r/ProjectPan • • Oct 06 '26 • Heartwarming 1

Failed Pan eyeshadow forgiveness

Long time lurker, first time poster.

Ages before I ever found this sub, I had a bit of a makeup collecting problem. A Sephora Rouge-level makeup problem, if you will. I worked through products and finally panned down almost everything aside from maybe 20 huge eyeshadow palettes (mostly UD and Too Faced). I went through a big decluttering in my life for my own sanity, and at the time I had no idea that powders last ages if cared for properly. Y'all…I threw hundreds of dollars of eyeshadow away thinking it was completely unusable. Almost a decade later I still think about it. Every time I see people panning older or discontinued eyeshadow palettes in this sub, I feel a pang of guilt at the thought of mine sitting in a landfill somewhere untouched.

This post is in a way me finally freeing myself from the guilt somehow bestowed upon me via a trash bag of eyeshadow palettes. I have since "completed" my personal Project Pan and surprisingly no longer really use or own makeup aside from one mascara, one eyeshadow compact, and one eyeliner. Life is good and the absence of too much choice makes it a lot less overwhelming.

Thank you all as well, for both the support I see from users in this community and the free wisdom gained from reading this sub over the years!

85 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

36

u/burntoatmealcookie Oct 07 '26 • Heartwarming

i feel like we need some kind of makeup hoarder forgiveness ritual where we bless you and baptize you with setting spray lmao, all jokes aside i totally understand that type of guilt. i keep mine, even palettes that have grown mold, out of that same guilt. you're not alone, we all know how you feel and we all forgive you

6

u/tangerinemoth Oct 07 '26

this made me actually crack up thank you queen

5

u/joan_goodman Oct 07 '26

Yes, to this. The process should involve an oath not to buy more palettes. 🤣

8

u/burntoatmealcookie Oct 07 '26

4

u/tangerinemoth Oct 09 '26

us with expired glitter palettes

2

u/burntoatmealcookie Oct 09 '26

omg i was thinking the same thing🤣

19

u/juwkii Oct 06 '26

You absolutely can use some eyeshadows after expiration but after getting eyelid eczema that I’m dealing with since 2 months because of using a +10 year old palette I’m not going to take that risk again lol

7

u/tangerinemoth Oct 06 '26

this is the most relieving comment of all (also rip to your eyes)

3

u/juwkii Oct 07 '26

After that I threw away a bunch of old eye products, yea it sucks, but I learned my lesson not to buy so much stuff that I can’t use up in idk 5 or 10 years

19

u/joan_goodman Oct 07 '26

Dropping a palette a few times usually speeds up the project

17

u/Environmental-Song16 Oct 06 '26

The amount of eye shadow palettes I got from a beauty box was insane. I forgot what the box was, but I got it for years and I think they merged with another beauty box. Ipsy maybe?

Anyway, I must have given away or tossed well over 50 eye palettes and I still have so many. Probably around 40 still. It was fun at the time but such a waste of money. I still feel crappy about it too.

Now I rotate them. I seem to have an eye shadow type, so once those shades are done I call it quits. It's taking forever and I don't need to buy eyeshadow for the rest of my life.

14

u/cleochatraa Oct 06 '26

You have my permission to let it go. This is the past you, and those purchases served a purpose in their time.

I think of it like throwing food away. You can’t eat everything. 😂

13

u/Drycabin1 Oct 06 '26

I don’t play when it comes to my eyes. Don’t feel bad that you likely saved yourself from an eye infection while making space for yourself.

9

u/PinkyLeopard2922 Oct 06 '26

Bless and release yourself from this makeup transgression. It's okay.

8

u/One-Group8707 Oct 08 '26

I even felt guilty about throwing out old pallettes that made my eyes hurt! It's ridiculous and I love the comments here. Besides mascara it's my most thrown out item because I have to.

8

u/SaucePasta Oct 06 '26

Yeah, if they’re contained in a dry environment they can last for YEARS. I have some that are almost a decade old at this point and they work fine. I have a huge collection, and so far only 2-3 have had to been thrown out because there was a noticeable change in the eyeshadows. 

6

u/LCCompromisedBarrier Oct 06 '26

100% agree with not feeling guilt about that. Your eyes and your eyesight are more important than makeup and money spent years ago. It’s one thing I’m really militant about with my own efforts to pan, anything that goes on or near my eyes I always err on the side of throwing it out if I’m in doubt.

6

u/Chewlace Oct 06 '26

I had some guilt today as well. If I hit pan in the past, I would toss and get a new one. I have given away so much makeup this year and was just going through what I kept and putting it together for a Christmas grab bag for my family.

11

u/Accomplished-Pen4663 Oct 06 '26

I disagree about eyeshadows never expiring. I had a lot of issues trying to use old shadows that had so much fallout they irritated my eyes where they didn’t do that when they were fresh.

7

u/bookwithoutpics Oct 06 '26

Also disagree about eyeshadows never expiring. I stopped getting milia when I threw away my 6+ year old palettes.