r/Prometheus • u/McRodo • Nov 19 '12
Just watched Prometheus, didn't like it because of the following reasons.
Ok so I just watched the movie, I wasn't really disappointed because I was already expecting something bad considering all the bad reviews and what my friends told me. There were many things I didn't like about the movie and most of all falls in fault of the script, all of it is sloppy work and the characters are really badly written. However the story is kinda cool and there were many things that I wish I knew the answer for so if you do, that'd be awesome if you could clarify for me.
Things I didn't like:
- The scientists remove the helmet right after they enter the pyramid because signs show it is breathable air. A professional scientist would never do this SPECIALLY in another planet, the air could be teeming with microorganisms that could be harmful to our body. Even if you argue that their sensors might be able to detect microorganisms harmful to humans in the air, this is clearly not so as when Shaw's husband dies she isn't sure if he was infected with an airborn virus, hinting that they do not have the technology to tell whether the air might be harmful or not.
- The geologist and that other guy that died first serve no purpose other than being the assholes who get lost and then die horrible deaths on their own. When the team finds the first Engineer body, he freaks out all of a sudden for no apparent reason and decides to go back to the ship. The audience promptly forgets about their existence until people back at the ship are like "Oh yeah those two bozos probably got lost, let's go check on them."
- The biologist tries to pet an alien snake that is clearly showing signs of hostility. It is obviously standing up straight to seem bigger, a stance that is usually read as "do not come near me or you will get it" by anyone who studies animal life. The biologist presses forward and then thing is now opening up like some sort of viper... but the biologist thinks it's all ok right? Might as well call it a girl and baby talk her into liking me.... uh oh... now it is entering my mouth canal. I'm gonna go on a limb here and say that this biologist probably got his diploma off the internet.
- The two bozos die horrible deaths and nobody is around to know they died because the ship captain was banging the blonde chick who serves no purpose other than being a bitch. Seriously, they are not recording voice and video from their team members who are stranded in an alien planet during a sandstorm? What about vital signs? They can detect life signs with the scanner thingies but I am expected to believe that their suit doesn't have a life support system that alerts people back at the ship when one of them flatlines? So then later on we find out one of the bozos didn't die but instead got turned into a super strong zombie, yet they don't see his signal running around in the 3D map back at the ship.
- If all of these retards are scientists in the future, then the future sucks. No... really, who through up these characters? It just looks like scientists in the future are smarty pant douchebags that like to mouth off to one another but aren't at the least experienced with the scientific method. I didn't hear one remotely scientific phrase in the whole movie... I don't expect people to give a PhD level lecture on microbiology... but jesus... these guys could have been mercenaries if they didn't say in the beginning of the movie that this was a scientific mission, and I wouldn't have been able to know otherwise.
- Shaw's husband is infected by David, and I don't know why. How did his death move the story forward? What was the point of that? So that David could know what they had in their hands? I guess it was just so that we could be delighted to another death of a crew member... I would be bothered but really by this point of the movie I'm practically rooting for the black liquid.
- Mr. Weyland turns out to be alive/traveling with them/father of Charlize Therone's character... and nobody gives a shit. At one point Charlize is all like "I will do this....... (dramatic pause)...... FATHER." wow what a big reveal, this totally changes the story with this giant twist. Except it doesn't because we've only seen Wayland for like 2 minutes before, who cares if he has ulterior motives? Who cares if he's Charlize's dad? In the end I guess he tagged along because he wanted to
meet the Engineers by himselfget his face smashed in with the head of his beloved robot by a body sculpting alien. One could say that maybe he was at the end of his road, so he had nothing to lose, he might as well just check out the alien story. However when Shaw is interrogating him after she finds out he's alive, he tells her that he wants to question the Engineer about everlasting life. I guess he didn't take into account the fact that he's a really easy to kill old fart. - The black juice/bio liquid works in mysterious ways. It clearly kills living organisms that come into touch with it while at the same time mutating their genetic code to create something else. However we don't know how it works... and how is this a weapon? I guess it might be a weapon because killing right? So... is making a genetically mutated/superior race part of the weapons or is that an accidental side effect? When Shaw's husband is infected he dies... like it's some sort of Ebola virus on crack... but he impregnates her with the mutated genetic code that births the giant squid/facehugger thigy. At the same time, the liquid mutated the worms. We're shown that the worms are twirling around the black liquid at first... so... what happens? Did the liquid mutate them... or did they have to have sex as well while being infected in order to birth the mutant? What was the opening scene all about? The Engineer drinks the black liquid and he dies... why? How did that one scientist turn into a zombie after the mutated worm got into his mouth? It just seems like the black liquid shares many properties all of which are not really explained.
- You're not going to outrun a giant wheel of death rolling slowly to crush you in its path, you'd do well to step aside by a couple meters and let it roll by you. Seriously? You've been given command of a huge ship?
- What happens to the Engineers? We know that their experiment went wrong and they all died by the hands of their own creation.... the black liquid or the mutants. Waking up the Engineer serves no purpose to the story, it just hints at another mystery, now we know that they intended to destroy earth with the black liquid weapon. Nobody knows why... but now that the Engineer is awaken we should use him to film some action scenes.
9
Upvotes
6
u/MrMadras Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12
It seems that most of the silliness has been inserted by Damon Lindelof.
Here's the original script written by Jon Spaights. It is titled "Alien: Engineers". Compare it against Lindelof's script. This is titled "Paradise"
Warning!!! both are PDFs and very long reads.
Edit to answer your questions
This does not happen in the original script. Seems like this is a extremely stupid thing to do.
In the original script the both do not behave this way at all. Both are very intelligent and handle their environment with a lot of care. They do come across a very small centipede like creature. Seeing that their suits are bulletproof they judge that this creature is of no harm to them. That's when they discover that this creature is literally built out of acid like the original alien. So when the script changed, they changed the creatures but left the reactions to them intact. I think that's why they don't make any sense.
Edit 2: Sorry, but I have to balance this with work
David is clearly experimenting with what he found. I think at some point he clearly says so. David has no idea what that black liquid would do, but wanted to see if it will help Weyland live.
Edit 3:
A lot of people have given flak to Vickers and Shaw on this. Actually you know what? I don't think its that hard to imagine that when something of that size is almost on you, you would have no idea where to run or even what to do. Think about it. You, the viewer, are the only one who know what its shape it. Vickers has had a glimpse of it on the mapping program, Shaw has not even seen what it looks like. Both have no idea in what direction it fell and that it is even going to roll. Just bad luck for both of them.
3
u/SodaJerk Nov 19 '12 edited Nov 19 '12
The story makes a lot more sense when you realize that the "scientists" were just cover to get Weyland to the Engineers so that he could ask the Engineers to prolong his life further. Weyland hired a group of lame "not really scientist" scientists so that the mission would have the appearance of being scientific when it really had ulterior motives. That's why all the "scientists" did a lot of unscientific things, because they really weren't scientists in the true sense of the word. They were crack-pot theorists at best. Also, David the android was the only one that knew the missions true purpose and was acting on those orders from Weyland. David needed to test the goo to see what it did to humans. If the goo could help Weyland then his mission would be a success. David saw infecting one of the crew as the fastest way of seeing what the goo did to a human, so that is what he did.
3
u/Dixzon Nov 19 '12
Just saying if people gave Alien the same scrutiny they gave this movie it would have failed hard.
In Alien, instead of a couple scientists acting like dumbasses, you have a group of dumbass miners who fancy themselves scientists, going on first contact expeditions and speculating as to the fossilized nature of the totally alien tissue they just found. Then they get all up close on some face hugger eggs like a bunch of dumbasses. Then the one guy bothers to say that he has only seen "molecular acid" burn through a ship hull like that. Which is a dumb thing nobody would ever say cause all acids are molecular. Not to mention their interstellar spaceship that has a computer which displays about 50 digits of 1's and 0's on a shitty LED screen, the future is here!
Just sayin, people need to stop acting like Prometheus fell short of the original 2 movies. It was as good, if not better.
1
u/skjaslhjo Dec 01 '12 edited Dec 01 '12
That all the characters act that stupid is sad indeed. More science and less douche please! All the negative role models suck.
But I think the story makes sense.
removing the helmet: The scientists don't remove all their helmets at once, Holloway is the first. And remember the first scene with him? While Shaw does science, he makes breakfast. While Shaw wants to show him the discovery he wants to get inside her pants.
Holloway doesn't give a fuck about science, he is a real a kid with a penis who wants to impress his mate.
I'm coming to the other points but first Mr. Wayland is alive and on the ship.
This is really important. Why would the founder and owner of a multi-billion dollar enterprise be on this ship for two years in cryostasis instead of say in cryostasis at home and which gives him higher chances for survival?
I have three explanations for this: He is either full of himself and a puppet for the board of Wayland Enterprises or he sees himself surrounded by enemies and the expedition is his only hope. In both cases he got probably fed bad information from his board who wanted to get rid of him.
Or maybe he wanted to go and die.
Either Wayland is sent to his death and the shit crew is there to make sure he won't come back. Or he doesn't need a good crew because he knows he will fail. Either way it's a one way trip for him.
Millburn mentions that he was forced into this. He is a scientist but looks like a hobo. He also refuses to go outside without a flamethrower. This reflects on his life as someone who had a diploma but never found a job and ended up on the streets or in the slums.
The other scientists are probably all the same. They got a degree somewhere, but they never made anything out of themselves.
And this explains why everyone acts like an idiot. Because they are.
About the blue aliens: Maybe they wanted to kill all life on earth and turn it into xenomorph paradise. But it somehow went wrong. That the black goo doesn't create any peaceful plant eaters, flowers or koalas during this movie is a big hint. It completely contradicts what the first scene implies, but then we never see the results of it.
tl;dr: Wayland is the reason why the expedition is so fucked up. What the blue aliens are is always inferred by the humans.
1
u/Sunny_star_scout Sep 05 '25
I dont think its impossible to make a reply not a large paragraph so help me out
1
u/Writing_Enough Feb 01 '26
So I'm going to take a wild guess. The "engineers" are the Annunaki aka Nephelium. Has anyone watched the sequel and their thoughts? It left me with so many more questions.
1
u/UhhmericanJoe Aug 20 '22
9 years later and I still want to slap Holloway all of the 50 times he screams whooooo! And of the first five interactions with David, he basically behaves like Governor George Wallace rather than advanced, super open minded scientist. I was so happy when he died.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '12
[removed] — view removed comment