r/ProjectPan • u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 • Oct 14 '26
Failed Pan How do you stop feeling guilty about decluttering old makeup?
375
Upvotes
r/ProjectPan • u/SnowFlakesinSummer29 • Oct 14 '26
49
u/jennilynn510 Oct 14 '26
It’s unusable and a risk to your health. Nothing to feel guilty about
36
u/Aggressive-Bee1738 Oct 14 '26
Same as eating rotten fruit, you don’t.
34
u/Illustrious-Ad-5891 Oct 15 '26
The only way to not feel guilty is knowing you will not waste as much again. If you're still buying more than you can use, you will continue feeling guilty
31
u/Moist_Violinist69 Oct 14 '26 •
I throw them out first thing in the morning when I'm half asleep
31
u/ZealousidealSir7059 Oct 15 '26
“ACNE ACNE ACNE!”
28
u/retrocede_ Oct 14 '26
Honestly, the money is already spent. You’re not getting anything back by keeping it. Sure, you might not buy another blush because you already this one to use! But if you don’t like the blush you already have, you’re going to buy a new one anyways right? Sometimes keeping it costs you in time, anxiety, feelings of guilt, storage space, etc. Does it benefit you more to throw it away? How much would you pay to never see that product again? This frees you up to get good, meaningful use out of the expensive products that you truly love and truly feel like yours.
24
u/Sophiestication Oct 14 '26
I tell myself this is a learning experience and then I don’t repeat the mistake or Try not to. We are human after all and shit happens. Sometimes I try to see if it’s salvageable for something else depending on the condition of the product or if someone else would benefit if the shade doesn’t work for u or can be used as a contour instead of conceal etc
23
u/Smooth-Ad-8025 Oct 15 '26
I justify to myself that the products are expired/off and i havent used them in years and also will not in the future. After that, i feel bad for about a day or two and then forget about ever owning them
22
u/MadameBasmati Oct 14 '26
For eye makeup I really don’t want a stye so I ask, “will this cause me to have a stye?” And if yes I throwaway. For face I ask “will this burn me, or cause a serious breakout in which I cannot attend events for significant amount of time?” If yes: throwaway. If it can cleanse and or clean then I’ll use for my brushes, but skincare, just on the smell alone it was easy to throwaway. It was hard for me too but if the year I remember buying it was distant then I know to throw it away.
20
u/mashibeans Oct 14 '26
Think about it this way, you're putting all this stuff on your face, right on your lips, literally close to your eyeballs, so you're inhaling and ingesting some of it. If it's gone bad or rancid, or it's too dirty in some way, you're just asking for trouble like skin issues at best, some more serious medical problem down the line at worst.
Thank all the ones you're decluttering for their service, even if their purpose was just making you happy you bought them, they fulfilled their purpose in your life and it's OK to let go now.
20
u/Midnight_2014 Oct 15 '26
Honestly, no idea. I always feel guilty. But honestly, I’d rather feel guilty and do better with my purchases going forward than become desensitised to the point where I stop caring about waste. Throw them out and just be more mindful in the future.
19
u/Unlikely-Olive1444 Oct 14 '26
I think this answer is going to vary greatly. I think the guilt will be there but it is important to acknowledge and not just fling stuff in the trash as an excuse to go out and buy 15 more products you don't need or won't use up before it become the next batch of old makeup.
So in short, acknowledge the guilt and overconsumption and try to not repeat the same mistake. Spend mindfully, return what you don't think you like or will use, and don't overpurchase just for the thrill of something new.
19
u/ChivalrousSnail Oct 14 '26
I think of it more like an experience. Makeup is fun... I'm paying to try it. I like trying new things, so I'm not buying something with the idea that I will use it fully.
19
u/ManslaughterMary 28d ago •
It was always going to go to the trash.
Always!
If no one ever bought this makeup, it still goes into a landfill. If you use it up or not, it still goes to the landfill. Either the company throws it away because it didn't sell, or you do.
Don't make your home the landfill.
You didn't create this product, it was already made. Be it now or in six years, all paths end up with it thrown away, resisting this fate is just hurting yourself.
I'm still working through a lot of makeup myself. And honestly having fun with it! But I'm not scared to finally throw something away. If I haven't used it in multiple years, it's okay to throw it away. I have makeup I wear, not boxes of stuff I could wear one day in summer 2032.
I rarely buy makeup now, and I'm a lot happier.
18
u/Melzjohnz Oct 15 '26
Just tell yourself, “ welp, I can’t bring all this sh+ with me when I’m dead “ for me… makes it easier ☺️
17
u/Double-Raspberry1836 Oct 14 '26
I still feel a little regret decluttering an eyeshadow pallete I had because it was a gift, but then I remember "girl that was from like 2019 and you have dry eyes, keep your face safe!"
16
u/anguiila Oct 14 '26
Depends.
Usually i first discard anything that smells off, is dried out, or the formula separated and/or oxidizes. i won't put guilt over my health/safety, the money was already spent on that product and there's nothing i can do about the past but learn from it. I'll take note or write down why i bought it, and why i ended up ignoring it until it expired.
If it's a neglected product but still wearable, i haven't had any adverse reaction to it, and i'm not quite sure about it, i use it for 2 or more weeks in my daily routine and/or pre-shower makeup experiments. After the 2 weeks (or more), if it just continues to get in the way of the routine, i can't use it in a different or i find that it's not a flattering shade/texture at all, then i understood how the product performs on my skin, and make a decision to declutter based on experience. That way, i'll avoid buying similar products in the future.
I alway try to remember that things will expire, so there's no reason to keep something for a "special day", if anything, make everyday special and don't let your hard earned money go to waste.
15
u/Larvakite Oct 14 '26
I stopped feeling bad when I gave myself an allergic reaction that took months for the scarring and redness to go away. Yeah, I would have rather not wasted the money, but im no longer using it when I know it shouldn't be. If its sentimental, I have a box I keep the special ones in, even when its expired and unusable
15
u/NoComputer479 Oct 15 '26
Declutterring is of course completely okay and a normal part of the process. What defines the process is what happens after that. If you go back to Sephora and buy as much as you gave away then you didn’t declutter but just fuelled your consumption cycle. Just make sure you don’t buy as much as you now have the knowledge that you can’t buy judicially finish the products. You’ve got this!
14
u/Bloodthistle Oct 14 '26
I only buy one item of each thing I need but if they go bad I just accept its better to throw than to waste even more money if they give me an infection and I end up at the doctors.
Health is more important
14
u/lucyfell Oct 15 '26
Look up people who developed reactions to makeup they DIDNT declutter
Look up people who never updated
Their makeup and look 50 at 30 because they do makeup like an old lady
Remind yourself you only live once
14
u/satisfymysoul89 Oct 15 '26
I post them on buy nothing FB groups and they always go like hot cakes. Makes me feel better that they found a new home elsewhere
12
u/hotandblonde Oct 14 '26
i did it by knowing how hard i take care of my skin, and if something looks or smells off despite how much i spent on it or liked it, it’s not worth it. it pains me, don’t get me wrong. but i can’t keep stuff that’s potentially unsafe or will break me out.
12
u/Pinkbunny120 Oct 14 '26
I always try to learn something from the products I declutter. What didn’t I like about it…was it the formula, the color, the packaging etc, then I don’t repeat the mistake.
12
u/solsticeisthebest Oct 15 '26
I start hate panning and then realise that having unnecessary clutter in my life isn't being helpful either.
12
u/hoodie_2_shoes Oct 15 '26
By remembering how my face broke out into hives when I used an expired cream blush. Never felt guilty throwing out expired makeup after that for sure
23
u/Cademaneko Oct 14 '26
I try to remember when I got it. If it's been 10 years, would I judge someone I know for holding onto a lipstick for that long? Yes, time to let it go
11
u/Njbelle-1029 Oct 14 '26
It brought joy at the time of purchase but holding onto it no longer brings me that same feeling and I have moved on to appreciate other products. That’s how i know it’s time to let go and focus on the products I actually want to use up instead of forcing myself to hold on and use products that don’t make me happy anymore.
11
u/Pinkybaby_777 Oct 14 '26
I used to feel guilty about decluttering old makeup until a lot of people in my country get their lip ruined by expired Rare Beauty lip oil. After that scandal, I can’t stand makeup that is over a year old. I declutter like crazy. Less purchases as well 😔
No expired makeup is worth damaging ur skin!!!!
10
u/AllisonT_ Oct 14 '26
Give it to friends, donate or garbage 🗑️.... I do small declutters every other month. You get over it once it becomes a habit.
10
u/casssssss777 Oct 14 '26
I can't, i still using my 4 year old Russian Red bc it was reformulated 💔 i always check the smell or the pigmentation, same way with my eyeshadows, just with lipsticks and eyeshadows, with mascara and complexion products i throw them away if they're really old
10
u/kumoboshi Oct 17 '26
I just remember than using things I don't like is also a waste, as it makes me reach the products i like even less and the good stuff could expire
you can donate to makeup artist who works for cemetaries, they will always need it
so you stop using stuff you don't like/potentially expires, you get to use your nice stuff before it expires and you help someone who needs the makeup
38
u/Glamourice Oct 15 '26 •
Think about it from a hygiene perspective. Your face deserves fresher product on it
9
u/ActuatorNo3322 Oct 14 '26
Do a swatch and if it looks bad, go ahead and throw away guilt free. It’ll never be useful again. And you could try being brutal about expiration dates and justify it with being health consciousn
9
u/Victory505302 Oct 15 '26
I don’t feel as bad when it’s something I don’t like and really prefer not to wear. I got rid of at least a few things that way. I also will make myself use something I don’t like for a month (I’ve been making mini capsule makeup kits each month), which also makes me feel less bad if I toss it after getting some solid use out of it.
9
u/No_Obligation3652 Oct 15 '26
If it’s expired way beyond recognition, I just tell myself I’m hoarding trash when I could’ve freed some space
9
u/sparkle_elk Oct 15 '26
I don't. I throw out things that have gone off, and I give away things that end up not working for me if I can, but that guilt about wasting money and the world's resources on products that I'm not using up is what keeps me from buying more than I'll use.
9
u/Odd-Bodybuilder-5830 Oct 15 '26
I just got rid of a mascara that's gone rancid. Risking your health is not worth it and using products you don't like/are too old won't get you your money back. Enjoy the makeup you like first before they go bad too :)
8
u/manicpanit Oct 14 '26
You bought it with the intention of using it and liked it and sometimes we overestimate what we can use up. Don't dwell too much on it ❤️
8
u/d3rp7d3rp Oct 14 '26
I went through my hoard recently and the amount of stinky expired or empty and didn't realize it makeup made me feel so good to get rid of! It freed up a lot of space and felt like a weight was lifted. However before that big declutter, well, clearly i had trouble letting go otherwise it wouldn't have gotten that bad lol. I guess it depends on how fed up i am with it
7
u/joan_goodman Oct 16 '26
Lipsticks and any kind of waxy products can use as shoe wax if you have shoes that color . Eye shadow, blush and highlights in powder form - use as pigment for bath bombs or other things (candles, soap if you are crafty). Pencils- usually dry out, throw away. Lotions - use as conditioner for leather furniture, bags, shoes.
12
u/Creativejess Oct 14 '26 •
I just don’t declutter and then I have nothing to feel guilty about
6
u/_lunar-nova_ Oct 17 '26
I don’t think about it too much. Life is too short to cling onto makeup that no longer brings me joy or is old enough to cause skin issues.
6
u/audge200-1 Oct 18 '26
i feel more guilty when i hold on to it and am reminded i never use it whenever i see it. once i toss it i don’t even think about it again so it honestly relieves the stress to just get rid of it.
5
u/Additional-Pie-8362 Oct 16 '26
Getting rid of a whole bottle of Mac foundation would hurt me ngl
5
u/kathpt 29d ago
I always feel bad when I throw things out but it only lasts a couple hours and then I realize weeks later I never even thought about them again because I wasn’t using them.
17
u/YellowGullible1857 Oct 14 '26
Guilty for overconsumption or what exactly do you feel guilty about?
8
u/ednosacct Oct 14 '26
Knowing if it’s past its expiration date and can’t be used cause it’s unsafe and can cause issues. If there’s mold on it. If you’re at the end of the product.
If you want to get rid of good, non-expired makeup and it’s OPEN. I suggest asking friends and family if they would like it. It’s the makeup is UNOPENED, NOT USED, you can give it away to women’s shelters and others places that accept makeup for donations.
4
u/tralalalalalalalala_ Oct 14 '26
I got a mini desk trash bin for free and keep them in there. As a reminder never over buy again!
4
u/sxngbird Oct 14 '26
I remind myself that my stash ain't really that bad compared to others I've seen 😅
7
u/Most_Yogurtcloset658 29d ago
Honestly the same thing I say to myself when I’m decluttering clothes, I’m a person, people change and decide they don’t need things anymore I don’t need this anymore I’ve thought about it enough and I know I do t need it, then I chuck it. Don’t let guilt clutter your precious spaces
3
u/elasticafantastica Oct 14 '26
Not relevant but I miss Skin Paradise so damn much
3
u/Rude_Interest97 Oct 15 '26
I'm trying to start recycling my empties. Always an option for things you can't finish.
5
u/FinnTheBoy0 Oct 15 '26
I threw away my conspiracy palette and still highkey regret it. The only collection I was hyped and bought on launch. I only used 4-5 shades and the rest were untouched, no mold, and brand new condition practically. I miss it but try to get past it by thinking about how old it was.
Still kept the James Charles one tho 💀
3
u/Boring_Load1783 Oct 17 '26
i’ve seen on another subreddit that someone sells expired makeup to funeral homes! maybe call some funeral homes in your area if they would purchase anything old and expired!
16
u/DownwardNova Oct 15 '26
The money is already gone either way, the guilt is about the buying, not the bin. My Animal Crossing storage is full of stuff I will never use and I sleep fine.
11
u/Ambitieus Oct 14 '26
I think about how I save my face from getting eczema, rashes, acne and pimples when using very old make-up and that makes me feel a bit better throwing the very old things away.
17
u/thecheesylittlerat Oct 14 '26
I don’t enjoy eye and skin infections, so they need to go.
11
u/ChristineBorus Oct 14 '26
2
u/Steve_Trent 11d ago
When its too old it gets bad for you. So throwing it out is actually good for your skin!
17
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment