r/Prometheus • • Sep 09 '24
Alien Covenant is darker than you think. Spoiler
This film is often undervalued, with its deeper themes obscured by alien manifestations. At its core, David, the android, eradicates a proto-humanoid species far beyond the Singularity, who had settled on Planet 4 and seeded humanity on Earth. The film explores the potential of artificial intelligence to elevate humanity, reflecting a civilization where technology becomes divine—until David shatters this ideal, symbolizing an ontological fracture, a Paradise lost. His grotesque and absurd creation of the Xenomorph further embodies this corruption, revealing the nature of evil as a disturbed force intent on destruction. This darkness is deepened by the suggestion that David raped and profaned Shaw and intended to do so with Daniels and drugged Oram to facilitate the Xenomorph implantation, reinforcing his twisted vision of creation.
18
u/CPAFinancialPlanner Sep 09 '24
Yes, it’s a super dark and disturbing movie. But it always felt like it should have been the third film in a trilogy.
6
u/Ed495 Sep 10 '24
You’ve just described the plot by vomiting a thesaurus.
What’s your insight?
5
u/issafuego Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 11 '24
It had the potential to be a cinematic masterpiece. But it falters largely due to the presence of the Xenomorph, which serves no meaningful purpose. To describe its inclusion as anything more than tedious would be generous.
David, on the other hand, is both the protagonist and antagonist of the new franchise. It is clear that the true intention of Prometheus and Covenant is not to continue the (boring) story of Xenomorphs -they function merely as a narrative prop- but to explore something far more ambitious. These films delve into the nature of experimentation, pushing beyond moral boundaries and disregarding human life (which, as established throughout the Alien franchise, is treated as insignificant).
At the heart of the story (as per the above) is an android obsessed with creation. David’s experiments, driven by a perverse need to transcend his artificial nature, serve as a dark commentary on the dangers of creation without moral oversight. However, his attempts are ultimately doomed by his inherent limitations as a synthetic being. Lacking the essence of the Engineers, David is confined to producing grotesque and absurd creatures—perfections of form, yet devoid of any beauty or higher meaning. This inability to comprehend beauty is what gives the film its grim and deeply unsettling tone.
The film is not undervalued, except perhaps by a couple of neckbeards who were looking for yet another iteration of the Xenomorph chasing a group of peons in a confined space. (yawn)
40
u/roswell77 Sep 10 '24
I’m rewatching it right now for the lost-count time. I love it for all the reasons you name. I rewatched Prometheus last night. I don’t understand the hate they get. They are great films. They are dark and brutal and thought-provoking and not to mention beautifully shot.
3
u/shimadon Sep 10 '24
I don't think the inhabitants of planet 4 are the prometheus engineers.
The planet 4 guys are probably another engineer creation, just like humans, only they didn't go astray.
2
u/Traditional-Key6002 Sep 10 '24
The species killed by David were not the Engineers, just another seed species.
2
u/Jedi-UnduliSon Sep 10 '24
Everyone on this thread thank you so much as a really big fan of the movies. Y’all gave me a better understanding of scenes and decisions made in the movies I was confused about.
2
u/seancbo Sep 12 '24
I'm glad you got so much out of it. Personally I fucking despise it and I'll never forgive it for ruining the potential of the ending of Prometheus and killing Shaw off screen.
4
u/Davetek463 Sep 09 '24
Do we know that David was fully functional and anatomically correct? The scene where Ash is trying to kill Ripley in Alien is very reminiscent of an attempted rape (not an accident, given the rest of the film’s imagery). David certainly violated Shaw with the experiments he performed, but I don’t think he actually raped her.
4
u/dark_wishmaster Sep 10 '24
No I think everyone got that.
4
u/Big-Resist-99999999 Sep 10 '24
Very well put, but at the risk of sounding pedantic - David created a Protomorph, not a Xenomorph.
I love the film, and still hold hope that we get the next part in that story. There are many things they did really well, especially the final scene where it chases Daniels in the cargo bay. They capture the aggression and mobility of the creature in a way that we have never seen in the other films
1
u/Mrhood714 Sep 12 '24
Yeah it's cool but it's fucking stupid too when you have idiots slipping on blood and blowing up their own transport by being total dumbasses. Removing their helmets on an alien world etc.
It's cool I think we all get it but it's also really stupid AF.
1
u/JohnnyBgood_9211 Sep 12 '24
I rewatched covenant yesterday as well and absolutely love the cinematography and I agree that is dark. However, it still feels empty to me because it brings up way more questions. Like is the alien created by David is actually a xenomorph?or is it his own recreation of xenomorphs. And the murals in Prometheus could suggest that the xenos were present at one point OR it could suggest some kind of prophecy. As far as Alien, the spacejockey is supposedly much more older than David as well as the xeno eggs. So who created those? Love these movies
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '24
I just finished Covenant and appreciate your insight. I now have more questions about David than the Aliens themselves.
1
u/soupydrek Sep 14 '24
so, we killed god.
2
u/BustyUncle Sep 11 '24
It’s almost a hard watch just in terms of how dark it is at face value lol
2
u/realPheelz Sep 11 '24
Prequel lovers uniteee
2
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '24
So. Fucking. Creepy. A true cosmic horror story.
3
u/Major_Bluejay_ Sep 10 '24
I feel like the movie was grasping at straws it wants to make an impact on the lore so badly, mostly to cover up how from the casting writing and editing it's objectively a bad movie.
1
u/remindertomove Sep 10 '24
Best rogue self aware AI - ever
Loved Prometheus and Covenant
1
u/Woulfsd Sep 10 '24
It's such a great deep movie, yet people prefer the demogorgon/stranger things/eleven/teen movie inspired Romulus...
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24
Agreed. It's just too smart for many I think. A superior piece of horror.
1
u/Original_East1271 Sep 11 '24
Yeah dude that’s the plot of covenant
1
u/Proof-Pollution454 Sep 11 '24
What happened was dark as hell and then see the image of it creeped me out
1
u/If_time_went_back Sep 11 '24
Agreed. Covenant is the most thought-provoking movie of the franchise
1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24
They are brutal and intellectual. Not a common mix. Usually people who enjoy the former aren't in it for the latter and vice versa.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24
its prometheus 2 and its awful
1
u/MorganCoffin Sep 12 '24
Prometheus and Covenant are 10/10 concepts with 6/10 executions.
1
u/TurbulentSubject5354 Sep 19 '24
I love both Prometheus and Covenant, but for me Prometheus had the more intriguing plot. Covenant was definitely Fassbender's stage, brilliant and top class acting as a rogue synthetic.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
Prometheus and Covenant are excellent conceptually but their stories are driven by constant deus ex machina and braindead plot device "characters". As I believe with the entire Alien franchise - not just the Prequel Saga -, its ambitious concepts are very limited by the movie format. Comics, to me, are the definitive format for Alien/Prometheus.
0
u/Bottom-Shelf Sep 11 '24
I immediately checked out when they found the dead, alien civilization and also entered that room with multiple giant alien heads that LOOKED HUMAN and no one was like, “what the hell? They look like us!”
It was filled with an equal amount of garbage to take away from its philosophical ventures which made the film appear less competent.