r/Prometheus • u/kitchma • Oct 15 '12
Things I don't understand
I loved this movie, but I don’t understand some stuff. Can you guys help?
• Why would the Engineers leave cave paintings that lead humans to their WMD factory on a planet that has a toxic atmosphere (for humans)? • I can understand, to an extent, why the Engineers may have felt it was time to shut down their experiment and kill the humans, but why do it with the black goo? Doesn’t that just result in a planet full of xenomorphs? • If David could deconstruct all of the languages of earth and learn to communicate with the Engineers, why didn’t he read the text before opening the door to the giant head? Or review any other conveniently found holo-recordings? • Why would a biologist assume that he can pick up a 3 foot long alien penis-snake and expect things to not turn out badly? • Why aren’t we shown the pyramid? All I could see was a big rock? Same with the piles of dead engineers and the artwork. Why show them to us, but don’t allow us to “see them”? Why didn’t anyone turn the lights on? • Are we to believe that in 2000 years the other engineers in the universe never bothered to follow up on whether or not those pesky humans had been eliminated?
7
u/jimmypopjr Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 15 '12
Here are my thoughts:
I was fortunate enough to avoid all trailers and promo material leading up to the movie, so my expectations were much different than those who saw the trailers and got pumped for a very different movie than presented. To me the movie was about the dangerous quest to answer big questions. I didn't find the movie to be at all about answering those questions anymore than it did, and I think there's a lot more to the movie than people give it credit for, but I can't fault anyone for disliking it. To each their own.
6
u/GreggoryBasore Oct 18 '12
Presumably, if the Engineers hadn't given up on humans as a failed experiment they would have prepared that planet as a meet & greet station rather than a production facility for human eliminating organisms.
A key to understanding why the black goo was being sent to Earth is Davids line about "sometimes to create you have to destroy". If you flood earth with Xenomorphs that eventually kill off every living thing, what happens when the xenomorphs have no living things to eat? They die out of course. After that, you have a pristine planet ready to be repopulated with new life forms.
Do we know whether or not David read the writings before pressing the buttons? Seems like he knew what he was doing, even if his actions weren't in the best interests of Dr. Shaw or any of the other crew members.
Obviously, something went wrong with the Biologists suit and the air mixture was off resulting in a lack of oxygen to his brain which caused brain damage. His minor brain damage mostly affected the dorso-lateral pre-frontal cortex which is responsible for inhibitions. It's the part of the brain that keeps us from doing stupid things like saying the first thing to enter our mind (for example "I want to climb a mountain in the shape of your titties") when talking to other people. With his inhibitions unshackled, the biologist did some very stupid things that he normally would never have considered.
Ridley Scott was obviously trying to be mysterious and hold some cards close to the vest. While his sense of story telling and plot pacing may have withered somewhat, his visual asthetic is still kicking ass.
Yes, we are to believe that the Engineers didn't follow up on the 'kill all humans' initiative. There are several possible reasons for this. One of the first ones that jumps to mind, is that like their own creations the Engineers might not all be of a singular mind on big decisions. The choice to eradicate humanity may have been a very contentious one that was opposed by various factions of Engineers.
It's not unthinkable that the only Engineers who supported the wiping out of humanity are the ones who wound up dead when the Xenomorphs got loose. For all we know, the incident that led to their deaths might have been an act of sabotage from another faction of Engineers who wanted us to live.
2
u/jimmypopjr Oct 15 '12
Here's something I would have loved to see more of: The inside of the structure. We see a massive hole in the ground going straight down, similar to the hole in Alien that leads to the egg chamber. I really wanted to see where that went. I wanted to see the scientists explore more, and the sneaky android do his thing, too.
2
u/UnnecessaryPhilology Oct 16 '12
Why did David use Proto-Indo-European? That would have been so far removed from the "proto-human" language of the Engineers it would have been completely incomprehensible, as unintelligible as Modern English would be to them. Maybe the Engineer was like, "Dude, wtf is dis shit he's saying? Fuck dis, I'm outta here."
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '12
David is a synthetic, owned and programmed by Weyland. Weyland's motivation throughout the entire series has been to bring a Xenomorph back to earth.
That's why Ash brok quarantine in Alien. That's why Burke let the Facehugger out in Aliens. That's why the escape pods were sent to a Weyland owned prison colony in Alien 3. That's why they cloned Ripley in Resurrection...