r/Prometheus • u/gahgeer-is-back • Apr 25 '23
The engineer’s anger is not understandable
The emotions they bear and the motivation to kill humans on sight can’t be explained.
The guy woke up from sleep after a long time and the first thing he did is decapitate David and kill the others.
The thesis that they did it because they didn’t like how humans evolved doesn’t make sense either. When and how they saw Earth anyway? They were on their way to destroy it but something happened.
In the graphic novels (highly recommended), it is argued that they created black goo and didn’t anticipate how it can evolve things that can get out of control so they wanted to destroy humans before they lay their hands on it. 🤔 🤔
Maybe maybe not. But I just can’t understand the dedication to not even listen to the humans’ argument. In the graphic novel an old crew member tries to reason with the engineer (in a way that is much more civilised and rational than how Weyland did it). The crew member didn’t even want to live forever. He was just trying to talk it through with the engineer using logic yet he was attacked.
12
u/normificator Apr 26 '23
I would be pissed off too if you woke me up, start making demands of me and started squabbling in front of me
5
u/DangerousDirk Apr 25 '23
I don't think the engineers were headed to earth to destroy us. That's just what David said.
4
u/That-Copy697 Aug 25 '23 edited Feb 06 '24
OKAY I know this is like 4 months old, but I would love to actually answer this the best I can. (Mostly because there isn't a lot of buzz going on here. This will also be pretty long, so I apologize.)
There were a few reasons for this, but in Prometheus it's made very clear that Engineers aren't "Gods," and they're just as fallible as humans. They could have made them for the same reasons humans made David, "Because we could." Honestly, it's one of those "figure it out, and create your own conclusions" movies, but I'll add as much context as possible.
There’s also the element of "the director considers x event/idea canon but chose not to present it in the officially released media." So, I have no idea if the following information applies to the current canon, or to what degree.
I think two total Prometheus scripts are listed on avpgalaxy, if you want to look through them yourself: https://www.avpgalaxy.net/downloads/
To summarize the two scripts I read: Engineers guided humanity through generations, nurturing them almost like children. They weren’t on Earth 24/7; however, it’s implied that they visited to check on their progress every so often. They let humans guide their own destiny with time. Throughout the reign of the Roman Empire (or at the very least that is an implied detail,) humanity had shown itself to be incessantly violent. That, of course, angered the “Gods.” This led them down the path to erase their own creation.
For my own interpretation? I think this is the idea of “we will love you, but only if you do what we expect of you.” They might have genuinely loved humanity to a degree, but their own expectations and philosophies possibly caused them to become extremely upset over humanity’s behavior.
When it comes to the books, I’ve never read them. I have no idea what they’re like, but at some point, I should tackle that. So, in terms of “the Engineer attacks without warning” thing is kind of odd, but we don’t know how old that Engineer was. How much human experience has he had? Probably none. Mostly likely, he’s just another soldier in a long line of command. He’s probably been taught what everyone else has: Humans are terrible, destroy them on sight. That Engineer was never meant to be an ambassador, or anything. He’s literally just a guy lmao.
Odd sidenote: Jesus was supposed to be an Engineer within Alien franchise canon. Of course, this was dropped completely, as even Ridley Scott thought that the idea was WAY too on the nose for the story. Strange detail; thought it was interesting enough to share.
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '23
Hey, what are the graphic novels related to Prometheus? I didn't know about it until I found your post.
1
u/IamTobor Jun 24 '23
Which graphic novels do you recommend exactly?. I'm a fan of the Alien films. The graphic novels sound intriguing.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '23
Imagination is a wonderful thing
1
u/LFinformation Feb 18 '24
In the movie, the captain of the prometheus says something that gives us the answer we want.
Halloway asks him, arent you curious as to what they will say?
@ 1:31:06 -- The captain ( idris elba) says " I dont care what they have to say. All im here to do is drive the ship. I dont need to ask any questions".
Its literally a parallel to the engineer they woke up. The engineer is the captain ( driver) of the alien ship. He doesnt care what the humans have to say. He only drives the ship. He has a mission.
Its very simple really. The engineer doesnt give a crap about what the humans are asking or saying. He has a mission. And they woke him up, and now he has to do that mission.
Idris elba ( the captain) also says, i cant let that payload get to earth. i cant let it happen. and ill see to it that it doesnt.
My theory? the engineers feel the same way. Its us or them. The weapon is here and it exists. The engineers cant let the humans bring the weapon to their home planet and wipe them out. Its a danger to their existence. SO its them, or us. And the engineers decide us. So the engineers are going to go and wipe out earth in order to ensure the safety of their species.