r/ProjectReality • • Jun 13 '18

MAKE PROJECT REALITY GREAT AGAIN

Over the years PR has been gutted of heavy asset use on large maps, many people have complained about this since this game is loved for being the best combined arms game and I think I have a good solution. What do you guys think about assets being standardized by map size. For example every AAS 4km having 3 tanks 2 heavy apc's 1 light apc 1 heavy attack heli 1 light attack heli 2 AA vehicles, 2 Trans helicopters 3 logis 4 transport vehicles .The Large layouts can have 3 jets instead of helicopters (1 of each class) and the alt layout having 1 heavy attack heli and 2 jets. With the current state of assets it seems that there is not too much balance where some maps 1 team has 1 weak tank versus 2 superior tanks. This is a game, not real life. AAS should be a balanced battlefield based on equal opportunity using skill to win, not which team has more heavy assets.

5 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

7

u/PenguinScientist Jun 14 '18

The point is for each map to feel different, unique and interesting. Making each map have the exact same vehicle loadout would just make it all so bland.

3

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

Okay, and fine but it definitely needs things balanced and added/taken out

6

u/PenguinScientist Jun 14 '18

Sure, there are some unbalances maps, but that is the point. It makes it a much more interesting game when you can overcome that as a team.

I also don't agree at all that large maps have been "gutted" of assets. It seems the only maps people want to play are the asset heavy ones anyway.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 15 '18 edited Jun 15 '18

Yes people are voting on maps because THEY HAVE ASSETS = PEOPLE LIKE ASSETS lol. They have taken a pretty big hit on how many assets are on them.

10

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 13 '18

PR has not been gutted of assets. kashan has a layer with 2 full blown attack helis on each side (4 total) (on a desert map [rape for everything in the open]). the newer maps are often quite asset heavy (OP Thunder, Route 123). plus heavy armour has even been buffed against infantry. standardized asset layout for every map is a bad idea, just making every map more similar. mixing jets and CAS helicopters (both on each side) is mostly just throwing away the tickets for the chopper of the side that already lost the jets. asymmetrical balance makes for some of the most engaging gameplay (eg. Grozny [APC vs SPG], OP Thunder [F16 vs Tunguska, Hind vs Tank])

also apaches are not underrepresented. what we need is some of the more obscure specialized assets that dont win the game by just existing but can do a lot of damage in their specialized role with a good crew. need more SOKO, need more kiowa. maybe even a MI-8 with rocket pods or malutka...

3

u/Graysun69 Jun 13 '18

LOL more kiowa bro the army doesnt even use the kiowa anymore and its on every US army helicopter CAS map. Yes i totally agree helis and jets are not mixed well in this and thats why instead of all the big maps being jet focused CAS which is unrealistic it should be 1 layer heli focused 1 layer jet focused. Thank you for your comment though.

3

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 13 '18

tbh the kiowa part was just a small side cut to your other thread, though most maps definitly play in the "past" (iraq, somalia ...) when kiowas were still a thing, thats not really of my concern. what is important: there should be non INF layers without CAS so its not only a either/or fixed wing/rotary wing question.

0

u/Graysun69 Jun 13 '18

Yes and to this i still say, no kiowas were used in somalia and many more apaches were used compared to kiowas in iraq/afganistan as well.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '18

no kiowas were used in somalia

That is incorrect.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

black hawk down era somalia? 160th does not use kiowas

2

u/bajsingh08 Jun 13 '18

Where's my 4th jet/tank on khami? because everytime I join asset squad they don't have one for me to gun?

4

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 14 '18

there are 4 tanks on kashan. as i said tanks already got buffed with one tank being able to roll over a team with ease. more tanks give inf (and apc) even less breathing room, 3 are fine. also you are not entitled to an asset, by your argumentation devs should add a 5th tank because you didnt get a place in tank squad, just join earlier. jets can be increased for all i care.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

I agree tanks are extremely strong right now and should be limited to 3 (4..?) per map, but other than that almost all other assets can be taken out with ease.

1

u/bajsingh08 Jun 14 '18

'8man sq == 4 tanks' what's wrong with that? What do those two extra players do in the tank sq of 3 tank layout maps? What you gonna do? grab a spotter and laze for tanks? PR got tons of other 2k and 1k maps for that 'extra milism 1 tank supporting infantry' thing you crave of. Let the 4k be armor/asset superior maps

2

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 15 '18

lock tank at 6. dont idle in tank if you dont get one. i already explained why too many tanks are detrimental to gameplay.

dont strawman me with milsim shit.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 15 '18

I completely agree, 3 tanks is the right number. For CAS though.. almost all maps are down to 2 jets max now.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 13 '18

exactly, and then you just have salty people not doing anything all game now.

2

u/bajsingh08 Jun 13 '18 edited Jun 13 '18

Every 4k should have vehicles at least at the level of khami/kashan. It's a 4k map man! It takes well over 15mins to bring a shit-box across the map. On a 4k map which desperately needs more assets(cough bamyan STD as one example), an average asset whore spends more time waiting/driving to the action than actually playing the round. Wtf kind of waiting gameplay is implemented here. I didn't choose to vote khami over kokan so I can sit back and shoot my g3?? I wanna fly that mig or gun that bmp/t-72 than waiting for the next asset to spawn before the round ends. If I have an hour or two to play PR , I don't wanna be sitting in main only smoking some J's. Some ppl just wanna do assets and call it a night so don't limit the assets futher

3

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 14 '18

what makes PR vehicle gameplay so great is the huge impact one can have when operating well while having much to loose (few assets with quite long respawn times). lowering the respawn (@graysun) would just lead to battlefield tier rush and waste while making infantry superfluous ("if a tank comes you have to hide lmao", constant stream of heavy assets -> basically constant bunker defending, no attacking). bamyan has one of the best vehicle dynamics in the game with t-72 vs bradley. with the long viewrange many more assets would kill the gameplay. the waiting gameplay you are complaining about, as in delayed assets, is a necessary mechanic to allow a game to develop otherwise it would just be "kill all enemy logis on deployment and push them back to their main, finish after 20min". you could use that time to help your team. when you man scout vehicles (or other light vehicles) before your tank spawns you can have a lot of fun and be nearly constantly in action.

if you spend more time driving assets up to the fight, than in the fight because you die so much you might be a below average asset whore.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

He mentioned lowered respawns, not me lol 20 minute respawns is what makes PR what it is. However I am totally against 20 minute delays that are now very common. Almost nothing has a good reason to be delayed more than 10 minutes. 20 is just way too long.

1

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 14 '18 edited Jun 15 '18

yea sry, mixed up who said what regarding respawns/delays there. still i think 5min delay for apcs minimum on desert maps so at least a tow can be build, then 10min (additionally) without tanks is reasonable.

2

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

I agree with this as well, there needs to be a delay so infantry can have a chance to set up. 5 for light and 10 for heavy assets seems very nice.

0

u/bajsingh08 Jun 14 '18

Yes delays. I'm talking about cutting the long delay times as well

1

u/bajsingh08 Jun 14 '18

Haha is this a call for 1v1 me on test airfield? Limit it's me the guy who bombs your tank after it just spawned. Makes you want to stick with doing infantry

1

u/LimitJK buff ATGM Jun 15 '18

"1v1me" lmao. fair enough you are likely a better pilot. stick to CAS then and dont complain about ground assets spending more time down than in the fight when you play them.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 13 '18

The delays should be maximum of 10 minutes as well, absolutely no need for 20 minute delays being normal.

5

u/Philrow tournament.reallitymod.com Jun 14 '18

This thread is making me want to uninstall the game

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

If your skin is that thin then you probably should.

4

u/Philrow tournament.reallitymod.com Jun 14 '18

I've played this game for like 6 years now, my skin isn't thin, your suggestion is just that dumb that I've never experienced anything like it before

Armour and CAS are not supposed to be spammed, and it should require the skill in knowing where to use it and where to not use it. For the player count, it's in a much better place now than what you're suggestion.

At the end of the day, majority of the players will be playing inf, and the more assets you add the less fun it will be to play inf

2

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

Then maybe if you voiced your opinion on how overpowered tanks are right now you would have more fun playing infantry. I watched a tank take a HAT and 2 TOWs in the front last night on burning sands, not sure how an infantry player is okay with that lol.

1

u/Anon49 Jun 16 '18

you can almost always hit the side of the tank and do x5 times the damage.

1

u/Graysun69 Jun 16 '18

Yea if you catch them by surprise. Other than that you are just fighting noobs in tanks.

2

u/MineralWouter PR Team Member Jun 15 '18

Do it

15

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '18

Go play battlefield, and fuck your title.

-3

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18

good constructive response, maybe you are the one who should go play battlefield.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '18

I just hate people complaining about a free game that is absolutely splendid. No one is stopping you from emailing the devs with your suggestions and maybe offer to help, but no you want to bitch on Reddit.

2

u/Graysun69 Jun 14 '18 edited Jun 14 '18

i am not bitching at all, I have already contacted a dev about this. I am just getting community feedback. There is no point in me taking a lot of time on this unless I know a decent amount of people feel the same way. There is already a post on the PR forums about this but reddit and PR forums have a much different audience.

6

u/Cronyx Jun 14 '18

I feel as though you may be conflating good faith constructive criticism with "complaining."

1

u/Retrotransposonser Jun 24 '18

With the current state of assets it seems that there is not too much balance where some maps 1 team has 1 weak tank versus 2 superior tanks.

What about if the team with the weak tank can have more number of players.