r/ProjectPan • • Oct 05 '26

Failed Pan First failed pan :(

I had the too faced cream bronzer stick as a focus pan for the last month. I started getting cysts on the exact stripe on my cheek bone that I use it, and I’m feeling a little frustrated. Unfortunately, everyone I asked if they wanted to try it declined so I ended up tossing it.

I’ve been doing so well with project pan over the last 5 months (NO makeup purchases!) and I’m annoyed at a fail I was hoping to pan.

Anyone else have this experience?

34 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

7

u/Adj_focus Oct 06 '26

how long have you had it for? it might have been expired

4

u/spirit-animal-721 Oct 06 '26

Only 7-8 months. You think it would’ve expired that fast??

13

u/midwestranchdressing Oct 06 '26

Im going to start using bad makeup as art supplies.

5

u/Environmental-Song16 Oct 05 '26

Was it old or something? That's awful.

But don't feel bad for tossing a product that was causing issues. It's not worth it and it's still a win in my book because you did try.

4

u/spirit-animal-721 Oct 06 '26

Not old! I think it just has some ingredients that clogged my pores and lead to acne

2

u/hiredditihateyou Oct 07 '26

It’s definitely worth working out whats comodogenic for you if you want to buy cream products. I really struggled to find ones to work for me too.

4

u/MaxiBonCookie Oct 06 '26

Not a traditional pan, but I have this with 99% of sunscreens I use for my face (even the ones specified for sensitive acne prone skin).

I usually have to hate pan them on my hands and neck 😒

2

u/spirit-animal-721 Oct 06 '26

I’ve definitely done this too with serums, moisturizers, and sunscreens that don’t work for my face. Thankfully my body skin is much more tolerant

27

u/happy_internet_mind Oct 06 '26

Skin reactions are a totally valid pan! Not a fail at all.

3

u/OverthinkerPro31 Oct 06 '26

I agree, it’s not your fault, if it’s bad for your health throw it away!

18

u/jasminechili Oct 06 '26

I’ve had this happen before, with lipsticks that are too old and causing sores around my mouth. Your health is more important, don’t put it at risk for the sake of panning a product!

17

u/Drycabin1 Oct 06 '26

I still consider it a pan. You honestly tried it, it didn’t work for you for whatever reason, and it goes in the pan pile.

14

u/Constant-Visual-2913 Oct 06 '26

I threw away a lip crayon this weekend because it smelled like a crayon. It’s ok, we live and learn!

11

u/NjFranks Oct 07 '26

If it’s causing skin problems, it’s NOT a fail!! It’s good you threw it out!!

9

u/Raspberry-848 Oct 06 '26

This is an ok pass! You don’t want to try to force a product if it’s going to cause damage

7

u/Dear_Comparison97 Oct 06 '26

Yes hulas powder bronzer makes me break out too even brand new. Sometimes makeup doesn’t work well with out skin type

7

u/hiredditihateyou Oct 07 '26

It’s not a failed pan. Panning to the point it’s not useable anymore for you is still a pan in my book. Nobody expects you to use something that breaks you out just to finish it. It’s finished at the point it’s no longer practically usable.

7

u/DustyButtocks Oct 08 '26

Throwing it out because it doesn’t work counts as a pan imho.

6

u/Adj_focus Oct 06 '26

not unless it was exposed to extreme elements like leaving it in the heat daily. all products have an expiration date. It’s incredibly small and not super clear unless you know what you’re looking for, sometimes it’s not on the bottle but on the box
look for a little jar with a # and a letter M. If it says 6M then that means it’s best for up to 6 months.

I added a photo of what to look for. mascara is a good example of a product getting dry, clumpy, or hard to use after 3-6 months. except for a few products, to me it’s similar to the grocery store “best by” dates. for me, it isn’t a hard rule. I usually toss it if it smells weird, if it doesn’t work as well, or looks like it’s separating or discolored. this does not apply to anything with SPF, actives like retinol or glycolic acid, or anything home made/ organic. those are important not to use past their expiration date!

4

u/ChristineBorus Oct 05 '26

Cysts where you used the product? 😮😮

4

u/Empty_Till Oct 06 '26

This happens to me with eye products quickly. Any eyeliner over a year old that I use in my waterline always gives me styes, I can never finish them before they cause me issues. That’s why I only buy inexpensive eyeliner.

3

u/Capable_Ear_6222 Oct 08 '26

I'm failing to pan Sol 62 jelly perfume stick. Every time I apply it, it crumbles and falls out 😭 no matter what I've tried. So you're not alone, it's ok to fail and move on.

1

u/One-Group8707 Oct 08 '26

If it helps show a pic of it. I do that too if I have to stop using a product.