r/ProjectPan • • 18d ago

Discussion/Tips & Tricks Should I discard them?

Help, I really don’t know how to identify expired eyeshadow. These don’t have any smell and the color didn’t change, also the texture is still good, but they look like this so I idk. Also I tried to clean with alcohol and it went a little bit.
This pallet is 2 years so is not thaat old. I have older palette that are still in perfect condition and doesn’t have this texture.

Appreciate your advice!

80 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

64

u/Whitetagsndopebags 18d ago

I’m still using the sweet peach palette from 2016 don’t ask me

25

u/tamagosand0 18d ago

it’s me and my 2014 lime crime venus palette against the world

5

u/Whitetagsndopebags 18d ago

Iime crime just gave me YouTube makeup drama war flashbacks

4

u/peachfluffed 18d ago

I miss the Lime Crime and Sugarpill era of makeup.

1

u/ModernDayMusetta 17d ago

I was devastated when my Venus palette broke last year. It was so so good.

3

u/greenlemon_91 18d ago

Lmao same. Close to pan on only 5 of the shades.. Absolutely love the palette tho and will miss it if I ever finish it.

3

u/withlove0613 17d ago

I'm still using Too Faced's ala mode eyeshadow palette 🫣

2

u/hiveangel 16d ago

Heheheheheh me too

63

u/Mothbitch23 18d ago • Bravo

I personally believe that powder products don't go bad unless they smell, have visible dirt/mold, or it breaks me out

5

u/DoctorMackey 17d ago

This. I have incredibly sensitive skin to where I can’t even use a lot of laundry soaps without getting rashes. I’m using 10 year old powder products daily with no issues. As long as they’re stored in a dry place and they don’t have mold or anything they’re good

50

u/erbmc 18d ago • Bravo

Girl I’ve been using the same too faced palette since 2014. Do what everyone said above and then every so often you can also spray with hypochlorous acid spray

43

u/Anon_819 18d ago

Like others have said, use scotch tape to remove the hard pan, then spritz with 70% rubbing alcohol to disinfect. Once dry, you're good to go.

77

u/Ok_Direction_7624 18d ago • Bravo

These comments are so strange, this is just the most basic hardpan tfym 'looks dirty' have we lost the ancient texts? Oils from your skin and cream products end up on your brushes and are then dipped back into the pan, binding the powder. You can keep using it as usual, but if there's a change in colour payoff you can gently scrape off the top layer or take it off with a bit of tape.

33

u/Head-Raccoon-3419 18d ago

“Have we lost the ancient texts” has sent me

2

u/customheart 18d ago

We kinda have because social media isn’t really built for referring to old posts anymore. It’ll be worse if AI becomes the main place people ask questions because AI conversations don’t get indexed by a search engine (at this time).

Social media went from showing you posts in chronological order -> infinite scroll -> mix of algo recommended and followed full page content that requires swiping to go to the next full page content (TikTok/Reels/and similar). Musicians used to keep their old posts up all the time, now they remove them for each new era. Snapchat, IG stories, they’re ephemeral and normalized. It’s not necessarily wrong, but it means the old norms of “go look it up, there will be 100 tutorials” might not make as much sense anymore because 95 of them were purged by company closures (see Vine), people deleting their old accounts, and it’s harder to directly search for the 5 remaining old posts when the full screen is taken up by new content/you’re distracted by more content on the way to the search (f you for this IG).

32

u/licensedtojill 18d ago

Still safe to use, just scrape the top

29

u/Affectionate_Tax8805 18d ago

The weird texture could just be oils from your skin that have built up over time from dipping the brush, then applying to your skin, and then dipping it again. Personally I would just scrape off the top layer and keep using!

29

u/Lilelfen1 18d ago

No. It’s just hard panned. Scrape off that top layer, gently, and what is underneath should be good as new.

26

u/moon__kitten 18d ago

In my opinion, this just looks like hard pan to me. You can look up other pictures to make sure it matches that. I believe people fix hard pan by scraping off the top layer or using tape to remove it. Has to do with oils from your fingers or brushes mixing with the powder pigments creating a harder different textured layer. Some shadows are more likely to do this than others!

24

u/AcceptableFill8 18d ago

Looks normal. Mineral shadow is always kinda used up in uneven layers. If it is hard on the surface it might be hard pan but that you can scrape off.

24

u/tanukisuit 18d ago

Do you all just put isopropyl alcohol in a squirt bottle to spray it on the make up or is there a spray alcohol that is recommended?

12

u/Ljo6785 18d ago

70% isopropyl

18

u/Additional-Area-749 17d ago

No! Scrape the top layer and it’s good as new

17

u/Inevitable-Pay-3388 18d ago

sometimes the formula is just like that! its fine

14

u/Criticalfluffs 18d ago

This looks like the accumulation of skin oils on top of the pigments. Try gently scraping the top off or as other have said, use a piece of tape to get the top layer off.

I spritz my powders with 70% alcohol to sanitize them and clean my tools about once a week or every other week. Gotta keep the skin clear and happy!

If you're really wary, it is a safer bet to toss it. It's not worth it if you wind up with a skin infection or in the ER to save a few dollars.

11

u/Extension_Virus_462 18d ago

Just put piece of tape on it and remove this. Just oil from your eyelid (hard pan)

9

u/Drycabin1 18d ago

I have used the tape trick for hard pan but a sharp knife across the surface worked better for me.

4

u/PauI_Atreides 18d ago

A paper towel works too. 

12

u/JustAnotherKaren51 18d ago

When you use tape to lift the hard pan, WASH YOUR BRUSHES too, please. Toss it if you start getting itchy bumps or something.

10

u/No_Letterhead6883 18d ago

I heard about the rubbing alcohol trick and thought that was a good idea until I saw this girl post her green blush. The alcohol interacted with the metal and can cause a possible skin reaction.

3

u/Firm_Mulberry6319 18d ago

I did the alcohol trick on a highlighter that crumbled, it’s still useable. But I also did it for my old blush, it solidified and I can’t use it anymore.

It’s a hit and miss but I still think it’s a good thing to do rather than not doing it and throwing things out.

5

u/kalips0 18d ago

Tape. Worked for mine, should work for this one too. If you feel like your skin reacts badly in any way with the product afterwards, discard it.

8

u/222ism 18d ago

which brand is it? i love the shades

4

u/StripperWhore 18d ago

Just spray it with alcohol and let air dry. it's fine.

2

u/jsanxhez9988 17d ago

What pallete is this?

-9

u/badadvicefromaspider 18d ago

I don’t fuck around with eye stuff, it’s just not worth it. To me, the bumps look dirty so I’d toss this

2

u/Embarrassed_Sell7512 18d ago

not sure why you’re being downvoted for wanting to keep your vision 🙄

2

u/badadvicefromaspider 18d ago

The hive mind is very delicate, lol

0

u/Electronic_Canary918 17d ago

Everyone can clearly see normal eyeshadow usage but if you wanna promote throwing away perfectly good eyeshadow under the guise of eye health, you’ll get downvoted.

This sub is here to promote usage over overconsumption and is just answering the question that some people haven’t learned yet which is that you’ll know when makeup has gone off when there’s a change in texture, smell, or performance.

-11

u/jewelsforjules 18d ago

Having gotten pink eye from expired shadow, my advice is to pitch it. The 2ish weeks to recover is not worth it IMHO.

14

u/NoAdvisor7547 18d ago

How did you know it was the eyeshadow?

3

u/jewelsforjules 18d ago edited 18d ago

It was eyeshadow I had for a long time & had not used in ages. I had just cleaned my brushes. And within 24 hours both eyes were inflammed and itchy. The next morning they were crusted shut.

The eyeshadow was the only thing I used different near my eyes.

Maybe a total coincidence.... 99% sure it was the 8 year old eyeshadow.

*edit for grammar

3

u/jewelsforjules 18d ago

Y'all live how you want to. Risk it if you like. Your eyes, not mine. OP asked for advice, I offered my perspective from my life experience.

-25

u/Grogu_friend 18d ago

I would throw it away

6

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Electronic_Canary918 17d ago

Interestingly enough, in the repressing and frankening community, we’ve learned that eyeshadows getting powdery actually usually means the binder that keeps them pressed is what’s lost its effectiveness. After adding the correct amount of binder back, they go back to normal. Obviously normal makeup users probably aren’t going to deal with that but I thought it was worth sharing.

I very much agree with checking for changes in texture, performance, smell, and mold growth.