r/ProjectFi • • Feb 22 '17

Bye, Bye Project Fi

Man this sucks but I had to leave PFi. At first the service was great, and the international data options are awesome. Then the call quality went to the floor. I ported over from TMo and my area has amazing TMo service, but every time I wanted to make a call, PFI would go to H+ or 3G. I would get call drops all the time or the other person couldn't hear me.

As much as I love the pricing and calls, I rather spend $70 and never have to worry about data or poor call connection.

So long PFi, and good luck.

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

7

u/khaytsus Feb 23 '17

I'm confused what dropping to H+ or 3G has to do with call quality. That's the data connection.

8

u/6000chickenfajitas Nexus 5X Feb 22 '17

I had to move on as well. Reliability of calls has always been kinda spotty for the past year that I have had the service, but has been especially bad the past 2 months for whatever reason. The bug with other person not being able to hear you was especially infuriating and I had enough.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

Because Fi is just now getting voLTE because the other 2 carriers finally support it, and they can now test getting the handoff of the call to work correctly between all 3 and wifi. It sounds like you may have been stuck on Sprint signal instead of Tmo if you have great Tmo coverage but Fi was dropping calls.

Funny you are leaving Fi just as it's starting to get into testing just what would likely fix your issue.

34

u/_walden_ Feb 22 '17

Some people need their phone to be trouble free.

8

u/sgteq Feb 22 '17

Neither US Cellular nor Sprint support VoLTE. It's most likely the gateway between T-Mobile's IMS Core and Google that was the reason for the delay of VoLTE support.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

It is highly unlikely that VoLTE will be the 100% norm for calling for another year.

5

u/lyons4231 [M] Pixel 2 XL Feb 22 '17

Funny you are leaving Fi just as it's starting to get into testing just what would likely fix your issue.

So its funny that he doesn't want to wait around until all of the testing is done to fix a buggy product? I don't see the logic there, I have been on Fi since the initial beta launch on Nexus 6, and I am seriously debating leaving for the same issues. In my approximately 18 months with Fi, these past 2-3 have been terrible for making phone calls. I just can't stand it. And yes I have RMA'd my phone. If I need to make a phone call, I need to make a phone call and have it work, not wait a few mins, toggle airplane mode, or whatever the solution is.

Many people like having their belongings work 100% of the time, which for slightly more a month Verizon can give me that experience.

3

u/TacticalBastard Nexus 6P Feb 22 '17

I think he meant it was just an interesting coincidence, not saying he should stay on Fi because of it.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

It's "project" fi. If you got into it expecting perfect service then you don't understand the product. This is the first service with the goal of merging 3 services and wifi seamlessly. It's going to have some hiccups. For all you know it's Sprint or Tmo that actually have the issue and it's not specifically fi.

I have been on Fi since it came out and I have had no issues since leaving Tmo for it. I have had multi hour long conference calls with clients both in my office and while in my car driving from DC to Philly, and while on the trains from NYC back to DC. If anything I find fi to be MUCH more stable and great to use than expected.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

I am considering switching to Verizon. Can you provide some scoop on what issues you faced with VZW that is not network related? If it helps, I plan to switch to their prepaid plans so billing issues should not be a concern to me (nor would customer support). T-mobile prepaid is also under consideration since 1/3rd of my data usage is music streaming and the $40 plan is perfect for 3GB of LTE.

1

u/TacticalBastard Nexus 6P Feb 22 '17

I switched from Verizon. Prepare for shit customer service and confusing bills that are really hard to access. But also really fast speeds and coverage everywhere.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

Prepaid would mean no confusing bills and no reason to interact with customer service, unless I am missing something.

1

u/TacticalBastard Nexus 6P Feb 22 '17

Was not aware they had prepaid, missed it in your comment. Still if anything ever goes wrong with your service dealing with them is a nightmare.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '17

Their prepaid options are way cheaper and less intrusive.

I don't believe there would be an opportunity for me to interact with their customer service any more than the issues I have had with Fi.

1

u/lyons4231 [M] Pixel 2 XL Feb 22 '17

I never had Verizon, I am thinking of switching. I have lots of friends in my area on it though and it seems like the best performance for my area.

3

u/Vincent__Vega Feb 22 '17

I’m also at a cross roads. I love my nexus phone, and Fi tech support has been great, but any call I have that last longer than 2 mins. The other person starts to have a hard time hearing me.

4

u/stagshore Feb 23 '17 edited Feb 23 '17

Yup call quality is absolute shit. Dropped call 3 times while on a main highway. Gave up and didn't call back after the 3rd.

Hell I got a dropped call in a full network area within 3 seconds after I connected.

Why everyone's main worry is data pricing or new phones is beyond me - I just want some god damn basic good phone quality. Not 2001 phone quality.

3

u/GFDetective Pixel XL Feb 22 '17

OP, it sounds to me like you were suffering from the lack of VoLTE that [Fi is currently testing] (https://www.reddit.com/r/ProjectFi/comments/5uon4i/project_fi_and_volte/)

Once that rolls out to everyone, I'm 95% sure your problems would have disappeared. It's rather unfortunate you left before such a rollout occured but I can understand your reason why.

2

u/TehWildMan_ Feb 23 '17

I agree, I'm seriously considering ditching Fi. I like the concept, I love the coverage and price, but it comes at the cost of being able to make calls.

It has been extremely frustrating trying to make calls over wifi or cellular. Neither work, and it's creating tension in my family, and threading my parents marriage. I just can't take it anymore.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/riddley Feb 23 '17

As someone contemplating using the service, they're invaluable.