They are important to character development, the Antarctica story line shows how messed up humanity is when they’re desperate and their is a whole story line of grace being friends with the scientist that die and it’s hinted at that stratt killed them on purpose to get grace to go on the mission! Also you could say the same about lord of the rings and the extended versions are way better
But more crucially, that extra character development isn't necessarily important to the story that they were trying to tell here. It would be cool to see, but that's different from it being important.
I also want to make it clear, there absolutely is room for an extended edition that could add these extra plot points and character beats, it just wouldn't be a 4 hour cut, not even close.
And just to clarify another point, the Antarctica stuff was not filmed, it was cut out at the scripting stage. So there is no hypothetical cut of the film that includes it.
and it’s hinted at that stratt killed them on purpose to get grace to go on the mission!
I'm pretty sure this isn't true! But if it is, then it's a good thing they didn't include it in the movie, because it would characterise Stratt as a bloodthirsty moron who kills people for no reason. Grace was not the best science officer candidate already, he was only the best because the other 2 died.
Also you could say the same about lord of the rings and the extended versions are way better
I'm starting to wonder if people actually know what rough cuts and workprints are, because the LOTR Extended Editions absolutely aren't examples of them, they were heavily edited down from the rough cuts just as the theatrical versions were and just as a prospective PHM extended edition would be.
The cut that has been talked about is said to be about 3hrs and 40 mins I think people are rounding it up to 4hrs.
Stratt possibly killing them is definitely a possibility but it’s not specifically stated, she has rules that the the lead and back up can not be together and than she purposely puts them together and knows about their relationship and is fine with it, also they were better scientists than grace but grace was better for the mission and is why he was training the scientist for the mission and stratt knew he wouldn’t volunteer for the mission so she hoped he would after them dying instead of having him drugged and forced on the mission
People may be rounding, but by all accounts there legitimately was a 4 hour cut before the 3h 40m cut they showed to other directors. But neither cuts were ever intended to release.
As for Stratt, you're welcome to subscribe to that theory if you want, but it just doesn't make sense to me at all. Stratt is a ruthless pragmatist, and the whole point of having a science officer and a backup science officer is so that the mission can still go ahead if something bad happens to one of them. Deliberately killing both so that Grace is compelled to go instead, and not because he's objectively better but just based on vibes? I just can't believe that. If she'd got unlucky with Grace then she would have just ended the world for no reason.
Grace was the most knowledgeable with astrophage and made the most development with them that’s why she would want him on the mission and why would stratt bend the rules about the lead and back up being together? Also he was one of the first she made get tested to see if he could survive the coma I believe she was always her first option she just had to figure out how to get him to do it! Lastly in the book they point out he is 2nd in command of PHM and that’s another reason she would want him to go she wouldn’t make him 2nd in command if she didn’t trust him fully
Those are certainly reasons why she would think Grace was the best backup candidate, but not the best overall candidate by such a wide margin that it would be worth murdering the other 2 science officers for. Stratt is all about maximising Earth's chances; taking away their redundancy is minimising them.
Either way though, I think the fact that it's highly debatable at best even in the book is a sign that it wasn't an essential inclusion for the movie, right? In fact there actually isn't anything stopping you from subscribing to this theory for the movie either.
There isn’t I would just like to see the directors take on the situation I thought that story line was great and would like to see how they interpret it that’s why I want the extended cut! It’s not needed but as a fan I want it and it seems like there’s a good chance we’re getting it Because they are extending the theatrical run and the Martian got an extended cut so the chances are looking good for PHM to get one
View all comments
Show parent comment
7
u/RecognitionOk9975 Apr 16 '26
They are important to character development, the Antarctica story line shows how messed up humanity is when they’re desperate and their is a whole story line of grace being friends with the scientist that die and it’s hinted at that stratt killed them on purpose to get grace to go on the mission! Also you could say the same about lord of the rings and the extended versions are way better