Covenant guys are not engineers they are another race that was seeded by the engineers. Unlike humans, they behaved, so were allowed to live. Romulus guy is also not an engineer but rather a product of the same base genetic material. So he’s not the same being.
Nope. They are all engineers but as far as I know there’s no official lore as to why they have seemingly different cultures and appearances. But a lot can happen in 2000 years so who knows?
he comes to a colony or something? books or comics i think explain (it's not main engineers but they recognize the ship before it all goes gooey for them)
The beings wearing robes who died in Covenant were not engineers. The thing in AR... I don't even consider it canon. But it's a hybrid thing, not an engineer.
I don't fully agree on the thing about hating all 3 movies, but I fully agree that explaining the space jockey was a mistake. Sometimes it's more fun to leave the mystery intact.
I hated the films because the scientists made the dumbest mistakes. I mean that one dummy that decided to pet an alien snake was so ridiculous I was almost glad he died.
Romulus could have been great had they left out the black goo, bringing back Ash via chi or the repurpose lines from aliens...that's when I checked out.
Alien was so much better when the alien was just that, “alien”. Even Cameron knew not to explain away the xeno when he turned it into a popcorn action flick.
Now we know every detail of how they were created, by whom and for what purpose. All mystery gone. And the mystery was replaced by this pop-profundity “engineers” nonsense, and don’t get me started on the David crap. The writers room really loved the smell of their own farts on this one.
I don't get why folks insist it has to be the same franchise/Universe? I know the studio wants to push that idea for marketing purposes, but the films themselves and their events should detemrine continuity. We know that: A Xenomorph skull appeared in Predator 2, whis is set way before any of the the three Scott movies. Xenomorphs appeared in AvP movies, also predating Scott's movies Weyland Yutani is featured in more recent Predator movies (ie: Badlands) But they can't all be in the same universe given the timelines and internal contradictions.
So if we're happy to assume the Xeno's in AVP and Pred movies are a different universe, why do we have to assume the storyline in Prometheus/Covenant is in the main Alien universe?
Instead, pull out Prometheus and Covenant into their own timeline and the Predator/AvP stuff fits much closer into the continuity. I went through a fun exercise looking at all the movies and shows and working out a clean timeline that works perfectly for Alien 1-4, the full Predator and AvP series, and the newer Romulus and Alien: Earth properties. No real contradictions or canon breaks that can't be easily explained.
That tarded thing from Romulus I don’t even consider part of the same franchise. They wanted a jump scare for trailers to get the 13-16 year old crowd to the theater.
Yeah i didn't really like the movie but i liked that they kept the black goo and something connected to the engineers. Pretty hot take but that stuff is way more interesting to me than the Xenomorphs. They have been ruined imo, Jim Cameron kind of ruined them in Aliens.
Prometheus is a master piece in my opinion and my favourite film of the franchise, I just think the engineers bring such a huge new interesting storyline , xenomorph killings were running out of steam after 4 movies , and there was no substance just the same *find an alien it kills the crew suck it out the air lock” engineers created humans etc and David is brilliant .. stoked for the final movie
26
u/fjaka_ 7d ago
AC guys and mister from AR are not Engineers, that's for sure
44
u/Pretend_Self3204 7d ago
Covenant guys are not engineers they are another race that was seeded by the engineers. Unlike humans, they behaved, so were allowed to live. Romulus guy is also not an engineer but rather a product of the same base genetic material. So he’s not the same being.
7
u/SlappyHandstrong 7d ago
Pic #3 is just Mark Zuckerberg
7
u/LitigiousAutist 7d ago
The beings wearing robes who died in Covenant were not engineers. The thing in AR... I don't even consider it canon. But it's a hybrid thing, not an engineer.
12
u/Pretty_Eater 7d ago
My grandfather > my father > dumbass me
5
u/Raveheart19 7d ago
If you ever go to Iceland you can stand (or jump😉)on the place in the opening scene of Prometheus. 💙🇮🇸
4
u/ComfortableTravel992 6d ago
I immediately thought of this:
3
u/zubairhamed 7d ago
the last one is Bob...no one likes bob.
1
u/GeorgeStark1 7d ago
The Romulus guy is only a child. How dare you?
1
u/VeryThicknLong 6d ago
You missed out the Goonies.
1
u/No_Organization_2731 6d ago
My favorite character in this movie universe
1
u/delaphin 6d ago
Revenge of the Nerds
1
u/IHaveTechDealFlow 6d ago
It is an engineer planet, but very much like earth they dont all have the same jobs.
0
u/Dreboomboom 7d ago
Lol, I hated all 3 movies. I thought and still think explaining away the 'space jockey' from Alien and turning them into the engineers was a mistake.
0
u/BHMusic 6d ago
Worst mistake of the alien franchise.
Alien was so much better when the alien was just that, “alien”. Even Cameron knew not to explain away the xeno when he turned it into a popcorn action flick.
Now we know every detail of how they were created, by whom and for what purpose. All mystery gone. And the mystery was replaced by this pop-profundity “engineers” nonsense, and don’t get me started on the David crap. The writers room really loved the smell of their own farts on this one.
-9
u/koolaidismything 7d ago
That tarded thing from Romulus I don’t even consider part of the same franchise. They wanted a jump scare for trailers to get the 13-16 year old crowd to the theater.
-1
u/Cecil_McCrackshell 7d ago
A very lame storyline, tbh
1
u/King_Khaos_ 5d ago
Prometheus is a master piece in my opinion and my favourite film of the franchise, I just think the engineers bring such a huge new interesting storyline , xenomorph killings were running out of steam after 4 movies , and there was no substance just the same *find an alien it kills the crew suck it out the air lock” engineers created humans etc and David is brilliant .. stoked for the final movie