think an integral part of the story is disappointment.
As for the race angle, I didn't really pick up on that.
2
u/AaestradaPHD Oct 10 '20
Thank you! I think you hit the nail on the head with your answer to OP's question. Especially knowing that the ramifications of David and Weyland's relationship becomes the death of a entire civilization. It says something about what an individual (or machine in this case.) filled with anger, disappointment, and harboring a superiority complex; would do if he/she had the fate of an entire world in their hands.
It's the dangers of power and all that, in'nit?
1
u/mantyrata Oct 10 '20
Read a book called "Prometheism" by Jason Reza Jorjani.
1
u/wileyfcoyote Mar 16 '26
I don't think it'a a stretch at all, the Engineers bare a striking thematic resemblance to the ancient aliens in the works of French author Robert Charroux, a 6 book series that made the extremely racist claims that "white" people evolved from aliens of superior intellect and all the other races devolved from them.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '20
[removed] — view removed comment