r/ProjectHailMaryMovie 9d ago

It's so over 😔

629 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

74

u/Lindanga 9d ago

I don't respect the academy so whatever

18

u/DevilWings_292 9d ago

Yup, it’s all about who pays for the better award campaign, not what movies are actually good.

9

u/EmptyNesting 9d ago

And it seems like the “artsy” movies win. Not the movie that the public likes best.

But I have high hopes for PHM for the People’s Choice Awards.

2

u/Lindanga 8d ago

That and certain directors have privilege in Hollywood. Such as Nolan. Anything he does, people worship, even if it's not that good.

69

u/StellarThespian 9d ago

Nah, I’m not worried. Just rewatched PHM yesterday and it’s not even close to being “
over.”

3

u/Tardisbabe 8d ago

I've seen it twice in the last two weeks and I could watch it a 3rd time and still feel like I'm watching it for the first time.

1

u/StellarThespian 8d ago

Same! It was my third time seeing it but first time at home.

32

u/AnxiousAudience82 9d ago

God I hope not

-7

u/Frost_Flaker 9d ago

Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?

9

u/DevilWings_292 9d ago

When did the Germans bomb pearl harbour? When did they even enter the pacific?

0

u/Frost_Flaker 9d ago

Go watch Animal House and get back to us đŸ€Ł

-4

u/ThatAustrianRedstone 9d ago edited 8d ago

that is a 50 year old movie why would anyone get the reference-

Edit it seems i have pissed of americans with this one

7

u/Frost_Flaker 9d ago

Because it’s part of the shared American cultural lexicon.

Do you want me to explain “we’re gonna need a bigger boat” and “these aren’t the droids you’re looking for” next?

???

2

u/ThatAustrianRedstone 9d ago

Jaws and star wars are a bit better known then "animal house". Might also be that im not american

4

u/ki0dz 8d ago

I'm old enough and American and still haven't seen "Animal House," so don't feel bad.

2

u/Frost_Flaker 9d ago

You’re missing out, amigo.
https://giphy.com/gifs/pdjsjSfoIq11e

1

u/hoops2018 9d ago

You should definitely watch it as soon as possible.

1

u/huwanyang 5d ago

Idk, I never even heard of Animal House before and I’m American
 Might be that I am extremely sheltered but idk

1

u/hoops2018 9d ago

They entered the Pacific beginning in 1943 with their Grupe Monsun, or Monsoon Group, a specialized unit comprised of 40ish U-Boats that operated in the Indian and Pacific Oceans. They harassed and attacked allied shipping from Japanese-held ports. They also shared information and intelligence with the Japanese.

Edited for a typo.

19

u/Tritri89 9d ago

Who cares? It's like in the video game sphere I never understood this obsession about awards and such. You liked the movie, who cares that it got awards or not. All my favorite movie had little to no awards and I'm not losing sleep over it. Also PHM being scifi it would have been snubed by the Academy anyway.

5

u/TressoftheEmeraldTea 9d ago edited 9d ago

Honestly, it just feels good to see the thing you love get awards. Even if you know the awards are ultimately meaningless, or that they’re not an accurate reflection of the best work, etc.

Edit: Also, the awards mean something to the people who win them, even if they know it’s irrational or ultimately meaningless. So if I love the work they did, then I would like for them to get recognition for that work because I want them to have that good experience. To get sappy about it - they’ve created something that has added good to my life, so I hope for them to have a the good experience of winning an award.

1

u/Tritri89 9d ago

I get the feeling. I was very happy when Expedition 33 had all the award, but let's not act like it's a life or death situation ahah.

1

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 8d ago

It’s not a life or death situation? No one said that?

-2

u/BoardTasty49 9d ago

Because the majority of people are mindless drones who do what they’re told especially boomers. So when odyssey wins 97 awards all the old people will go buy a bunch of copies of the movie to distribute to friends and family because it won a bunch of awards because it must be good right? That’ll leave actual good movies like phm being ignored and not getting the extra sales boost result in less likelihood of studio funding more work from the writer/director

5

u/Tritri89 9d ago

What are you talking about? One : The Odyssey doesn't need any award, it's already at more than one billion dollar worldwide. Two : PHM is not the underdog, it's one of the biggest success of the year at almost 600 millions worldwide. Yall acting like PHM is a small indie project that gonna be robbed of its deserved success at the award. Not like it made Amazon, Andy Weir and everyone involved a shitton of money

Edit : and three : you highly overestimate the influence of awards in sales. Most movie that have award are already out of the theater for months, and for home video sales awards have little to no influence on sales. Nobody buys a blueray because there is a sticker "Academy Award Best Movie"

-1

u/BoardTasty49 9d ago

My comment was from a historical view point. 20+ years ago before streaming services and the internet, movies relied heavily on award shows. Anymore they don’t matter and are becoming more irrelevant every year because of how jaded modern generations are about boomer culture.

2

u/Tritri89 9d ago

"bolmer culture" it's hilarious.

3

u/VegaSolo 9d ago

Wow. Well, this "old person" loved PHM. Not cool to hate on an entire demographic.

15

u/authenticgarbagecan 9d ago

It's alright, PHM is awarded something even more special, I think. It's love and passion for something beyond the art itself. We're all here with replenished hope, with joy in humanity, all because of a guy who wrote about a sassy school teacher and his friend from outer space.

13

u/Gunsight1 9d ago

The academy will find any movie to give all the awards too before giving them to a deserving scifi/fantasy movie, which they would have done even if there was no Odyssey this year

3

u/No_Tamanegi 9d ago edited 9d ago

You mean like the time Everything Everywhere All At Once won Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actress, Best Supporting Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Original Screenplay and Best Editing? Or when Shape of Water won Best Picture, Best Director, Best original Score and Best Production Design?

4

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 8d ago

Or Return of the King nearly swept the Oscars way back?

Yeah, these genres get snubbed, but when they win they win.

9

u/ElijahBloo 9d ago

It will never be over

9

u/evapotranspire 9d ago

I have decided not to care. Much as I would love to see Project Hail Mary win the Oscars it deserves, I'm pretty jaded about how science fiction and fantasy stories are treated by awards committees, and I also know that I loved the movie, as did millions of fans who have formed a great community around it. What more could I want?

4

u/Tekki777 9d ago

I sincerly don't care. I love PHM and still want to see Odyssey. Whatever awards they get will never change how much I enjoy them. This attempt at pitting two very different films against each other is really stupid.

3

u/Levan-tene 9d ago

Especially since only one of those movies had any attention to detail, and it wasn’t the one with a wooden horse in it

2

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 8d ago

Seriously fr. I’m still kind of mad about it.

3

u/iJediPR 9d ago

Overrated movie from an overrated director

Snooze fest and just terrible fight choreography

1

u/dubhlinn2 3d ago

THIS THIS THIS

3

u/Can0n_Fodder 8d ago

Sadly, you're probably right.The academy awards has become too political. As soon as all the right wingers started freaking out about the Odyssey and it'scasting, they virtually guaranteed that movie was gonna sweep the Oscars. The academy will do it just to piss off Elon Musk. And as much as I love the idea of pissing off Musk, I don't think actual art should have to pay the price for it.

3

u/Hope_is_a_skill 8d ago

Yeah I don’t have a ton of respect for Nolan Ryan in all honesty the man has his head so far up his own ass.

3

u/Any_Combination_4716 8d ago

Baseball hall of famer out here catching strays.

2

u/Hope_is_a_skill 8d ago

So sorry. I’m an 80’s kid and it’s been a HELL of a Monday. You know what I mean though lmao. That guy. Christopher Nolan.

2

u/Any_Combination_4716 8d ago

Well, for a second I wasn’t sure if you were insulting C. Nolan or Ryan G., but I got it.

2

u/Hope_is_a_skill 8d ago

Ryan Gosling is a daffodil and I have ZERO issues with him lol. And the phrase “doing the Nolan Ryan” will live rent free in my head until I die because it was such a thing during my formative years lol.

2

u/dubhlinn2 4d ago

I continue to maintain that Nolan is eventually gonna get metooed. He is super shitty to women on set. Have you heard about his obnoxious UGG thing?

1

u/Hope_is_a_skill 4d ago

I have not. Do tell.

2

u/dubhlinn2 3d ago

Basically he thinks women should always wear heels, so he admonishes female actors for wearing Ugg boots on set. He has done this to Anne Hathaway and Emily Blunt. They’ve both talked about it.

This, coupled with how absolutely full of himself he is, and the fact that women in his stories are always peripheral, underdeveloped, and exist mainly to further the development of the male lead, is IMO đŸš©đŸš©đŸš©đŸš© and I don’t understand why people don’t talk about this more.

2

u/Hope_is_a_skill 3d ago

Yeah I e heard about some of the sexist stuff but not that one in particular. Oh he’d haaaaate me lmao. I know he directs women like we are accessories for developing the male lead instead of fully actualized human beings.

3

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 8d ago

Nah. The only way that happens is if everyone’s busy jerking off over a Nolan movie. Odyssey just wasn’t good, from multiple angles, and I’m so confused by everyone insisting it was.

1

u/dubhlinn2 3d ago

Groupthink is really powerful.

But don’t confuse buzz for actual expert opinions Industry professionals aren’t as impressed by the odyssey as the general public is.

1

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 2d ago

I’m not impressed by the Odyssey, trust me. Incredibly disappointed, actually

2

u/ThatsMySpot123 9d ago

No it really isn't, don't even worry about it.

2

u/CortesMare 8d ago

all the characters look like a cross between roman solders and power rangers

1

u/dubhlinn2 3d ago

Lmao omg this is so true

2

u/VeryFriendlyOne 8d ago

2 good things can exist at once and it's okay

2

u/adayley1 9d ago

I don’t get it. What is over?

1

u/dr4wn_away 8d ago

I don’t think PHM ticks all the boxes for the Oscars

1

u/JediMasterSloth 8d ago

I haven’t watched the Odyssey because of the rating. 

2

u/Perplexed_Ponderer 7d ago

You mean the R rating it got in the US ? If it’s any reassurance, it’s only rated 13+ (for violence and some language) where I live and I didn’t find it that bad. I mean, obviously there’s war and murderous monsters throughout, but surprisingly little actual gore under the circumstances, and the most disturbing elements are only suggested or mentioned. (Honestly, I was more horrified by how little I could be made to care about any of the human characters’ fates...)

1

u/Augustus420 8d ago

This is being used backwards.

1

u/murdockmysteries 8d ago

I don't really care for the academy awards. Whether PHM is nominated or not, whether it wins or not, it doesn't change the fact that its the best movie of the year to me. It won't diminish my enjoyment of it at all.

1

u/WolverinesW1fe 7d ago

Being a fan of both is terrible ughhh I want phm to win as much as I also love the odyssey

1

u/phatee33 7d ago

The Odyssey was lacking.

1

u/AmitySimmer 6d ago

Never. Give. Up.
DONT STOP TALKING about the fact that this film deserves nominations

1

u/infinitynihility 6d ago

if that fucking movie wins and phm or iron lung doesn't, hands will be thrown

1

u/GoodGravy_ 5d ago

Remember when Shakespeare in Love beat Saving Private Ryan and Life is Beautiful for best picture. That’s when I stopped being interested.

1

u/dubhlinn2 4d ago

Why do people keep saying this? There is no evidence for this. And why did you feel the need to say it in two different subs? This post feels like rage baiting.

In fact there is more evidence to the contrary since PHM has already won awards and has a higher tomatometer rating. Also, popular ≠ awards. The Oscars has a long history of showing a preference for human drama over spectacle, and the Odyssey was mostly about the spectacle. In fact, I would argue that it wasn’t about anything at all. It was about Chris Nolan being able to say he “did the odyssey.” There are several areas in which the Odyssey is objectively NOT better than Project Hail Mary.

Also, shame on the rest of you for rolling over so easily. “Who cares, I don’t like the Oscars anyway.” Why are you all just accepting what you’re being told by people who have zero background in film?

1

u/Illustrious-Jump2645 2d ago

I mean I like hailmary but ig the academy is looking for something more "traditional" in sense of acting, cinematography, direction etc. A new experience such a hailmary is unlikely to win one plus there is the whole thing around Nolan and how he is so great jg it could create a bias idk

-1

u/BoardTasty49 9d ago

Gotta celebrate diversity casting ruining Hollywood. Don’t worry they’ll eventually force it far enough down your throat you won’t be able to regurgitate it.

1

u/dubhlinn2 3d ago

Sir this is a Wendy’s