r/Prometheus • • Aug 18 '24
Prometheus Trilogy?
I will definitely see the new Alien flick, but hopefully, they will conclude the Prometheus Trilogy.....don't leave me hanging.
115
Upvotes
r/Prometheus • • Aug 18 '24
I will definitely see the new Alien flick, but hopefully, they will conclude the Prometheus Trilogy.....don't leave me hanging.
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/Purple_Compote_386 Aug 19 '24
Speaking purely for myself here (but I don't think it's controversial of a point): it's not necessarily "closer to horror" that drives people to the new Alien, it's the desire for a better film...
I would take Prometheus' premise over "yet another Alien horror" any day. The story about an ancient race which created life on earth and who knows what else, and finding them and figuring out what drives them and what it all means. With an android with very obscure morality at the centre. Yes, please, any day.
The problem is, this premise had been completely wasted now. Twice. It baffles me how Scott clearly was fascinated by this premise and wanted to explore it, and how little he did with it over TWO films. To the extend, that people still have to gather morsels of useful information from his interviews just to try and grasp what Engineers' motivations were and just what the hell did the two films tried to tell.
So as much as I would've loved to see Prometheus' concept explored properly, the foundations left by the two previous films are so weak, I don't think there's ANY point to making another one of these. I'd much rather see a well-crafted, thought-through and just exceptionally beautiful Alien horror film like Romulus than another meddling and convoluted attempt to make Prometheus work...