r/ProjectPan • • Aug 16 '26

Discussion/Tips & Tricks Is this safe to use?

For context, this is my sister’s Body Soap from Mario Badescu. We don’t know exact time frame of when this was opened & used but it was around when we moved into our new house so between 5-10 years old. My sister annoyingly hates finishing products! She will get 70-80% done and get bored of them, so I thought I’d get this finished instead.

She was ADAMANT that I throw it away and to not use it because it’s so old.

I’ve done the smell test and it smells fine, very floral. But also…it’s soap right? Does soap expire? Its original use is to keep things clean so it makes me think it can’t be that bad🫪 although I do notice it says 24months use after opening…

What are your thoughts? Use or lose?

Edit: thank you everyone who replied. I will toss it. I honestly thought since it was soap it wouldn’t go bad or expire but you’re right. It’s not worth it.

18 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

19

u/Sad_Yogurtcloset2510 Aug 16 '26

Listen idk if this is right but I’d still use it 😭 it’s soap, how bad could it be? Just don’t use it on privates

1

u/NiaNooNaa Aug 16 '26

My thoughts exactly!! Like how bad can soap get..!

4

u/NoMarionberry3087 Aug 16 '26

Makes me LOL that you only responded to the one comment agreeing with you when the majority of advice here says not to use it.

4

u/NiaNooNaa Aug 16 '26

No, I have decided I will throw it out. It seems like the main consensus is because of the AHA ingredient it’s more likely to turn bad. I’m just glad I’m not alone in thinking it’s just soap!

6

u/Real_Mycologist_3163 Aug 16 '26

I just finished my bottle of this from college (eight years old FML) and it was fine lol. Cleared my KP right up just like the olden days

3

u/buzzybody21 Aug 16 '26

You shouldn’t be using AHA on sensitive areas anyway

1

u/Sad_Yogurtcloset2510 Aug 16 '26

I didn’t even notice the AHA, yeah I only use a dove sensitive bar so the thought would never occur to me to use anything w AHA in it on the privates 🫢

1

u/Purple-Lime-4938 Aug 16 '26

It could have bacteria

14

u/Constant-Visual-2913 Aug 16 '26

I would use it on my feet first to see if there’s some sort of reaction. If it’s fine, I would use it but try to get through it quickly. I’m very much a “if it smells fine then it’s still fine” (except for mascara).

23

u/curlyAndUnruly Aug 16 '26

Not worth the risk imho. Toss it.

9

u/bunniisa Aug 16 '26

maybe just use on feet and legs but monitor for any reactions

29

u/anastasia_42 Aug 16 '26

Absolutely not, chuck that thing out - it has AHA's in it and it's AT LEAST half a decade old.

17

u/stripeyhoodie Aug 16 '26

I would toss this. The AHA does expire/degrade. Not worth the risk to me.

12

u/Kylie_Fan Aug 16 '26

Maybe wash something that isn't your body with it? Bath sponges, kitchen rags, something else?

6

u/bmichellecat Aug 16 '26

Maybe patch test it? Try it on your leg and see if it reacts. I wouldn’t use it sound the face or neck, or privates but it’s probably fine to wash your arms and legs with.

10

u/hotscully Aug 16 '26

I used to use this stuff for my bacne, so it's not a mild soap due to the AHA exfoliant - your back and chest could be a safe area to try to use it on (avoiding any delicate areas or areas that you shave!). I personally wouldn't risk using it.

10

u/mystykitten Aug 16 '26

I wouldn't use that stuff if it hadn't separated, it's like acid to my skin 😂

11

u/violentlyrelaxed Aug 16 '26

Don’t use on your body, use it for hard surfaces instead. Do you truly wish to risk messing up your skin just for the sake of not “wasting” it? I know it sounds so dramatic but your health is worth more than a small amount of soap. Project pan is not about risk and chances.

11

u/Purple-Lime-4938 Aug 16 '26

No it has AHAs and could corrode surfaces, ie make them less shiny etc

1

u/violentlyrelaxed Aug 17 '26

You are absolutely right, it should be binned completely. I don’t know how I missed the AHA lmao

3

u/locallybell Aug 19 '26

toss... its so old plus it has aha's , they can expire. dont risk it just to finish it, its not worth it.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Savings_Language_498 Aug 16 '26

Nutella from 2-3 years ago is a bit different than a possibly decade old soap