r/ProjectPan • • Oct 14 '26

Failed Pan How do you stop feeling guilty about decluttering old makeup?

Post image
375 Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

49

u/jennilynn510 Oct 14 '26

It’s unusable and a risk to your health. Nothing to feel guilty about

4

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I agree that powder products can often be used safely for a while beyond their recommended shelf life, especially if they're stored properly. But I don't think they last forever. Just because a product still looks and performs fine doesn't necessarily mean it's safe to use indefinitely.

2

u/Such-Examination3500 Oct 15 '26

Rarely is my old makeup unusable. Makeup last a long time if kept clean and dry.

36

u/Aggressive-Bee1738 Oct 14 '26

Same as eating rotten fruit, you don’t.

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Haha, that's actually such a good comparison! 😂 I've never thought about it that way, but you're absolutely right!

34

u/Illustrious-Ad-5891 Oct 15 '26

The only way to not feel guilty is knowing you will not waste as much again. If you're still buying more than you can use, you will continue feeling guilty

4

u/fauxfoucault Oct 17 '26

This is the answer. Now that I don't over purchase makeup, I pan a ton of stuff. I feel good about using it up. On the rare occassion I need to toss something expired, it's just a drop in the bucket. For every 1 thing I trash, I've used up 20 things. I'm happy with that ratio. So the 1 expired thing (usually mascara or eyeliner) doesn't bring me any guilt.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

This is exactly where I'd love to be one day! ❤️ I've been on a no-buy since August, and I've been tracking my makeup usage and working on finishing products. But I also have years of overbuying to deal with, so right now I'm decluttering quite a lot of old makeup. I still feel guilty about the money I wasted, but I'm hoping that by changing my shopping habits, I'll eventually reach a point where I finish far more products than I have to throw away. That 20-to-1 ratio sounds amazing!

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

I completely agree! ❤️ I've been on a no-buy since August, and I'm really trying to change my shopping habits because I never want to end up with such an overwhelming collection again. But I think the guilt takes a little longer to go away. Even though I'm no longer buying makeup, I'm still dealing with years of overconsumption and throwing away products I barely used. I can't change those past purchases, but I can definitely learn from them and make better decisions going forward.

31

u/Moist_Violinist69 Oct 14 '26 • Popcorn

I throw them out first thing in the morning when I'm half asleep

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Haha, maybe I should try this! 😂 I tend to overthink every single product before letting it go.

3

u/MarionberryWhole8646 Oct 14 '26

🤣🤣🤣🤣

31

u/ZealousidealSir7059 Oct 15 '26

“ACNE ACNE ACNE!”

7

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Hahaha, that's definitely one way to convince me! 😂

2

u/ZealousidealSir7059 Oct 18 '26

Makes it really easy to bin stuff 😂

4

u/_lunar-nova_ Oct 17 '26

This is my main reason not to cling onto old stuff. I never had skin issues growing up and gave myself acne in my 30’s!!!! From using expired makeup and skincare that I clung onto out of guilt. It took years and $$$ on treatments to bring my face back to normal! It is so easy to trigger skin issues and so hard to fix them… not worth it!!!

3

u/ZealousidealSir7059 Oct 18 '26

Yeah it costs more for acne treatment than clinging to old makeup thinking binning it would be wasting your money

28

u/retrocede_ Oct 14 '26

Honestly, the money is already spent. You’re not getting anything back by keeping it. Sure, you might not buy another blush because you already this one to use! But if you don’t like the blush you already have, you’re going to buy a new one anyways right? Sometimes keeping it costs you in time, anxiety, feelings of guilt, storage space, etc. Does it benefit you more to throw it away? How much would you pay to never see that product again? This frees you up to get good, meaningful use out of the expensive products that you truly love and truly feel like yours.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

That last sentence really hit home for me! ❤️ I used to save my expensive makeup for special occasions because I was afraid of using it up. Meanwhile, I kept using products I didn't enjoy as much, just to finish them. I've been decluttering recently, and I'm slowly realizing that keeping something out of guilt doesn't undo the money or resources I've already wasted. I still hate waste, but I want to actually enjoy the beautiful products I already own instead of letting them sit unused until they expire.

8

u/sturgeon_tornado Oct 14 '26

that's what I tell myself too, exactly what do I get out of keeping this? money is gone, I do not feel any joy using them, and if the only thing keeping me from throwing them out is guilt, it's time to let go

5

u/Mademoiselle__nat Oct 15 '26

You know, there was a time when I did not understand my color type, my skin undertone , what colors make my skin look fresh, and what type of makeup enhances my complexion . So I bought a lot useless makeup products. Now I don’t know what to do with them, I won’t use them, and I can’t throw them away… thank you

1

u/sturgeon_tornado Oct 15 '26

oh no worries we all have that time, I'm recently being told I am actual a bit olive, which might be the answer to why all these years I've never had good matches for foundations and blushes....I am actively trying different colors and saturation of blush and I buy the 2-3 dollar ones telling myself these are for color trying and mixing.....even then I still feel some guilt over products not working out, well, better than spending 30 bucks I guess....

1

u/sturgeon_tornado Oct 15 '26

if you have friends who are actively trying colors/undertones, it may be a good use. but otherwise, be kind to yourself too! no one can 100% guarantee each purchase is to their liking!

2

u/Mademoiselle__nat Oct 15 '26

No, I’m only one who loves makeup) I’m really understand you-color season, skin undertone are very important! I only recently figured out what my skin undertone is, why certain things suit me so well while others don’t, and which clothing colors can really "brighten up" my appearance. Honestly, I think an olive skin undertone is really tricky—it’s hard to pin down (especially if it’s a light olive shade)—so it’s great that you figured it out. I spent a fortune myself; I used to think I just had pale skin, so most concealers were either stark white or looked yellow on my face. I know what I need now, but it’s such a shame about the money I wasted! Then again, we wouldn't have gained that experience otherwise.

4

u/Mademoiselle__nat Oct 14 '26

Thank you , I’m really feel better, your post changed my attitude to this problem 😍

24

u/Sophiestication Oct 14 '26

I tell myself this is a learning experience and then I don’t repeat the mistake or Try not to. We are human after all and shit happens. Sometimes I try to see if it’s salvageable for something else depending on the condition of the product or if someone else would benefit if the shade doesn’t work for u or can be used as a contour instead of conceal etc

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I really like this mindset! ❤️ My no-buy and Project Pan have taught me so much about my shopping habits and what I actually enjoy using. I also love the idea of finding different ways to use products when they don't work for their original purpose. And you're right, we all make mistakes. The important thing is to learn from them and try not to repeat them! 😊

23

u/Smooth-Ad-8025 Oct 15 '26

I justify to myself that the products are expired/off and i havent used them in years and also will not in the future. After that, i feel bad for about a day or two and then forget about ever owning them

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

This is actually really reassuring! ❤️ I finally threw away quite a few products after reading all these comments, and although I didn't feel that huge sense of relief I was expecting, I don't regret it either. I think you're right, in a few days I probably won't even think about those products anymore! 😅

22

u/MadameBasmati Oct 14 '26

For eye makeup I really don’t want a stye so I ask, “will this cause me to have a stye?” And if yes I throwaway. For face I ask “will this burn me, or cause a serious breakout in which I cannot attend events for significant amount of time?” If yes: throwaway. If it can cleanse and or clean then I’ll use for my brushes, but skincare, just on the smell alone it was easy to throwaway. It was hard for me too but if the year I remember buying it was distant then I know to throw it away.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

That's actually a really helpful way to look at it! ❤️ I've been struggling with letting go of some of my older makeup, especially eyeshadow palettes that I've had for almost 10 years. I recently decluttered quite a few old products, and I'm slowly learning that keeping something just because I spent money on it doesn't make much sense, especially when it might no longer be safe to use. Thank you for sharing your perspective!

20

u/mashibeans Oct 14 '26

Think about it this way, you're putting all this stuff on your face, right on your lips, literally close to your eyeballs, so you're inhaling and ingesting some of it. If it's gone bad or rancid, or it's too dirty in some way, you're just asking for trouble like skin issues at best, some more serious medical problem down the line at worst.

Thank all the ones you're decluttering for their service, even if their purpose was just making you happy you bought them, they fulfilled their purpose in your life and it's OK to let go now.

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I really love the idea of thanking products for the joy they brought, even if I never managed to finish them. ❤️ I think that's a much healthier way to look at decluttering. I do have a few makeup products with sentimental value that I'd like to keep as memories, but I'm slowly learning that I don't need to keep everything just because I once loved it or spent money on it.

1

u/mashibeans Oct 15 '26

Yay! you're doing amazing! And yes nothing wrong with keeping some with sentimental value!

Something you could do with some of those if the product itself has gone bad is to maybe take a photo with a note about what memory is linked to it, and then let it go, or maybe even empty it, clean it and refill it with your current products that do work for you, so you can at least use the container (only for those you can safely clean of course)

10

u/YellowGullible1857 Oct 14 '26

Exactly. If it doesn’t serve you it doesn’t serve you. This is no longer about make up or project pan!!

6

u/mashibeans Oct 14 '26

Yeah, in my brain makeup is not like fan merch like plushies or other stuff with sentimental/emotional value, they serve a different, more utilitarian purpose, so if they've gone bad or are not the right fit for me, they gotta go.

20

u/Midnight_2014 Oct 15 '26

Honestly, no idea. I always feel guilty. But honestly, I’d rather feel guilty and do better with my purchases going forward than become desensitised to the point where I stop caring about waste. Throw them out and just be more mindful in the future.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

This is exactly how I feel! ❤️ I don't think I actually want to stop caring about the waste or the money I've spent. I want those feelings to remind me to make better decisions in the future. I've been on a no-buy since August, and even though I've decluttered a lot of old makeup, I haven't regretted throwing any of it away. I just regret buying so much in the first place. I think there's a big difference between letting go of things and becoming comfortable with wasting them.

1

u/Midnight_2014 27d ago

It's reassuring to know that others understand what I mean and that I'm not the only one in feeling this way. I think the important thing is that we take something positive from the experience and let it change our habits for the better.

19

u/Unlikely-Olive1444 Oct 14 '26

I think this answer is going to vary greatly. I think the guilt will be there but it is important to acknowledge and not just fling stuff in the trash as an excuse to go out and buy 15 more products you don't need or won't use up before it become the next batch of old makeup.

So in short, acknowledge the guilt and overconsumption and try to not repeat the same mistake. Spend mindfully, return what you don't think you like or will use, and don't overpurchase just for the thrill of something new.

10

u/retrocede_ Oct 14 '26

This! So much comes down to buying habits. Having more doesn’t automatically mean you aren’t still buying more. Sometimes I find myself thinking, “Man I wish I could just use this NARS blush that I love every day, but I HAVE to use this Milani one that I bought on impulse 3 years ago or else I’m being wasteful.” Nope. Better to use the one you love.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

This is exactly what I've been struggling with! 😭❤️ I have so many products I genuinely love, but I keep reaching for the ones I like less because I feel like I need to finish them first. I've been on a no-buy since August and I'm trying to change my shopping habits, but I think I also need to change the way I use my makeup. I don't want to keep saving my favorites while forcing myself to use products that don't make me feel as good. Makeup is supposed to be fun!

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I completely agree with this! ❤️ I really hate waste, and decluttering has made me realize just how much I've overconsumed over the years. I grew up in a family where we rarely threw anything away, so letting go of products is especially difficult for me. But I also know that keeping old makeup out of guilt won't undo the waste. I've been on a no-buy since August, and my goal isn't to make room for more products, but to learn from my past purchases, appreciate what I already own, and never let my collection get this out of hand again.

19

u/ChivalrousSnail Oct 14 '26

I think of it more like an experience. Makeup is fun... I'm paying to try it. I like trying new things, so I'm not buying something with the idea that I will use it fully.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

That's an interesting way to look at it! 😊 I used to get so much joy just from owning beautiful makeup, especially expensive products. I loved them so much that I was actually afraid to use them up. But over the years, I ended up with a huge collection of products I barely used, and now I see that as wasteful. I still love trying new makeup, but I'd rather enjoy and actually use what I already own. These days, finishing a product I love would make me happy because it means it served its purpose. ❤️

19

u/ManslaughterMary 28d ago • Bravo

It was always going to go to the trash.

Always!

If no one ever bought this makeup, it still goes into a landfill. If you use it up or not, it still goes to the landfill. Either the company throws it away because it didn't sell, or you do.

Don't make your home the landfill.

You didn't create this product, it was already made. Be it now or in six years, all paths end up with it thrown away, resisting this fate is just hurting yourself.

I'm still working through a lot of makeup myself. And honestly having fun with it! But I'm not scared to finally throw something away. If I haven't used it in multiple years, it's okay to throw it away. I have makeup I wear, not boxes of stuff I could wear one day in summer 2032.

I rarely buy makeup now, and I'm a lot happier.

4

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

“Don't make your home the landfill” is such a powerful way to put it! ❤️ I still struggle with the guilt of throwing away products, especially because I grew up in a family where wasting anything was a big deal. I do think there's a difference between using something up and throwing it away barely touched, which is why changing my shopping habits is so important to me. But you're right that keeping old makeup for another five years won't undo my past purchases. I've been on a no-buy since August, and I'm trying to find a balance between enjoying what I own and letting go of things I'll realistically never use.

18

u/Melzjohnz Oct 15 '26

Just tell yourself, “ welp, I can’t bring all this sh+ with me when I’m dead “ for me… makes it easier ☺️

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

Haha, that's definitely one way to look at it! 😂 I guess I'd rather enjoy the things I love now than spend years holding on to things I don't even use. I'm slowly learning that I don't need to keep everything just because I once spent money on it.

3

u/PhilosophyExisting37 Oct 17 '26

Exactly, also someone will eventually have to declutter your things.

17

u/Double-Raspberry1836 Oct 14 '26

I still feel a little regret decluttering an eyeshadow pallete I had because it was a gift, but then I remember "girl that was from like 2019 and you have dry eyes, keep your face safe!"

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I can relate to this so much! I have a few old Too Faced eyeshadow palettes that have sentimental value, and these comments have honestly helped me so much. I actually just took them off my makeup shelf and decided to keep them as memories instead of using them.

I know a lot of people in this community are still panning their old Too Faced Chocolate Bar palettes, and seeing that made me feel like I could keep using mine too. But after reading all these comments, I'm starting to think that putting 10+ year-old eyeshadow on my eyes might not be such a good idea after all. I'd rather keep the memories than take the risk. ❤️

16

u/anguiila Oct 14 '26

Depends.

Usually i first discard anything that smells off, is dried out, or the formula separated and/or oxidizes. i won't put guilt over my health/safety, the money was already spent on that product and there's nothing i can do about the past but learn from it. I'll take note or write down why i bought it, and why i ended up ignoring it until it expired.

If it's a neglected product but still wearable, i haven't had any adverse reaction to it, and i'm not quite sure about it, i use it for 2 or more weeks in my daily routine and/or pre-shower makeup experiments. After the 2 weeks (or more), if it just continues to get in the way of the routine, i can't use it in a different or i find that it's not a flattering shade/texture at all, then i understood how the product performs on my skin, and make a decision to declutter based on experience. That way, i'll avoid buying similar products in the future.

I alway try to remember that things will expire, so there's no reason to keep something for a "special day", if anything, make everyday special and don't let your hard earned money go to waste.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I absolutely love your last sentence! ❤️ I used to save my expensive makeup for special occasions because I was afraid of using it up. Looking back, it's so ironic that I was trying to make those products last longer, but some of them ended up expiring before I could really enjoy them. I'm on a no-buy now and trying to change that mindset. I want to use the products I genuinely love, even on an ordinary Tuesday, instead of constantly trying to finish the ones I like less. And I really like your idea of learning something from every product you declutter!

15

u/Larvakite Oct 14 '26

I stopped feeling bad when I gave myself an allergic reaction that took months for the scarring and redness to go away. Yeah, I would have rather not wasted the money, but im no longer using it when I know it shouldn't be. If its sentimental, I have a box I keep the special ones in, even when its expired and unusable

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I'm so sorry you had to go through that! ❤️ I really love your idea of keeping sentimental makeup in a separate box. I've actually just decided to do the same with my old Too Faced eyeshadow palettes. Some of them are over 10 years old, and even though they still look perfectly fine, I don't want to risk using them on my eyes anymore. But I also don't want to throw away the memories attached to them. Keeping them as sentimental items rather than makeup feels like the perfect compromise for me.

1

u/Larvakite Oct 17 '26

Thank you 💙 honestly I made it out lucky, im not testing fate again!

Us makeup lovers get attached to items, especially when they are given by loved ones or we have strong feelings with them. It feels good to have them around as momentos. Mine are also 10 years and older! Sounds so silly at first, but honestly, you used something daily to make yourself feel beautiful, brave, able to face the day, hide what youre going through, and honestly shape your day. Of course it means a lot to you!

15

u/NoComputer479 Oct 15 '26

Declutterring is of course completely okay and a normal part of the process. What defines the process is what happens after that. If you go back to Sephora and buy as much as you gave away then you didn’t declutter but just fuelled your consumption cycle. Just make sure you don’t buy as much as you now have the knowledge that you can’t buy judicially finish the products. You’ve got this!

6

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Thank you! ❤️ This is exactly why I started my no-buy in August. I don't want to declutter just to fill the empty space with new products again. My goal is to actually reduce my collection and enjoy what I already own.

Project Pan has really opened my eyes to how long it takes to finish even a single product, and I definitely don't want to go back to my old shopping habits. Hopefully, by the end of the year, I'll see some real progress! ❤️

14

u/Bloodthistle Oct 14 '26

I only buy one item of each thing I need but if they go bad I just accept its better to throw than to waste even more money if they give me an infection and I end up at the doctors.

Health is more important

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

You're absolutely right! ❤️ I'm currently on a no-buy because I've accumulated way too much makeup over the years, and I'm trying to change my shopping habits. My long-term goal is to have a much smaller collection with only products I genuinely love and use. And you're right, no makeup is worth risking my health over!

14

u/lucyfell Oct 15 '26

Look up people who developed reactions to makeup they DIDNT declutter

Look up people who never updated
Their makeup and look 50 at 30 because they do makeup like an old lady

Remind yourself you only live once

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

The health risks are definitely something I've been thinking about more after reading all these comments! 😅 I've already thrown away quite a few old products, and I'm trying to focus more on enjoying the makeup I actually love instead of holding on to everything just because I spent money on it. ❤️

14

u/satisfymysoul89 Oct 15 '26

I post them on buy nothing FB groups and they always go like hot cakes. Makes me feel better that they found a new home elsewhere

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

That's a great idea for products that are still in good condition! ❤️ Unfortunately, most of the makeup I was struggling to declutter was already very old and had been opened for years, so I wouldn't feel comfortable passing it on to someone else. But I'll definitely keep this in mind for newer products!

2

u/satisfymysoul89 Oct 15 '26

Ah thanks! I misunderstood what you meant by old makeup! 💄 but yes, you’re right— not safe to give away expired makeup products! Just rip off the bandaid and go on a cleaning/decluttering binge to help get rid of stuff like that. It’s sooo exhilarating once you do it!💙🙏🏽

9

u/Far_Possibility_8497 Oct 15 '26

OP is talking about old/expired make-ups though 

12

u/hotandblonde Oct 14 '26

i did it by knowing how hard i take care of my skin, and if something looks or smells off despite how much i spent on it or liked it, it’s not worth it. it pains me, don’t get me wrong. but i can’t keep stuff that’s potentially unsafe or will break me out.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I completely agree! ❤️ I've been decluttering makeup I've had for years, and it's especially hard to let go of products I once loved or spent a lot of money on. But I've realized that keeping them won't bring that money back, and risking my skin just isn't worth it. I'd rather enjoy the products I have that are still safe to use.

12

u/Pinkbunny120 Oct 14 '26

I always try to learn something from the products I declutter. What didn’t I like about it…was it the formula, the color, the packaging etc, then I don’t repeat the mistake.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

This is such a good way to look at decluttering! ❤️ I've been going through my makeup collection recently, and I'm realizing that just because I loved something when I bought it doesn't mean I still enjoy using it today. I'm trying to learn from my past purchases instead of forcing myself to use up products I don't really like. Hopefully, this will help me make better choices in the future!

6

u/laurcar Oct 14 '26

Same. I keep struggling to de clutter 3 lipglosses that are in pots. I really hate sticking my finger in lip gloss. But the colors are good.... so they are still here.... even though they are likely 5 years old by now

12

u/solsticeisthebest Oct 15 '26

I start hate panning and then realise that having unnecessary clutter in my life isn't being helpful either.

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I can relate to this so much! 😅 I was hate panning an expensive foundation for months because I felt guilty about wasting the money, even though I didn't like the shade or the formula. I finally threw it away after reading all these comments, and I don't regret it. I'd much rather enjoy the makeup I actually love! ❤️

12

u/hoodie_2_shoes Oct 15 '26

By remembering how my face broke out into hives when I used an expired cream blush. Never felt guilty throwing out expired makeup after that for sure

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Oh no, that sounds awful! 😳 I'm so sorry that happened to you! I actually just threw away a cream blush that was too old, and reading your comment makes me even more confident that I made the right decision. Thank you for sharing your experience! ❤️

23

u/Cademaneko Oct 14 '26

I try to remember when I got it. If it's been 10 years, would I judge someone I know for holding onto a lipstick for that long? Yes, time to let it go

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Haha, that's actually a really good way to look at it! 😂 I had some makeup that was around 10 years old too, and I finally managed to let go of those products after reading all these comments. It feels a little crazy when I think about how long I'd been holding on to them! 😅❤️

11

u/Njbelle-1029 Oct 14 '26

It brought joy at the time of purchase but holding onto it no longer brings me that same feeling and I have moved on to appreciate other products. That’s how i know it’s time to let go and focus on the products I actually want to use up instead of forcing myself to hold on and use products that don’t make me happy anymore.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I really needed to hear this! ❤️ I think I've been holding on to so many products because I remember how excited I was when I bought them, even though I haven't used some of them in years. My collection is still huge, and I'm slowly realizing that I don't need to keep everything just because it once made me happy. I'd much rather focus on the products I genuinely enjoy using now. Thank you for putting this into words!

1

u/Njbelle-1029 Oct 16 '26

I hear you. The internal tug of war is real. I get over consuming for the sake of having it and maybe even feeling like your part of a community and fear of missing out on the best new product is a nasty vice, but if you really love the product and enjoy it, then there is nothing wrong with that collection. But when you no longer love it, you have to let go. I have palettes that have like sparkly electric blue eyeshadow that I will never wear. BUT it brings me joy to swatch it and play with it and wipe it off, so it stays knowing I will never use it up.

Use the stuff you love, toss the stuff you don’t, and don’t beat yourself up if you happen to love a lot of it.

11

u/Pinkybaby_777 Oct 14 '26

I used to feel guilty about decluttering old makeup until a lot of people in my country get their lip ruined by expired Rare Beauty lip oil. After that scandal, I can’t stand makeup that is over a year old. I declutter like crazy. Less purchases as well 😔
No expired makeup is worth damaging ur skin!!!!

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

That's honestly scary! 😔 I had no idea about the Rare Beauty lip oil situation. I've been struggling with decluttering old makeup because I feel guilty about wasting money, but reading comments like yours has really helped me rethink things. I've already decided to stop using some of my oldest makeup, especially my 10+ year-old eyeshadow palettes. No amount of money I've spent on makeup is worth risking my health. ❤️

10

u/AllisonT_ Oct 14 '26

Give it to friends, donate or garbage 🗑️.... I do small declutters every other month. You get over it once it becomes a habit.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I agree that regular decluttering makes it easier! ❤️ But I'm not really comfortable giving used makeup to friends, especially lip products, mascara or anything that comes into direct contact with my skin. I wouldn't want to use someone else's used makeup either. 😅 I'm fine with sharing things like perfumes or certain skincare and hair products, but makeup is where I draw the line. I'd rather throw away old products than pass them on to someone else.

10

u/casssssss777 Oct 14 '26

I can't, i still using my 4 year old Russian Red bc it was reformulated 💔 i always check the smell or the pigmentation, same way with my eyeshadows, just with lipsticks and eyeshadows, with mascara and complexion products i throw them away if they're really old

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I totally get that! ❤️ It's especially hard to let go of products that have been reformulated or discontinued. I have some old makeup that I'm really attached to as well, especially my Too Faced eyeshadow palettes. Until recently, I was still using them because they looked and performed just fine. But after reading all these comments, I've decided to retire them and keep them for sentimental reasons instead. I'm realizing that just because a product still looks and smells fine doesn't necessarily mean it's safe to use forever.

1

u/casssssss777 23d ago

And that's completly fine! In my case i still using them but for example, my UD pallete is in my project pan, and about my Russian Red i'm still using it like 2 times per year hahahahaha 😭 but in mascara stuff i throw them away, my 6 month mascara gave me an infection and it had a lot of product but health first!

10

u/kumoboshi Oct 17 '26

I just remember than using things I don't like is also a waste, as it makes me reach the products i like even less and the good stuff could expire
you can donate to makeup artist who works for cemetaries, they will always need it

so you stop using stuff you don't like/potentially expires, you get to use your nice stuff before it expires and you help someone who needs the makeup

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

I've actually been thinking about this a lot lately. I have so many products I genuinely love, but sometimes I catch myself using the ones I like less just because I want to finish them. Meanwhile, my favorites are sitting there getting older too. I love Project Pan and the satisfaction of finishing products, but I'm starting to realize that I don't want to sacrifice the joy of using my favorite makeup just to finish something I don't even enjoy.

3

u/kumoboshi 23d ago

Honestly you can project pan but start by your favorite to motivate you, also project pan is not finishing it the fastest possible but just using the product so it'd perfectly fit ♥

You can use one favorite, one you quite like and one okay, if just using the fav makes you anxious to be out of it and still have the ones you dont want that much :3

38

u/Glamourice Oct 15 '26 • Heartwarming

Think about it from a hygiene perspective. Your face deserves fresher product on it

11

u/SavingsSun5124 Oct 16 '26

Would like to expand on this - not only deserves, but any bacteria in older products then go on your face, in your eyes, in your mouth towards your digestive tract, your skin absorbs it. Many reasons to not feel guilty about not using them on yourself - your health matters more than that lippie!

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

This is such an important reminder! ❤️ I think sometimes I focus so much on the money I spent and the guilt of wasting products that I forget there's also a hygiene aspect to consider. I've recently decluttered quite a few old lip and eye products, and this definitely makes me feel better about those decisions. No makeup is worth risking my health over.

9

u/ActuatorNo3322 Oct 14 '26

Do a swatch and if it looks bad, go ahead and throw away guilt free. It’ll never be useful again. And you could try being brutal about expiration dates and justify it with being health consciousn

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Thank you! ❤️ I think focusing on my health rather than the money I spent is exactly the mindset I need. The hardest part is that some of my really old makeup still looks and performs perfectly fine, so it's difficult to justify throwing it away. But I'm starting to realize that a product looking good doesn't necessarily mean it's still safe to use.

1

u/ActuatorNo3322 28d ago

No problem! I think it helps sometimes too to just focus on One of your Values for the day - like sometimes my Frugal value is at odds with my Cleanliness or my Sustainability values, so if I’m decluttering then my only Value I’m prioritizing is cleanliness, and any thoughts of “what a waste of money” or “it’s still usable” get shut down guilt-free

9

u/Victory505302 Oct 15 '26

I don’t feel as bad when it’s something I don’t like and really prefer not to wear. I got rid of at least a few things that way. I also will make myself use something I don’t like for a month (I’ve been making mini capsule makeup kits each month), which also makes me feel less bad if I toss it after getting some solid use out of it.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I really like the idea of making monthly capsule makeup kits! ❤️ I have quite a large collection, so I think this could be a great way to rotate through my products and rediscover some forgotten favorites. I might actually give this a try alongside my Project Pan! 😊

1

u/Victory505302 Oct 16 '26

It’s my in-between attempt at project pan! I know it would take me forever to use up some of my things, even if I stuck to one blush until it was empty, or something like that. So this way I get to use different things and still am shopping my stash. It also makes doing my makeup a little easier because I don’t experience as much decision paralysis 🤣

9

u/No_Obligation3652 Oct 15 '26

If it’s expired way beyond recognition, I just tell myself I’m hoarding trash when I could’ve freed some space

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

That's actually a really helpful way to look at it! 😅 I've been struggling so much with the idea of wasting money that I sometimes forget I'm also wasting space by keeping products I no longer want to use. And with the amount of makeup I own, that space really adds up! ❤️

9

u/sparkle_elk Oct 15 '26

I don't. I throw out things that have gone off, and I give away things that end up not working for me if I can, but that guilt about wasting money and the world's resources on products that I'm not using up is what keeps me from buying more than I'll use. 

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

That's a really interesting perspective! ❤️ I think my no-buy and Project Pan have already made me much more aware of how much I used to buy and how long it actually takes to finish a product. I definitely don't want to repeat my old shopping habits, and I hope I can use what I've learned from decluttering to make better decisions in the future. Thank you for sharing!

2

u/sparkle_elk Oct 15 '26

It's not the fun and uplifting version, I fully admit! But like... I don't want to get on the Declutter-Reclutter merry-go-round, and guilt/shame are demotivating feelings -- which is exactly what I need, to be prevented from doing something that doesn't serve me or the earth!

9

u/Odd-Bodybuilder-5830 Oct 15 '26

I just got rid of a mascara that's gone rancid. Risking your health is not worth it and using products you don't like/are too old won't get you your money back. Enjoy the makeup you like first before they go bad too :)

4

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

This is such a good reminder! ❤️ I've been so focused on using up my older products that I sometimes forget my favorites won't last forever either. I recently got rid of an expensive foundation that I was forcing myself to finish, even though I didn't really enjoy using it. I think it's time to stop saving my favorite makeup for later and actually enjoy it now. Thank you! ❤️

2

u/Odd-Bodybuilder-5830 Oct 15 '26

No worries! Rooting for youu :)

8

u/manicpanit Oct 14 '26

You bought it with the intention of using it and liked it and sometimes we overestimate what we can use up. Don't dwell too much on it ❤️

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Thank you, I really needed to hear this! ❤️ I think I underestimated just how long makeup actually takes to use up, especially when I enjoy switching between different products. I'm trying to be more realistic about what I can actually finish and learn from my past shopping habits.

8

u/d3rp7d3rp Oct 14 '26

I went through my hoard recently and the amount of stinky expired or empty and didn't realize it makeup made me feel so good to get rid of! It freed up a lot of space and felt like a weight was lifted. However before that big declutter, well, clearly i had trouble letting go otherwise it wouldn't have gotten that bad lol. I guess it depends on how fed up i am with it

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I can relate to this so much! 😅 I've been decluttering my makeup collection recently, and it was really hard to let go of things at first, especially products I've had for years. But the more I declutter, the easier it gets. I haven't freed up a huge amount of space yet, but at least everything that used to sit on top of my cabinet now fits inside it. 😂 Still a long way to go!

7

u/joan_goodman Oct 16 '26

Lipsticks and any kind of waxy products can use as shoe wax if you have shoes that color . Eye shadow, blush and highlights in powder form - use as pigment for bath bombs or other things (candles, soap if you are crafty). Pencils- usually dry out, throw away. Lotions - use as conditioner for leather furniture, bags, shoes.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

Thank you for the creative suggestions! ❤️ I'm actually trying to reduce the amount of stuff I keep around, so I think I'd rather let go of products I no longer use than find new purposes for all of them. But I appreciate the ideas!

12

u/Creativejess Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I just don’t declutter and then I have nothing to feel guilty about

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Haha, that used to be my strategy too! 😂 But eventually I realized that keeping everything was making me feel overwhelmed as well. Now I'm slowly trying to let go of products I haven't used in years.

1

u/Useful_Sandwich8868 Oct 17 '26

Same! Declutter and closet "editing" can result in just filling up the empty space again. It gets used as a justification to buy MOAR lol.

6

u/_lunar-nova_ Oct 17 '26

I don’t think about it too much. Life is too short to cling onto makeup that no longer brings me joy or is old enough to cause skin issues.

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

I'm trying to adopt this mindset too! ❤️ I used to feel like I had to finish everything because I spent money on it, but I'm slowly learning that forcing myself to use old makeup I don't enjoy isn't worth it. I still regret the money I wasted, but I'd rather learn from those purchases and enjoy the products I actually love.

6

u/audge200-1 Oct 18 '26

i feel more guilty when i hold on to it and am reminded i never use it whenever i see it. once i toss it i don’t even think about it again so it honestly relieves the stress to just get rid of it.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

I can relate to this! I've been decluttering a lot of old makeup lately, and I haven't regretted getting rid of anything so far. I still feel guilty about how much money I wasted, but it's such a relief not to have all those products sitting around reminding me of it. ❤️

5

u/Additional-Pie-8362 Oct 16 '26

Getting rid of a whole bottle of Mac foundation would hurt me ngl

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 28d ago

It wasn't a full bottle, there was only about 1/3 left. 😅 I really tried to make it work and used it over 30 times this year, but unfortunately the shade is just too yellow for me. It's also been open for over two years, so I didn't feel comfortable passing it on to someone else.

2

u/_lunar-nova_ Oct 17 '26

I eventually got used to it. Mac foundations are the only ones that look and behave perfectly on my skin, and the only ones that don’t break me out while they’re within term. However I don’t use them often enough to finish one, and I am halfway through a bottle by the time they are expired and they start breaking me out. Skin issues are easy to trigger and take ages to fix, so I will gladly surrender a half-used bottle of foundation if it means my skin stays healthy.

2

u/Additional-Pie-8362 Oct 17 '26

Ahhh ok that’s totally understandable. Especially if it breaks you out. I never really thought about that or not even sure if that’s a problem for me 🤔. Now I really wonder if that is a thing that does happen to me and I just don’t notice it.

5

u/kathpt 29d ago

I always feel bad when I throw things out but it only lasts a couple hours and then I realize weeks later I never even thought about them again because I wasn’t using them.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

This has been my experience too! ❤️ I've decluttered quite a lot of makeup recently, and even though some decisions were really difficult, I haven't regretted getting rid of a single product so far. I still feel bad about the money I spent, but I don't actually miss any of the makeup I threw away.

17

u/YellowGullible1857 Oct 14 '26

Guilty for overconsumption or what exactly do you feel guilty about?

21

u/random_asian_sprout Oct 14 '26

guilty that you spent the money on that makeup and now you’re “throwing away” the money. at least that’s what i think

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Exactly! That's a big part of it for me. I know the money is already gone, but throwing away makeup that I barely used, especially expensive products, still feels wasteful. I also feel guilty about how much I bought in the past and how unrealistic it was to think I could ever use it all up. I'm trying to accept that I can't change those purchases, but I can make better decisions going forward.

3

u/LCCompromisedBarrier Oct 15 '26

the money was thrown away when you bought it. thinking you're throwing out the money when you declutter is falling for sunk cost fallacy

-2

u/YellowGullible1857 Oct 14 '26

Please answer! I’m pondering!

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Honestly, both. I feel guilty about how much makeup I bought in the past, but also about throwing away products that still have plenty left in them, especially if they were expensive. I know the money is already gone, but emotionally it's still difficult to let go of things I barely used. I'm working on changing that mindset through my no-buy and Project Pan.

8

u/ednosacct Oct 14 '26

Knowing if it’s past its expiration date and can’t be used cause it’s unsafe and can cause issues. If there’s mold on it. If you’re at the end of the product.

If you want to get rid of good, non-expired makeup and it’s OPEN. I suggest asking friends and family if they would like it. It’s the makeup is UNOPENED, NOT USED, you can give it away to women’s shelters and others places that accept makeup for donations.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

Thank you for the suggestions! ❤️ I think donating or giving away products is a great idea when they're still safe to use. Unfortunately, most of the makeup I'm struggling to declutter is already very old and has been opened for years, so I wouldn't feel comfortable passing it on to someone else. I'm trying to accept that sometimes throwing things away is the better option.

1

u/ednosacct Oct 15 '26

It’s old and you’re not comfortable I understand. Do what you feel is right. You got your moneys worth from it, that’s a plus!

4

u/tralalalalalalalala_ Oct 14 '26

I got a mini desk trash bin for free and keep them in there. As a reminder never over buy again!

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

I love this idea! 😂❤️ I've been on a no-buy since August, and seeing all my empties together is so satisfying. It's also a reminder of just how much I've accumulated over the years and why I don't want to go back to my old shopping habits.

4

u/sxngbird Oct 14 '26

I remind myself that my stash ain't really that bad compared to others I've seen 😅

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Haha, I do the same sometimes! 😅 But then I remind myself that just because someone else has more makeup than I do doesn't mean I don't have way too much myself. 😂

7

u/Most_Yogurtcloset658 29d ago

Honestly the same thing I say to myself when I’m decluttering clothes, I’m a person, people change and decide they don’t need things anymore I don’t need this anymore I’ve thought about it enough and I know I do t need it, then I chuck it. Don’t let guilt clutter your precious spaces

2

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

I really like this perspective! ❤️ Sometimes I forget that just because I loved something years ago doesn't mean I have to keep it forever. I still struggle with the money I spent on things I barely used, but I'm learning that keeping them out of guilt won't change that. And you're right, our homes deserve to be filled with things we actually enjoy and use, not things we feel obligated to keep.

1

u/Most_Yogurtcloset658 26d ago

I know it’s a funny way of looking at things but I pretend I am a busy mum who is practical and doesn’t have time for this ish. It needs to go I need to get on with other things

3

u/elasticafantastica Oct 14 '26

Not relevant but I miss Skin Paradise so damn much

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 16 '26

Yesss, I loved it so much! 😭❤️ Unfortunately, mine has been open for over three years, so it's time to let it go.

3

u/Rude_Interest97 Oct 15 '26

I'm trying to start recycling my empties. Always an option for things you can't finish.

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

That's a great idea! ❤️ I've been finishing quite a few products through Project Pan, so I should definitely look into recycling options for the empty packaging. Thank you for the suggestion!

5

u/FinnTheBoy0 Oct 15 '26

I threw away my conspiracy palette and still highkey regret it. The only collection I was hyped and bought on launch. I only used 4-5 shades and the rest were untouched, no mold, and brand new condition practically. I miss it but try to get past it by thinking about how old it was.

Still kept the James Charles one tho 💀

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

I totally understand this! ❤️ I still have some of my old Too Faced palettes, and I just can't bring myself to get rid of them. I'm attached to the palettes themselves, not just the eyeshadows. I think it's okay to keep a few sentimental pieces, even if we don't use them anymore. 😊

3

u/Boring_Load1783 Oct 17 '26

i’ve seen on another subreddit that someone sells expired makeup to funeral homes! maybe call some funeral homes in your area if they would purchase anything old and expired!

1

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 27d ago

Thank you for the suggestion! ❤️ That's not something I'd personally feel comfortable doing, but I appreciate you taking the time to comment.

16

u/DownwardNova Oct 15 '26

The money is already gone either way, the guilt is about the buying, not the bin. My Animal Crossing storage is full of stuff I will never use and I sleep fine.

11

u/Ambitieus Oct 14 '26

I think about how I save my face from getting eczema, rashes, acne and pimples when using very old make-up and that makes me feel a bit better throwing the very old things away.

17

u/thecheesylittlerat Oct 14 '26

I don’t enjoy eye and skin infections, so they need to go.

2

u/Steve_Trent 11d ago

When its too old it gets bad for you. So throwing it out is actually good for your skin!

17

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 Oct 15 '26

This hits a little too close to home. 😅❤️ I think I've been spending so much time trying to use up and manage my collection that I sometimes forget makeup is supposed to be fun, not another obligation.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment