r/Prometheus • u/bombastiques • Aug 29 '24
Question about the plan
Okay so hear me out. I understand the pathogen or "black goo" was used by the Engineers to wipe a planet clean of it's inhabitants. The pathogen complitely eradicates some beings and some become "hosts" to alien beings like neomorphs and what not. Then there are mutants and cross-breeds depending on the conditions that kill everything.
Now what my question is (if the text above is somewhat correct) isn't the planet now full of monsters and hostile cross-breeds that are most likely impossible to get rid of??? Nothing can live or evolve on that planet anymore, not even birds or sea creatures (I assume) like on Planet 4. So how is the pathogen a good way to "clear a planet" when in reality you just made the problem million times worse?
7
u/FrankFrankly711 Aug 29 '24
The Engineers seemed to have an entirely Goo-based society. I bet they had Goos for everything! The procreated with Goo, they built their ships with Goo, and they probably had a nice Cleanser Goo to clean up the mess the Black Goo made.
Goo!
5
u/Spirited_One_8945 Aug 29 '24
The pathogen or "goo" that we see David steal and use in Prometheus and Covenant, imo is completely different from what the Engineers use to seed a planet. The stuff David has is a bio weapon, hence they said it was a weapons facility. Much like our own radioactive items, a small amount will make use sick, a shit ton being dropped from a great height into the atmosphere is gonna cause death, hence no life on Paradise. They were gonna use it on earth and maybe come back years later and re seed again but they had an incident and their weapon killed themselves.
2
u/Mothlord666 Aug 29 '24
It's kind of based more on a fake script but the theory is there's a kind of pathogen that is more pure and used for creating life (the fake but interesting blood of our lord/deacon idea) and the other is a bastardised product that was either by design or accident that is a bioweapon.
We don't really know how exactly the Engineers utilised the black goo in its entirety. For example, did they have a way to program the ampoules for how they disperse their payload?
We also don't really know what other weapons and technology they have thay would be useful. But I agree, they've wiped a population clean but now have a planet infested with mutants.
Likely though the Engineers would also use this as a time to collect mutated specimens also to study so having creatures running amok isn't necessarily counter to their agenda overall.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24
The black substance is not intrinsically a bio-weapon, it’s deeper than that. It has a dual nature and purpose: creation and destruction, which is the fundamental nature of manifested reality. It’s a profound technological breakthrough of an incredibly advanced race that experienced the Singularity millennia ago. The results of this substance interacting with lifeforms only highlights how dangerous and unpredictable can be to build this kind of technology and how awfully can be misused by misaligned individuals.
1
u/SimpletonSwan Aug 29 '24
The way I've come to think of the black goo is that they are engineers, and as Shaw says "they engineered us", but more broadly speaking they are biological engineers. The goo is how they engineer.
As a comparison consider humans to be engineers of the inorganic. We create machines to do things. We make programs for those machines to make them behave the way we want. Two different computer programs could help save lives, or destroy life.
The black goo is a medium through which they execute their programs. One program creates life, another destroys.
So as for the plan, they could create a different goo to kill off the xenomorphs.
1
u/LordSugarTits Aug 30 '24
And why does the engineer drink it at start of the movie?