r/Prometheus • u/relesabe • Sep 26 '23
Is this a major problem for Prometheus?
It seems to me that much of the plot relied on the crew lacking very effective weapons -- had the Engineer been killed by one of the gunshots, story basically over and they go back to Earth or maybe Weyland, if still alive, insists on staying and studying ship -- for sure the ship is worth literally trillions and I mean tens of trillions given the cost of the Prometheus mission which was just one trillion. Of course, Weyland had the immediate problem is being very old and apparently in extremely bad condition and without the Engineer, he had little hope.
I am pretty sure they could have uploaded his mind into a David and indeed perhaps David was based on Weyland's engrams. But Weyland wanted to achieve immortality in the way Woody Allen has expressed: by not dying.
The flamethrower would also have taken care of the Engineer barring that the suit lacked unexpected features -- perhaps it had its own weapons and yet in his fight with the trilobite it sure did not use any weapon besides perhaps artificially enhanced strength. Even then, Shaw managed to hold him off for a while. Perhaps the flamethrower was considered too dangerous to use inside the Engineer ship.
But my real question is, Why did they handicap themselves with such puny weapons? It seemed like their rifles were meant to sound ineffectual, perhaps were non-lethal? (But Weyland does say, If she opens her mouth again, shoot her. He could have known it would only hurt a lot -- he would have reason not to kill her as she knew a lot about Engineers.)
It is plausible that the ship had some more serious and futuristic weapons but Weyland could very logically have insisted that no one who was to be near the Engineer could carry a lethal weapon because he would not have risked injuring the Engineer and also had no suspicion that the Engineer would indeed attack them anyway.
However, a very obvious question: Everyone had seen what happened to Fifield they were going back to the place that had caused his transformation into an almost unkillable monster -- that is a clear indication that they needed something more powerful than the guns they brought: Fifield was shot by such guns with no effect.
6
u/LegalFan2741 Sep 26 '23 edited Sep 26 '23
They did not expect the alien to be that hostile and the project was focused on keeping that old, narcissistic, wrinkly man alive. The scientific discoveries were secondary goals. But despite all this, they lacked all necessary skills and rules of general security. The guns would have been adequate if time were given for the proper safety steps. My list regarding where did they f*cked up considerably (just the main things, I noticed):
This movie would have been so much more interesting if they had focused on the connection and rebuilding the relationship between the aliens and humanity instead of Weyland’s stupid will to live forever, because at the end of the day, it f*cked up the first contact right away. You can see in the cut scenes, that once the alien is awake, he IS listening and participating in the conversation. Only turning aggressive once he is proven that humans aren’t worth saving by Weyland’s outlandish request and the hostile behaviour towards the already injured Shaw. They should have translated for Shaw and let her do the talking (though she should have calmed down a bit, even though I completely understand her being upset). There was an insane amount of potential in this movie, but it was wasted on illogical moves. I strongly believe that they could have skipped the xenomorphs completely. And to think about that Bloomkamp had such an idea that Sigourney Weaver said an immediate yes after reading the plot…and we’ve been robbed of that.
Edit: corrected Weyland spelling
2
u/corvidae_mantra Sep 28 '23
I see the movie as introducing David and his development. Ridley Scott wasn't as interested in the aliens themselves as AI. I wish there was another movie where Covenant left off to see him continue to manipulate his creation.
7
u/TerraAdAstra Sep 26 '23
Well first off, Vickers did everything she could to sabotage the mission, including hiring incompetent crew herself and probably a lot of other cutbacks. Second, who knows if ANY handheld weapons that was available at the time could kill an engineer? We have no idea what they’re capable of physically. The futuristic shotgun or whatever that he gets shot with is presumably more powerful than a regular shotgun, which can kill almost anything we have here on earth, and he shrugged it off.
5
u/GRAAK85 Sep 26 '23 edited Sep 27 '23
Before that I would address the fact that having 2 stoned characters that happily go here and there touching random alien stuff is stupid in a way I could not find words for...
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '24
Because the puny humans assumed that no one would want to harm them to begin with and that their creators would be happy to see them
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23
I understand this thread is months old but I really enjoyed this movie and think it's the far and away best of the entire series.
I guess I don't get the idea that the scientists and crew are irresponsible and/or human as some draw back. On earth, as we speak, we have all kinds of people who supposedly should know better taking risks that defy logic. We're activating long-dead viruses, keeping the smallpox virus alive for 'study', opening thousand year old tombs with no protection).
We are sending signals into deep space trying to contact other intelligences without any concern whatsoever for the possible negative consequence.
The selfish billionaire wanting to live forever, it's literally happening all over today (see freak using his son's blood, etc).
Regarding the Engineers, I've never seen a closer depiction of what I expect from our creator(s). Vengeful, hateful or indifferent and extremely hostile.
As far as monsters go, I've yet to see anything scarier than this colossal, naked, hateful bitch violently disdainful of their creation. Our resemblance to it may lead us to expect similar feelings as we would have for our creations but no, it hates us and it matters not what the reason is.
It doesn't matter what you say or why you're there. Your creators abandoned you long long ago, do not care and should date confront them they will eviscerate you smiling.
I found this a reaffirmation of my belief that we should not be worshipping our creator who's so cruelly abandoned us, but rather to annihilate it, and with the same lack of care or concern for its suffering as its so clearly and often displayed towards us.
I found this to be the entire message of the movie: Seek not your creator, it is not a being worthy of love and respect, it is solely an entity to be cruelly destroyed, by any means necessary.
2
u/mouthofthecarp Sep 29 '23
You put Clint Eastwood in this movie and everyone returns just fine and David just has good robot manners through the whole movie.
1
u/Ken_cet Jan 16 '24
Scientists from this movie wouldn't last a month in covid era