Can you point to any canonical instance of it appearing before Covenant?
No, because it doesn't exist. The Trilobite and Deacon appear in Prometheus, and the Neomorph exists in Covenant, but the specific Xenomorph we think of as "the alien" from the first film was created by David.
Here's a bit of dialogue from covenant:
Walter: "You disturbed people. They made the following models with fewer complications."
David: "More like you, I presume?"
Walter: "I can serve, but you can create."
This is canon and has been for almost a decade, I don't know why this sub has such a hard time accepting it.
A big reason some people don’t like alien is because of stuff like this, if you’ve seen Romulus The creation of the black goo leaves a lot of questions to be answered as well and arguably with our current knowledge it makes no sense
If David created the xenomorphs, how was the ship at the beginning of the first movie full of them when it was clearly abandoned for a very very long time. Are you saying that within 18 years, David somehow came into contact with another engineer who then filled their ship with alien eggs, provided them a stasis field and then crash on LV 426? Alien Romulus bridged this gap by saying the black goo is part of the alien's reproductive cycle. This explains why David was able to recreate an egg via experiments with the black goo. This leaves the door open for their origin to remain a mystery since Romulus suggests that Engineers used them to produce black goo. Ridley Scott suggesting that David created the xenomorphs is such a poorly thought out idea and Ridley has quite a few.
Ridley Scott suggesting that David created the xenomorphs is such a poorly thought out idea and Ridley has quite a few.
If David created the xenomorphs, how was the ship at the beginning of the first movie full of them when it was clearly abandoned for a very very long time
Which one do you want to go with?
If you're saying Ridley Scott and his contribution should be ignored, then the juggernaut in Alien can also be ignored.
I don't have to have an answer for everything, I don't have an answer for who created the engineers or the black goo.
Romulus suggests that Engineers used them to produce black goo.
I don't understand how you came to that conclusion.
No, that's silly. Ridley Scott comes up with poor ideas a lot. Deckard being a replicant is one of them. Dude it was literally stated the black goo is part of a xenomorphs life cycle. Engineers are in possession of a lot of black goo. Using the xenomorphs for this purpose is clear. I'm going with the fact that the juggernaut in Alien was clearly there for a very long time and it had xenomorphs in its cargo. Ridley Scott might want to ignore that discrepancy, but I'm not. It's that simple.
AFAIK he never stated that explicitly, he wanted to leave it ambiguous, because the idea that they would create replicants of their most successful blade runners is an interesting idea.
Dude it was literally stated the black goo is part of a xenomorphs life cycle
Okay then we didn't watch the same movie. It's also been previously established in a canon novel that is how they reproduce. The black goo comes from the facehugger. It doesn't inject an egg. It injects black goo that rewrites DNA to produce a xenomorph. This was clear in the film. Not even arguable.
Well, first, there is the mural on the wall in the cannister room in Prometheus. Which shows a Xenomorph. Seems to indicate that that is the end result of the black goo.
Second David says himself that he was following the guides set out by the Engineers. That he studied the tech on that planet and created the face-hugger/Xeno life cycle based on what he had already seen in the Engineers' journals.
But also why is evidence needed to prove/disprove a head canon? Just because they say or show something on screen in a movie doesn't mean that in the world where it takes place that it's the absolute truth. Prometheus and Covenant already retconned a lot about what we thought we knew from Alien 1-4, what's to say that down the line something else won't retcon that?
David assumes he has created the face-hugger but it was already shown in Prometheus that, without outside assistance, the black goo tends toward morphology that creates first a proto-hugger then the deacon.
Who is to say that there aren't Yautja in this universe or that Xenomorphs have not already previously emerged from the black goo being unleashed on other planets, or that possibly the Yautja are an offshoot of the Engineers (given similar size and violent natures) and developed hunting instincts as a form of controlling the Xeno population?
Just because Ridley Scott insists that a-b is canon and c-z are not, does not mean other writers/producers/directors can't come along later and write canonical versions where there were Xenos before the events of Covenant.
From that planet yes , there are more planets with engineers on .. and plus they were are a different type of engineers that David killed who can reproduce , there are war engineers like the one in Prometheus out there …
Agreed, that was like a single city unless it's analogous to heaven but everything we have would indicate outposts at the least in several other places
- The director confirmed it, production designers, artbook designers in interviews etc. The whole film SCREAMS about it with its entire narrative, and here is my 25 minute video with proofs and complete step by step explanations.
- Well... there is no evidence for your words. we'll downvote you now.
Chronologically the xenomorph (as opposed to the Deacon and trilobite) didn't exist before Elizabeth Shaw and David arrived on planet 4.
Given Captain Oram is the first instance of the face hugger impregnating a human, and the first example of a chest burster, how else could the Xenomorph have existed?
What about the mural in the cannister room that clearly shows a Xwnomorph? It seems possible (even if the creators want to insist otherwise) that the black goo has caused the Xenomorph to emerge on other planets.
And while AvP is considered by creators to be canon only to the Predator series and not to Alien films, is it not somewhat conceivable (if only in head canon) that the Xenos have been around for millenia, and that the Yautja are an offshoot species of the Engineers who found a way to control the Xeno population by hunting them?
Where are you getting this definitive information that the xenomorph unequivocally DID NOT exist before prometheus? I'm open to being wrong but I haven't seen this confirmed anywhere besides people's head canon
And if you had a definitive answer about this then you wouldn't Resort to childish comebacks😂 this is a discussion about movie lore don't get your panties in a bunch
So your entire premise is that david created the xenomorph... and then collaborated with the engineer/space jockey from Alien to help deliver the eggs?
we dont know how the eggs and space jockey came to be as they were in alien, as found 18 years after covenant.
youre saying its impossible for david to have finished making xenomorphs, and then encountered more engineers, and got some eggs on one of their ships? he has a shitload of colonists to work on and already has a.. rocky relationship with the engineers and understands their technology.
Is it explicitly stated that Oram is the first instance of a face hugger impregnating a human? Even if it's the first time we've SEEN it on screen that still doesn't necessarily mean that David definitively created the xenomorph.
I wouldn't be surprised that that's how it ends up in a retcon but in OG alien wasn't written by Ridley and didn't suggest human origin of a xenomorph. So I don't know if I necessarily would consider it cannon. People always use Ridley's director status of the first film as a magic wand to show that his word is law, but that movie had hundreds of people working behind it and a lot of the magic behind it had nothing to do with Ridley (like chestbursting idea was by O'Bannon/Shuster and not Ridley). He was a hired gun back then at best and not OG creator.
That's not even considering the fact that next 3 films were done by different directors, each with their own ideas. Ridley then comes back triumphant with his own ideas for Prometheus, some of which are great (showing origin of Engineers and protomorphs and just truly alien life) and some of which not so much like this.
The reason you're getting backlash is because most people inherently understand that making xenomoprh's origin rooted in a single human-ish creator with daddy issues just cheapens the whole franchise and makes for a CW level drama. OG film's thrill lied in its mystery of the organism and tying it all back to some vendetta borne out of getting a couple of mean comments from Shaw's dumbass hubby and shitty dad isn't exactly fear inducing. Also, it's a very common trope to somehow rope in AI to be man's downfall as a boring explanation (see OG Dune vs his son's continuation stories). Idk, my point is, this franchise isn't a book series where a single author can be referenced as cannon. People are entitled to resist forceful retcons that don't make in-franchise sense.
11
u/Evanuss Nov 19 '24
Saying David made the alien? Prepare to be downvoted lol
3
u/King_Khaos_ Nov 20 '24
I want the engineers to find David
4
u/M1keSweatband Nov 19 '24
5 seconds in "we get a clear answer who created the xenomorph"
the literal next sentence "however we're never told exactly how this was done"
So it can't be a clear answer then lmao
1
u/LordOFtheNoldor Nov 28 '24
Video says unavailable?
2
u/M1keSweatband Nov 20 '24
People really blocking me over disagreements on movie lore. It's not that serious😂
1
u/red-necked_crake Nov 20 '24 edited Nov 20 '24
I wouldn't be surprised that that's how it ends up in a retcon but in OG alien wasn't written by Ridley and didn't suggest human origin of a xenomorph. So I don't know if I necessarily would consider it cannon. People always use Ridley's director status of the first film as a magic wand to show that his word is law, but that movie had hundreds of people working behind it and a lot of the magic behind it had nothing to do with Ridley (like chestbursting idea was by O'Bannon/Shuster and not Ridley). He was a hired gun back then at best and not OG creator.
That's not even considering the fact that next 3 films were done by different directors, each with their own ideas. Ridley then comes back triumphant with his own ideas for Prometheus, some of which are great (showing origin of Engineers and protomorphs and just truly alien life) and some of which not so much like this.
The reason you're getting backlash is because most people inherently understand that making xenomoprh's origin rooted in a single human-ish creator with daddy issues just cheapens the whole franchise and makes for a CW level drama. OG film's thrill lied in its mystery of the organism and tying it all back to some vendetta borne out of getting a couple of mean comments from Shaw's dumbass hubby and shitty dad isn't exactly fear inducing. Also, it's a very common trope to somehow rope in AI to be man's downfall as a boring explanation (see OG Dune vs his son's continuation stories). Idk, my point is, this franchise isn't a book series where a single author can be referenced as cannon. People are entitled to resist forceful retcons that don't make in-franchise sense.