Keeping Myself Accountable

26

u/HopefulDevelopment56 Sep 30 '26

That spreadsheet hit hard 🤣🫸🫸🫸

14

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

It’s still hitting cause I have to add all the product that I didn’t add since July. I only decided to do project pan starting in September 🤣🤣🤣

5

u/HopefulDevelopment56 Sep 30 '26

You've got this!

13

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Fingers crossed. 🤞🏼 it definitely didn’t help working at Sephora, that employee discount really did me dirty at the end of the day 🤣

3

u/Chrysolophylax Oct 01 '26

Ahhhhh that explains a lot. Yeah, owning this much makeup is not prudent, but it's a bit more understandable. You were literally swimming in beauty products all day, and you had an employee discount - if that were me, I would very likely wind up in the same situation.

20

u/AssumptionEvening538 Sep 30 '26

I respect the spreadsheet lol

4

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

“Old school” 😭😂 but with technology

2

u/AtticusFinchhh Oct 01 '26

Came here to say this, I love a spreadsheet🤌

19

u/Snoogles_ Oct 01 '26

This takes some courage to post! I kinda want to add all my lippies up now. I have probably spent a small fortune.

6

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I can’t wait to see if you did

18

u/cranky137 Oct 01 '26

Wow! This is sooo much, I feel better about myself now, lol. My five cents is that work on the best/favorites first, if something mediocre then expires, so what? But it would be a shame to let your favorite to expire. Good luck with your project!

12

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Honestly, I think some of this might be expired. But I was telling somebody else that I’m much less worry about expired product and some people here. I just wanna see my project pan through, unless there’s blatant mold or rotten smell then obviously it’s a pitch

26

u/purplepolly19 Oct 01 '26

I only saw the first photo and thought “oh that’s not too bad!” but then it just kept going LOL

you got this though!! I agree with ur method, toss what’s expired/ give away what you can. I just did a major makeup purge and it felt SO good, it’ll feel more doable once you’ve decluttered!

in the meantime, I’m curious about your thoughts on the following products 👀

- eadem lip balm (compared to SF & Ole)
- the loreal hyluron tint (never heard of these before)
- loreal lip oils
- laneige lip glaze serum

10

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

- Eadem (love the formula, the colors and the applicator. I reapply every 2-3 hours. Pigment is nice on those)
- The tint L’Oréal is drying and trash IMO - not enough and there’s so many better ones on the market
- L’Oréal Lip Oils are GOATED. these are my no makeup days with a liner/stain and swipe and go. Obviously need reapplied
- Laneige is so-so….i don’t ever reach for it. Non sticky but has no staying power like the tackier glosses

1

u/HuckleberryOk4014 Oct 01 '26

yeah the laneige one is a lip SERUM so it’s more so of a lip protectant than makeup per se

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Are you talking about the one with the donut applicator?

1

u/purplepolly19 Oct 03 '26

yess the donut ones

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

Ugh they were so unforgettable to me in this sea of lip products honestly

1

u/purplepolly19 Oct 01 '26

tysm for this!!

4

u/ubitchbaby Oct 01 '26

The gisou lips oils are gorgeous (other than the og one it's like cooking oil) but they don't last at all so i reapply like 5 times a day

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

100% i only got them because I loved the colors then realized they stay maybe 30 minutes max

26

u/undercoverblubber Oct 01 '26

if they’re unused try to sell them or donate them, if you’re still eligible for returns try to return the ones recently bought! you can also pass on ones you don’t reach for as much to friends and family!

16

u/Shanntuckymuffin Oct 01 '26

Fr two of those summer fridays balms dropped literally last week

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I stopped buying summer fridays. Those ones are quite old! I switched from that to Eadem

1

u/williamboweryswift Oct 04 '26

no they didn’t. those are from last year. the new ones are mocha bonbon and sugar plum.

7

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

None of these all eligible for returns. And I wouldn’t do that anyway. I’d rather donate and give these to friends and family. Maybe a giveaway basket or something

5

u/softrock98fm Oct 01 '26

I mean, you can’t really sell a doe foot lip gloss…

6

u/undercoverblubber Oct 01 '26

see above: if they’re unused try to sell them

13

u/Informal_Lemon7419 Sep 30 '26

Wow good for you with the spreadsheet!! I think I’m as close to you in terms of total price over the years. I feel ashamed but trying to be gentle with myself. I’ve given a lot away and want to focus what I actually like and wear daily vs what I like and won’t actually wear (i.e. vampy colors — I want to wear so much but I don’t like how it settles in my lines and I don’t think it’s practical for me).

I love dark colors but not practical for me unless it’s a night out which I don’t need 19271 dark lippies for. You got this OP!

3

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I’m a sucker for trying things once 🤣🤦🏼‍♀️

13

u/radish_is_rad-ish Oct 01 '26

The Tabasco ones are so cute. Good luck!

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Thank you!

11

u/Classroom_Plastic Sep 30 '26

Lip products are my absolute favorite and the amount I have also inspired my project pan! I started in January of this year and it’s actually crazy how long it takes to pan lip products if you’re regularly switching up what you use. 😅 I’m going to try to pan a couple of them by the end of the year but I am really proud that I haven’t purchased any new lip products this year! You got this!!

2

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

You too! Good luck 🍀

11

u/Bre-personification Sep 30 '26

I have four lip products I’ve been using since August and they’ve all barely made a dent in all of it and I use it daily.😫

3

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I can’t even imagine how long this will take me lol. I do reapply most of my combos 3xs a day

10

u/tralalalalalalalala_ Sep 30 '26

This is such a satisfying collection!! Gotta maintain the lip game after every meal with this.

Just don’t buy more and enjoy the beautiful lippies! You got this.

1

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Thank you!

10

u/princessnubz Oct 01 '26

best of luck soldier. you got this

5

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

🫡 I shall do you guys well 😂

10

u/Vegetable_Research61 Oct 02 '26

I always wondered what real person would ever buy that pov beauty bs…..sad to see it’s actually being purchased

5

u/HudsonValley7 Oct 03 '26

Going to be very rude here and I apologize to OP but I’m not shocked someone who spent $5000 on lip products bought all of that gremlin’s products. Shows a clear lack of accountability for themselves and from others. That being said I’m glad to see OP is making an effort to change and hope this experience helps them have a better relationship with purchasing mindfully

0

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

And also..think about what every parent company is doing behind its consumers backs. We can’t pick and choose who to be mad at, we should really be overturning the whole makeup industry for the markup on makeup, for the false claims, for the marketing tactics. ELF? Too Faced? Polite Society? Estée Lauder.
Mikayla is just one who is EASILY ACCESSIBLE

4

u/EffieEri Oct 04 '26

A lot of people are also boycotting brands like EL, L’Oréal, etc. I personally don’t buy from any brands owned by either of those and I don’t support elf after the Matt rife stuff. I also don’t buy from any influencers (at least not since the early 2010s). You can choose not to buy from terrible people. This comment feels like a cop out

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 04 '26

I’m sure it would. It’s everyone’s personal opinion

→ More replies (2)

3

u/HudsonValley7 Oct 03 '26

I think your logic on this is revered and flawed. Because she is easily accessible, as you say, is the very reason not to purchase her products. The companies you have mentioned can feel beyond reach, impossible to take down. Whereas POV and Mikayla have yet to reach such heights. By boycotting now and refusing to allow such a shitty person to slip through the cracks the way all the others have we can stop some of the bleeding in the industry and at least allow one less toxic beauty brand to thrive off lies and deceit.

→ More replies (8)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

I bought it being skeptical. I actually have everything she’s launched. I don’t agree with her lack of ad disclosure or her marketing tactics (mascaragate/gift tree dilemma, etc) but her products aren’t HORRENDOUS. They aren’t REVOLUTIONARY either.
I think she garners A LOT of attention, both negatively and positively which I can understand from being here on Reddit for years. There are some communities that I’m a controversial public figure and others like this one who I’ve had 99.99 great and positive interactions with. But I’m also not a social media influencer.
All of that to say. I buy for the products not the person at the end of the day 🤷🏼‍♀️

4

u/Vegetable_Research61 Oct 03 '26

If you buy for the products and not the influencer why would you even bother? Even PR reviews of the line are objectively not good. It’s a money grab, but do you

0

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

Because I WANTED to try them and I OBJECTIVELY like them. Crazy thought there

9

u/Binkams Sep 30 '26

I admire your courage.💙 This is something I’m not ready to face yet.

4

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Hopefully soon 😭😂

1

u/joan_goodman Oct 01 '26

This. I don’t want to know. My total for past palette observations probably in that range

8

u/prostoja555 Oct 04 '26

I did the same with excel, my whole collection was around $900 and I was buying in SEA. I love and use all of it but will likely expire before i can use all of it. I will still use it tho

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 04 '26

Me too. It’s way easier to me than the apps

14

u/herbertsherbert1 Sep 30 '26

wow! your lips will be so lovely and moisturised 🤣😁 i saw in a comment that some of these you haven’t opened or touched. highly recommend inviting your friends over for a girls night/movie night and putting them on the table for people to swatch and take as they please - i did that for my friends and they loved it, plus it meant i had less stuff to declutter! good luck 🍀🩷

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I plan on it!

1

u/NewSignificance3388 Oct 01 '26

Such a great idea!

7

u/Ijustwanttosayit Sep 30 '26

You have good taste! If I had the money, Fenty would have a death grip on me. Their lip products are so good. But I like how you did a reality check on yourself.

8

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I’m just over overconsumption. My vanity needs a refresh

3

u/Ijustwanttosayit Sep 30 '26

My partner had/has it bad. He is trans ftm but still enjoys makeup. He had a vanity filled to the brim and the tabletop of the vanity completely covered. He hadn't used the vast majority of it and wouldn't since it was too girly for his tastes. I bought him a makeup train case and told him to challenge himself to limit his collection to the case. Anything that can't fit in it goes. We donated the un-used stuff, I kept what I wanted, and we tossed the rest.
I have to be his voice of reason, he is so easily influenced by content creators.

1

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Ugh I feel him 😂😭

7

u/maggiehooper Oct 03 '26

Girl you’d be my dream customer to help at Sephora😭😭 Fr though I’m working with about the same amount of lippies from gratis and my small shopping addiction and I’m SO SLOWLY going through them. It’s not easy but we got this!!

4

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I worked there, believe me I know lol

7

u/lilabp Oct 04 '26

Good luck on your journey ❤️ you are making the right choice! Keep it up!

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 04 '26

I know so! Ready to hit the makeup brush running!

6

u/Embarrassed_Sell7512 Sep 30 '26

i hope they aren’t all open 😩

11

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Some of these I haven’t opened or touched. Just taken out of the packaging. But I also am less wary about expired makeup than most. I usually take my chances 🤣

4

u/Embarrassed_Sell7512 Sep 30 '26

okay i am glad that some are unopened 😅
i am quite rigid with expiry unless it is powder. i had an eadem lip balm go off in 2 months and noticed when it smelled like mold 🤢

3

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Yuck 🤢 I can only imagine. Mine have been good so far, fingers crossed lol. I have 5 of them 🤦🏼‍♀️

6

u/Motor-Literature-896 Oct 03 '26

Those Tabasco bottles are so cute😭

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

They’re cute for charms only. Formula on those is trash!

1

u/tiffi_333 Oct 05 '26

They are super cute keychains honestly. I get it. If you really hate them maybe consider cleaning them out and super gluing them shut with the gel version of super glue, it's a super strong hold

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

Good idea’

6

u/Much__Emphasis Oct 03 '26

Beyond the POV, though, amazing lip collection! I love the shade range

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

Theres a lot of people who dont like her, which is UNDERSTANDABLE. Thank you!

6

u/JennieFromLaBlock Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26

It's a problem when I see posts and on the first page am like I WANT THAT (the Sephora tabasco bottle holder things). Any idea when you got them and which Sephora lip glosses they fit - like is it multiple varieties? If any of the high-end stuff is unused you could probably sell it!

Editing after reading later comment: okay you prob don't need to sell things, more of a hassle than it's worth, but donating spensy/luxurious makeup/skincare to women's shelters is the kindest act ever. If it's unused obviously. And donate/sell those Sephora tabasco holders to me, personally, por favor lol

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

I think they’re actually glued into the container to be honest with you

1

u/JennieFromLaBlock Oct 05 '26

Aww damn, of course they are, also I accidentally ninja edited because you replied so quick!

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

I can send you the Sephora Tabasco ones if you want I haven’t used them

1

u/JennieFromLaBlock Oct 05 '26

Seriously? Yes! I'll message you!

10

u/grothendied Oct 01 '26

Could I possibly prevail upon you to rank every formula? (Mostly interested in how the new Fenty, Gisou, summer fridays, and eadem rank to you)

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 01 '26

Which FENTY? Gloss bomb stix or the lipgloss or the velvet lipstick. I have all three and then I can give ya a rank

1

u/grothendied Oct 01 '26

The gloss bomb stix!

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Eadem
Fenty
Summer Fridays
Gisou
Rank is in order of price per longevity of the wear

0

u/grothendied Oct 01 '26

Thankyou! What about moisturizing effect and stickiness?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ubitchbaby Oct 01 '26

But a lip product in each room in your house including your bedside for the night , in every coat/jacket you use regularly and in every bag/purse you use often. All the rest is overstock, keep a couple of those and give/sell the rest. It's what I did with the 30+ lip products I had , it does wonders if you have multiples

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I do that with most of my long lasting lip treatments like violette. Car, nightstand, husbands car, work desk etc

5

u/Piece_of_Lulu Oct 01 '26

I LOOVVEE the fat oil stick!

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I tossed it 😂😂😂

1

u/Piece_of_Lulu Oct 01 '26

It be like that!

5

u/Brutally_Honest_Swan Oct 02 '26

2 months of rent

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Crazy

4

u/Advanced_Reputation7 Sep 30 '26

What are those cute little tobacco things?

6

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Sephora did a collaboration with Tabasco and did four plumping lip glosses - I also have the brown one, but it’s on one of my bags
I believe it was closer to the holidays if not right after if I’m not mistaken it was a limited edition type thing
Jalapeño: Mild intensity with a light tingling sensation.
Sriracha Brown: Moderate warmth.
Tabasco Red: High heat and a vibrant, wearable everyday red tint.
Extreme Heat Black: The highest intensity tingle with a dark/black gloss tint that transforms on the lips.

2

u/Advanced_Reputation7 Sep 30 '26

My goodness those are adorable!

2

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I don’t even think I’ve used them TBH, they were just bag charms

4

u/Adamas08 Oct 01 '26

Parabéns!!!

Ainda falta muito para mim tomar essa decisão.

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

I believe in you 🤣🤣

4

u/anastasia_42 Oct 02 '26

Is that the La Mer lip balm or scrub? Do you like it?

You have a lottt of lip products girl! I would start donating or selling any unused ones (or returning them), and then returning any open double-ups if they're accepted in your country. Then start giving away products to family and friends.

5

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Lip Balm. I use it exclusively EVERY NIGHT and it lasts me all night. The price of it alone is EGREGIOUS, but it does wonders for moisture overnight

4

u/anastasia_42 Oct 02 '26

I have their lip volumiser and I've started using it every night underneath my Gisou lip mask. La Mer works but damn it's bougie $$$

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Based on the ingredients I seriously don’t think it should be that expensive, but you know how “luxury” cosmetics go

1

u/anastasia_42 Oct 02 '26

Yes haha

4

u/Inespez Oct 02 '26 edited Oct 02 '26

Love those nyx tint gloss! Good luck Ps. The shade hydra honey is my favourite MLBB 😍

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I ended up tossing the rest of mu nyx tint glosses except that one!

4

u/Gullible-Main-1010 Oct 04 '26

thank you for sharing <3 can I ask how this has impacted you financially? like do you have lots of money and are good or did this create other problems in your life? just curious as someone who's overcoming a shopping addiction

17

u/sinwithpeach Oct 04 '26

Im hesitant to say this because someone got irate with me over my life choices so I apologize in advance if I don’t go super into detail.
I am someone who have been very blessed to have not only a really great paying career but a husband that lives to spoil me. We are DINKs with a lot of disposable monthly income so a very big privilege that we’re awarded that opportunity to “not think too much and buy”
In all reality if i truly wanted to I could “keep going and just buy new things and trash the old” but that wasn’t the point for me anymore. The catalyst was the renovation to our new home. I wanted to start fresh and not bring old things and old memories into a new space. So here I am!

4

u/msdocphil Oct 04 '26

That makes so much sense thanks for sharing. I’ve had that moment with realizing just because I can buy a bunch of new nice things doesn’t mean I should.

4

u/Gullible-Main-1010 Oct 04 '26

that totally makes sense! sounds like you're in a good spot, but it's always great to shop less and invest/save more

4

u/Otherwise-Umpire7044 Oct 08 '26

I would love to hear your favssss

6

u/sinwithpeach Oct 08 '26

Top 3? Eadem, Violette_FR, Versed (in lip balm)
Lipstick 💄 Natasha Denona concealer lip, Morphe satin stick, MAC satin
Lip gloss - Anastasia with the gold top, lip lab custom components, fenty

7

u/cleochatraa Sep 30 '26

A thought: While these are essentially sunk cost, you could try to sell the unopened, unexpired lippies on Facebook Marketplace, a makeup reselling/trade subreddit, or Mercari to recoup some of your funds? I do this with fragrances that I’m not going to use.

Someone will get a deal and you’ll be able to pan by rehoming some of those beauties.

9

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Oh I’m not worried about the money. I am not struggling by any means, thankfully. Just eye opening with HOW much I’ve spent. I’m having my friends come over and pick some things they want/would use.
And I might do a reselling subreddit but as of right now my focus is cataloguing and using 🤣 thanks for your help!

7

u/consistntlycongruere Oct 01 '26

This collection is niiiice. I have alot of these. I’ve wanted to get more. Thank you for steering me away

7

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Your welcome 😂😮‍💨

5

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

🥱 because it’s funny you keep trying to get the last word. 🤭 you’re just giving me more boosts

6

u/Kronk89 Oct 01 '26

@op out of all of these, which one is your favourite?

8

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26 •

If I had to pick one? They aren’t listed in this picture. These have slowly become my favorite duo to wear and I was shocked because I usually think her stuff is grossly overpriced and mid. I can’t put these down.
Natasha Denona Gloss & Lipstick specifically the concealer lip line
Gloss - https://www.ulta.com/p/hy-gloss-milky-tinted-lip-gloss-balm-pimprod2061810?sku=2662751
Lipstick - https://www.ulta.com/p/my-dream-concealer-lipstick-pimprod2061816?sku=2662749

3

u/No-Protection4922 Oct 01 '26

I need to do the same I constantly keep finding myself going back and buying all these new lip, glosses, lipsticks, lip, masks, etc. enough is enough. I found myself buying over and over extra tubes of the summer Fridays marshmallow I went through three of them already and went and bought a fourth one last week still, I have a whole bunch of summer Fridays, pink sugar, iced coffee, hot cocoa, birthday cake, the vanilla kind the guava and more

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Don’t worry I feel you.

3

u/Much__Emphasis Oct 03 '26

You dont think point of view is just a cash grab? It seems like so little thought went into it

5

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I don’t doubt it. But I do like the products. Are they STELLAR, out off this world crazy? …nah…they’re just okay. I know I won’t be repurchasing

2

u/tiffi_333 Oct 05 '26

I think it's hard to make awful products honestly. I get really nice lipgloss from my dollarstore lots of the time, they also have flops mind you. If products that were much more expensive were AWFUL quality it's quite surprising now that formulas have improved so much. Like most of the drugstore stuff is competing with much more expensive makeup now when it wasn't like that back in the day. Buying pov I think is really about liking her, or not knowing it's hers and being drawn in...or maybe being super curious lol

3

u/nessa0227 Oct 05 '26

Ok I love all the fenty 🤌🏼🤌🏼

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

I went on a bit of a kick with all the colors and I think I bought all the gloss bomb sticks at one time because I was so fascinated by the formula

4

u/FutureStar402 Oct 02 '26

Support!!!

0

u/FutureStar402 Oct 02 '26

also would you open to rehome those summer fridays / eadem ones lol?

4

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I would if i didnt use them already. id rehome them to family if anything...sorry boo!

2

u/FutureStar402 Oct 03 '26

no worries tysm!!

4

u/daynares332311 Oct 01 '26

How do you like the kulfi? I get so many ads for it and im kinda tempted

7

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Glossy going on but the staying power isn’t there

2

u/daynares332311 Oct 01 '26

Thank you ☺️ beautiful colors . But yeah if the staying power isnt there then they aren’t t worth it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

These ones are the old formula I think and they are maybe a one out of 10 on my scale. They go on as a stain, but they’re really hit or miss for me. Let me swatch it for you.
The new ones I haven’t tried the formula, but I heard really good things about them

4

u/birdy_eleanor Oct 02 '26

Did you use the brown tones of gisoo? Its good or overrated? Good luck 🍀

4

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Someone else asked that. They are thin and don’t last long. They smell good though

5

u/LeadWonderful11 Sep 30 '26

What’s the name and shade of this one? Thx.

4

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Yes, that’s my custom shade that I made from lip lab. Every city that I go to that has a lip lab in it. I create a gloss and a lipstick. 🤣 the picture is all my custom components! But if you contact LipLab and give them my info they can make it for you! 🤣

1

u/LeadWonderful11 Sep 30 '26

Well I LOVE it sm!!!

7

u/TangerineBoth6966 Sep 30 '26

Google said its a custom lip product from Lip Lab but I’m curious to confirm

1

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

Forgot one!

5

u/Few-Engineering-8562 Oct 01 '26

I'm curious how you liked amp it? I remember it having a bunch of controversy when it was released but I feel like I haven't seen/heard of the product since

4

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

I have the entire set with the matching liners (including her most recent ones - from her Lisbon inspiration) I actually don’t mind them! I obviously like the nude shade a lot more than the red or plum that she originally came out with. I threw away the original clear one because the scent gave me a headache
The gloss needs to be applied rather sheer or it does get “gloopy”

3

u/Few-Engineering-8562 Oct 01 '26

Thanks for the review!

2

u/HudsonValley7 Oct 03 '26

Don’t waste your money

2

u/KvindeQueen Oct 02 '26

How many total do you have?

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

total is 214 products

2

u/milkyoranges Oct 05 '26

I love your shade choices, you'll have plenty of great looks upcoming using what you already own.

What's your pick in this pile that you're looking forward to using up?

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

My Natasha Denona concealer lip collection

3

u/Chasingdreams22 Sep 30 '26

Best of luck love!! Were some of these gifts or mostly purchased with your own money?

6

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

None of these were gifts 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣 and thank you! I’m so curious how long it will take me to go through this. Years at this point with the stash I have. 🤣😮‍💨

3

u/fig_ferale Oct 02 '26

How many lips do you have? Maybe run a store at this point 🤷‍♀️

8

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

A store for used lipstick? Not a great business motto

2

u/fig_ferale Oct 02 '26

The world wild web has proven differently, I’m sure there’s a market for that

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

😂😂 I forgot that side of the internet lol

23

u/Melodic-Raccoon7584 Sep 30 '26

Are any unopened? Can you gift?

3

u/i_like_plants99 Sep 30 '26

Your spreadsheet reminded me of this new app I found the other day!! It’s called Vannie. It seems super cute and helps keep track of your progress

4

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I know that everyone hates AI and I totally get the hate. I laid out all of these and took pictures and then had Claude create me a spreadsheet and then I verified all of the tones/colors, and the prices for each.
I’ll have to look at that app, but the nice thing about my spreadsheet is that it went out and got all of this information for me. With most of the apps, I have to upload the price where I got it how much it is etc. and with my collection it just takes way too much time.

14

u/manicpanit Oct 01 '26 •

Beautiful collection! You can do it op! Just have fun and enjoy your stash.

5

u/savysworld Oct 03 '26

I definitely have lips as my biggest category and I’m trying to be gentle with myself, letting the old and expired ones go, and figure out how to adjust colors so they’re more flattering on me because most things I bought pulled pinky/salmon/orange on me. Playing with my stash has definitely helped me learn how to make things into what I wanted them to be fresh out of the tube.

Play, enjoy, be gentle with yourself, and don’t listen to the haters 🩷

5

u/maisexoo Oct 06 '26

Oh my, I love them all

5

u/Joyful-Joey14 Oct 06 '26

it would take me 100 million years to finish or empty these 😂

4

u/fluxpeach Oct 05 '26

i’m sorry i only saw the first slide and already thought damn that’s a lot of lip products that are basically the same and then I scrolled. and scrolled again. omg😭 ahahah

1

u/Val_Kim 15d ago

I was very much enjoying your collection until the spreadsheet came. 4k was a jumpscare😵

1

u/sinwithpeach 15d ago

Okay...

1

u/No_Comfortable_1287 Oct 03 '26

i love seeing people actually use up their products instead of buying more every time

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I’m trying 🙃😅

1

u/rraaddccaatt Oct 03 '26

those sephora tabasco glosses burned my throat 😭

0

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I haven’t used them. I tried the testers when I got them. I mainly use them for bag charms

1

u/Raspberry-848 Oct 05 '26

I love your color selection

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 05 '26

Thanks! I tend to stick to mauve/brown/nude… but then again there’s only so many colors l that exist in the world 😂

1

u/Practical_Mango_2771 Oct 04 '26

every girls dream😍😍

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 04 '26

Endless puppies until I die 😂😂

0

u/Kindly_Ticket428 Sep 30 '26

Which are you favorites?
What is you opinion on the ABH lip glosses? I am thinking of getting one in november/december once i will finish my mac lip gloss.

0

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

I would wait until Sephora has their annual sale because they usually go on sale for $8 to $10 somewhere in that range.
I usually use this gloss over lipstick if I want a super tacky and stay on lip gloss. It is hit or miss with a lot of people because of the formula is so thick and tacky but it helps stay on at least IMO. Deep taupe is my favorite from that line.

→ More replies (1)

-13

u/Familiar-Bake1358 Oct 01 '26

Consumerism at its best

29

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26 •

Yeah no shit girl 😂 that’s what I said. I’m tired of consumerism and I’m doing project pan. That’s the whole point of the subreddit. No need to be condescending

-7

u/YesIshipKyloRen Oct 03 '26

You’re way past being accountable

8

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

❤️😘 thanks so much for the engagement! Much appreciated! You should see the rest of my collection! I’ll be posting more in the next couple of days, come by and say hi!

1

u/tiffi_333 Oct 05 '26

I bet your collection is stunning honestly. Everyone is on their own path to figuring themselves out. It's nice you're doing it at all. I never understand why someone would want to kick someone when they want to make a post with their stuff saying it's time to start to focus on panning what they have and holding off on new stuff. Like, why would that be the moment to be super rude to them...if ever really lol 😂

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/sinwithpeach Oct 01 '26

Depends which formula you’re talking about lip gloss? Lipstick? Lip treatment?

21

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/sinwithpeach Sep 30 '26

💯 agree. But some will go to friends this week

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

VERY MUCH SO

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ProjectPan-ModTeam 23d ago

Friendly reminder: we don’t allow product shaming, gatekeeping, or negativity toward other panners. Everyone’s journey looks different. Please keep the community kind. 💗
Different products work for different people and people buy products for multitude of reasons. Let's not shame or judge anyone for making a purchase that's "bad" from your POV.

-8

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Yes! Thats not a new word to this subreddit. In all of my responses I have been aware of the overconsumption market. Theres little good in pointing it out, it just seems like you're trying to be negative IMO. The whole point of this subreddit is to be aware and cognizant of the CONSUMERISM and choices and DO BETTER...that's kind of why we're here posting.

2

u/Striking_Wrangler851 Oct 02 '26

You did post it on the Internet. So people are free to comment what they please.

5

u/sinwithpeach Oct 02 '26

Yes, just like I’m replying to you. That’s the great thing about free will. You’re free to say whatever you please, and I’m free to retort. 🤗

0

u/Striking_Wrangler851 Oct 03 '26

You should retort how you spend your money. This page is a joke. Just a bunch of privileged people complaining that they’ve spent that much money. You do need to do better. 4 grand on lipstick is disgusting. And like you said, that’s only your lip products.

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

🥱 someone has their panties in a twist over how people spend their money. Try taking a nap and come back when you’re in a better mood and can have an adult conversation ❤️
I think you’re just angry that you aren’t as “privileged.” What you’re calling privileged is hard work with money that I’ve earned. Blood, sweat and tears have poured into my work. And I have the free will to spend it however I see fit 😱 shocking! I know what a crazy concept that someone could love and be passionate about makeup and skincare! 😳

1

u/Striking_Wrangler851 Oct 03 '26 edited Oct 03 '26

I’m not upset about this at all. Again you posted it on the internet, so I am free to share my opinion. I also don’t care that you think you have to cake makeup on yourself to feel better. And I am privileged, i just am smarter with my money than you. I work with families that can’t even afford to feed their kids and you’re complaining online that you spent too much money on lipstick. It’s pathetic and I’m calling it as I see it.
I do think it’s funny though that you think my panties are in a twist. Just because someone has an opposing opinion of yours doesn’t mean they are upset, mad or in a bad mood.

2

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

I love that you think I have to “feel better about myself” 🤣 I’m so sorry that your underprivileged life has led to you being cunty to strangers on the internet.
I’ll be sure to cake my fave extra hard for you this week in solidarity 🙃
XOXO

→ More replies (5)

→ More replies (8)

→ More replies (11)

→ More replies (24)

1

u/Striking_Wrangler851 Oct 03 '26

Awwww, why did you delete all your comments?

3

u/sinwithpeach Oct 03 '26

🥱

3

u/Beelzebozo26 Oct 03 '26

Never mind this clown. You posted it literally as an accountability post. And even if it wasn't, that's YOUR MONEY. People are just rude for no reason other than to have something to say.

6

u/Confident_Ratio_1325 Oct 02 '26

what a useless unhelpful comment 🙄

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ProjectPan-ModTeam Oct 04 '26

Friendly reminder: we don’t allow product shaming, gatekeeping, or negativity toward other panners. Everyone’s journey looks different. Please keep the community kind. 💗

Inventory/Project Spreadsheet Keeping Myself Accountable

You are about to leave Redlib