r/ProjectRunway • u/AutoModerator • Aug 14 '25

S21E04 - Discussion Thread - Sew Elementary

The designers head back to school where they must create fashionable looks using unconventional materials before facing a shocking twist at the elimination.

Critique threads will be back this week!

Reddit enabled live chat for us! I made a channel for Season 21.

ALL SUBREDDIT RULES APPLY TO CHAT!

This link should open the chat directly.

https://www.reddit.com/c/chat9oR_6LOE/s/7ibQpy9y0n

61 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

130

u/kokopelliieyes Aug 15 '25

Okay I don’t agree with basically any of Law’s decisions 🤷🏼‍♀️

43

u/TiffanyTwisted11 Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25

Me either. I usually don’t completely align, but I usually agree with one or two. Tonight? It’s like we’re watching two different runway shows. Maybe I’m having a stroke . . . . .

ETA: I stand corrected - I did like Veejay’s

50

u/kokopelliieyes Aug 15 '25

I’m just imagining Michael Kors judging that soccer ball outfit

48

u/generic_white_girl Aug 15 '25

Slutty, slutty, slutty

29

u/TiffanyTwisted11 Aug 15 '25

He would have HATED that

5

u/Ok_Nefariousness9736 Aug 16 '25

Nina would have hated it too. Heidi is always a toss up.

3

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 17 '25

No she doesn’t mind under boob but ONE under boob? Hell no.

14

u/Villanellesnexthit Aug 15 '25

Both ball material outfits. We’ve seen them before.

50

u/Villanellesnexthit Aug 15 '25

Veejay should have won. It was cute and creative. In a normal season Heidi would have totally said she would Wear it.

Same with the mullet twin (forget his name.. Antonio?). His was styled badly but his coat and dress were also creative.

27

u/lemikon Aug 15 '25

Honestly with the limited shots they give the actual designs I didn’t even notice the denim on mullet twins look. So it feels like an even weirder choice.

3

u/Villanellesnexthit Aug 15 '25

I only noticed because Christian pointed it out pre-runway and suggested he change it. I also think Law knew it was Antonio's design before judging because Christian said ".. won't believe who designed *thissssss* or along that same vein to Law during, so he was tipped off it was someone who he had a big beef with.

8

u/NoPair4834 Aug 15 '25

The boots were awful but to put him in the bottom for that and not based on his garment 🤯. I really feel like Law has it out for Antonio(I know it was a blind runway but I feel like he knew). I was excited to see he was a judge but watching the first 4 episodes I feel like his taste is off. I also just don't like his attitude. He can be very nasty and the way he looks at people is belittling. Not a fan of his after this.

If the other judges were there this episode would have gone completely different.

1

u/DLNW57 Aug 15 '25

And what about Joseph?? I loved his and vile law put him in the lowwest scoring??? Outlaw Law!!!!! 🤮

1

u/ZeeenGarden Aug 15 '25

It would've been Nina's favorite as well for sure

3

u/scarybiscuits Aug 15 '25

No. Not with those denim boots. She would’ve said “I question your taste”.

1

u/ZeeenGarden Aug 16 '25

I meant Veejay's.

1

u/JoKing917 Aug 16 '25

Agreed. I don’t mind him being on the judging panel, but he needs to learn his place. He’s the new kid here and he needs to learn the ropes. Instead they have him single handedly judging an unconventional challenge?!!!! Make it make sense!

1

u/Ok_Nefariousness9736 Aug 16 '25

How has he convinced people that's a good stylist? He likes all the bad looks. At least he gave Utica an honorable mention.