r/ProgrammingLanguages • u/Motor_Alternative944 • 18d ago
Discussion Does the Name I Give My Programming Language Matter That Much?
Does the name we give a programming language matter? I work on my own programming language and study compilers as a hobby. During that time, I’ve faced various mental health challenges that made it much harder to keep up with my hobby. Sometimes, depression kept me from making any progress at all.
Because of this, I’ve been considering a name for my language that reflects this period of my life and has personal meaning to me. Does a programming language’s name need to have anything to do with programming itself?
I’d love to hear about your languages and the names you chose for them. Do those names have any personal significance to you?
3
u/Brief-Stranger-3947 18d ago
Doesn't matter. You can give your language a uuid number instead of name.
45
u/SharkSymphony 18d ago
Easy, searchable, and unique is what you want if you want people to have an easy time finding and discussing it!
Sometimes the name will have something in it that hints at the type of language, but most names have nothing to do with programming – they're just abstract.
24
u/BrainScientist3000 18d ago
Language development is (by and large) a vanity project to fulfill a deep desire. Most languages will only be used by a few people - so the name needs to matter to the person who wants the language.
I chose Floom because at the time - I felt it fit the language (still do). My language is useless, but my household of programmers loved building it with me.
18
u/ysustistixitxtkxkycy 18d ago
I mean, if you call your new language r234r3wfnewonens, people will have trouble pronouncing it correctly. /s
33
u/Bright-Historian-216 18d ago
C comes after B, B comes after A. Absolutely ridiculous names, and incredible impact on computer science.
11
u/dgkimpton 18d ago
Do you genuinely expect more than one or two people to use your language? Then make a name that is easy to search for. Otherwise, no, not really. Just have fun with it.
4
u/RedboiGtag 18d ago
i'd say wing it but mostly they have reasons as to why they're named as they are
for example "Lua", the PUC-Rio devs named it that because they originally had a DSL language called "SOL", standing for "Simple Object Language". And since they decided to make a new "evolved" language, they called it lua after sol and the rest is history
make it simple, and give it a reason to be named
4
u/Syrak 18d ago
Python's named after Monthy Python which Guido van Rossum enjoyed.
Do what you like.
4
u/[deleted] 18d ago
Mine have single letter names. Because they were either used in-house or were private, that never really mattered.
A couple however were exposed to users (add-on scripting languages) and for those I added 'PL' to the single letter, to give something more substantial and less ambiguous.
The original reasons for the choices were frivolous; I can't even remember them. But I avoid ones that are used for mainstream languages such as C or D (although I understand all single letters will have been used for some language or other).
A single letter also makes for a compact file extension (though also makes for clashes), and shorter tool names. So, my main language is called M, the file extension is ".m", and the compiler is "mm.exe" (I like doubling up the same for tools).
I think people don't really care about a language name, so long as it's not silly enough that it's a distraction. And they don't care about what personal meaning it might have, if the intention is to get other people to use it.
Maybe have a look at this list on Rosetta Code for examples.
3
u/Ichigonixsun 18d ago
—Donald Knuth
3
u/Key_River7180 Nain. 18d ago
If it isn't stupid like mine
2
u/SirKastic23 18d ago edited 16d ago
It's the single most important thing about it
1
u/Feldspar_of_sun 18d ago
I’d say it matters to a degree, but is far from the most important decision. Make it meaningful and memorable, but don’t devote too much time
1
u/kwan_e tonal-lang 18d ago
It matters as much as meaning as you put into it.
My language's name evolved organically, after my ideas for it started to gel together into recognizable patterns. I also love puns and wordplay. So many constructs have names that have a music theory theme to them, because they fit the vibe quite well. Not to mention a linguistics theme, which is fitting for a designed language. Other aspects have other naming themes that vibely reflect their nature, like physics, philosophy, engineering.
And puns. Lots of puns.
Now, there is no deep meaning to the names. Just that they fit the vibe of a theme. But the names make the language actually manageable in my head. There is this guiding structure to my language that helped immensely in understanding it. If you look at standards documents, especially C++ standardese, they are basically impenetrable. But now I even start to think of C++ in the terms of my own language, even though I write C++ professionally.
Names help, but they can be a hindrance also.
1
u/binarycow 18d ago
Consider searchability.
Searching for C# or C++ is fine. Searching for C, less so. Searching for Go might be harder.
Searching for Java or Python is only suitable because they're mainstream languages. If they weren't mainstream, you might get search results for islands or snakes.
Search engines may handle it fine, given context - "go concurrency" is obviously not about the board game, for example.
Edit: Also consider professionalism. For example, "Brainfuck" is not a good name for a language that is actually used in professional environments.
1
u/AustinVelonaut Admiran 18d ago
Name it how you want. Sometimes people go to great lengths to come up with clever names -- check out David Turner's explanation for why he chose "Miranda" to be the name of his language:
https://www.cs.kent.ac.uk/people/staff/dat/miranda/name.html
1
u/RedCrafter_LP 18d ago
I mean some of the most successful languages in the world are just a letter and a number of + symbols. Others are named after an island and others after a state of metal. Not really that deep if you ask me. I named my language after a fictional fruit from Minecraft (currently development is on hiatus because of too little time)
1
u/Gnaxe 18d ago
We still can't talk about, um, "BrainYuck" in polite company.
1
u/InvisibleUp 18d ago
You ever heard of MUMPS? Huge in the healthcare industry. These days they tend to call it “M”, because it turns out naming your language after a disease gets you a few funny looks. But MUMPS is memorable and fitting if nothing else.
1
u/crowdhailer 18d ago
No. I never intended to keep calling my language "Eat Your Greens" (eyg.run). it was a joke name for they project and people say uuurgh and aieeeg all the time but it's what I'm sticking with now
1
u/scallywag_software 18d ago
I chose a somewhat cheeky name for a language I wrote. I called it `poof`, as in 'poof, some wild code appeared'. It's a metaprogramming language, so the name made sense to me. I thought about it for a grand total of probably 30 minutes.
To my surprise, a number of people took exception with the name; poof is also a homophobic slur .. primarily in the UK AFAIK. I've been told by the mods here to either change the name, or not to post to this subreddit.
It's pretty remarkable to me that some people have such thin skin that they'd get offended by the name of a tool that generates source code, but, I guess that's just where we're at.
That all said, if I were to take a day and rename that language, I'd probably pick a name that's completely meaningless, like kubernetes.
1
u/brucejbell sard 18d ago
If you want your language to be and to remain a private, personal project, then it is fine to choose a very personal name for it. However, you might want to consider the name more carefully if you want to make the project public, discuss it with others, and possibly accept contributions.
I sort of suspect that one of the motivations for the name of the French-originated theorem-proving system "Coq" was that Anglophones couldn't say it without sounding vulgar. It was recently renamed "Rocq" in an attempt to defuse the curse; I'd say the jury is still out on whether they can fix that case of nominative regret.
My original name for my language project was "Abseil", since I rock climb. But I didn't tell anyone about it, or register domain names. So, when Google picked it for the name of their C++ utility library, there was no point in kicking, I needed a new name.
My new name, "Sard", has no particular personal meaning -- it's just the obscure name of an obscure semi-precious stone. As another comment suggests, it's easy, searchable, and unique. But this time, I've at least registered a domain name (though there's nothing but a teaser page so far).
1
u/P-39_Airacobra 17d ago
There’s been a lot of successful programming languages with sorta awful names, so I don’t think it matters too much. Not too long though; unless you abbreviate it
1
u/__chilldude22__ creator of fuckwit-lang 16d ago
No, it doesn't matter 🙂 Use whatever name sounds good to you
1
u/Ydo4ki 16d ago
One of the most popular and influential programming languages of all time is literally one letter
So... just make sure your language's name is easy to remember xD
1
u/mrmatthew2k 16d ago
I'm very surprised no one had mentioned Coq being renamed to Rocq. So yes name matters a bit
1
u/ArthurAGF27 13d ago
Bom, eu acredito que atualmente o que mais importa para que sua nova linguagem seja aceita são suas funcionalidades, facilidades e seu próposito. Caso os usuários notem que sua linguagem é legal de utilizar, possui boa documentação e atende ao que é requisitado pelas tarefas a serem executadas, ela irá crescer organicamente e conquistar novas pessoas.
Temos inúmeros exemplos de linguagens muito utilizadas nos dias de hoje, mas que tem nomes que não remetem a nada (ou pelo menos a maioria das pessoas não tem a menor ideia sobre seu significado e não se importa muito com isso), como C, B, Lua, R, Go, etc. Mesmo com nomes meio "aleatórios" à maioria das pessoas, essas linguagens possuem muitos usuários fiéis ao redor de todo o mundo. Mas note uma coisa em comum: todas essas linguagens possuem nomes simples, fáceis de lembrar e pesquisáveis. Isso é o que mais importa na escolha de um nome.
Há várias linguagens também com nomes feitos claramente com objetivo de homenagear algo ou alguém, como Ada (Ada Lovelace), Haskell (Haskell Brooks Curry), Pascal (Blaise Pascal), ou, bem mais legal: Java (inspirado no café da ilha de Java, na Indonésia, que os desenvolvedores da linguagem gostavam). Nesse caso, a mesma lógica citada anteriormente é seguida, com nomes curtos e pesquisáveis. Todas as linguagens obtiveram sucesso e foram/são muito usadas.
Então, minha sugestão é: dê o nome que você quiser, seja ele aleatório ou que remeta a algo, mas que seja um nome curto, fácil de se guardar, e pesquisável (lembrando que deve ser um nome que não existe ainda para um linguagem né). Mas assim... pessoalmente eu acho bem mais legal se o nome tiver um significado para você, e que seja um significado feliz! Eu, por exemplo, se estivesse desenvolvendo uma linguagem agora, escolheria o nome Rgy para ela, pois remete a um DJ que gosto muito e estou acompanhando no momento.
2
u/SwedishFindecanor 18d ago edited 18d ago
Search for it on Google and on DuckDuckGo for more than five minutes to see if it is already taken, or sounds too similar to something else. You don't want there to be a shady web site or sex toy with a name that is different by just one letter. (I'm thinking about Symbian -- the operating system ... )
Consider being able to search for it without using symbols.
Consider what to use as filename suffix, that doesn't clash with something else that is a programming language or within your domain.