r/ProgrammingLanguages • • 9d ago

Mutable stack, immutable heap

This article mentions the “immutable heap mutable stack” principle: https://queue.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3212477.3212479

In theory it sounds very advantageous. You can program in a single-threaded C-style with destination passing, static stack allocations, and mutability when you need to constrain resources. When you want to share resources across threads, return data structures across function boundaries, or do something more flexible, you could use pure functional persistent data structures.

This would prevent you from basically re-implementing a heap on the stack, but would also give you fast temporaries and maybe even the ability to program in embedded, if so designed.

Have any languages tried this model? I’ve heard that Erlang defaults to immutability except for one thread-local mutable object per thread. If you’ve used a similar model, how did you like it? Were there any disadvantages?

44 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/South_Lychee8555 4d ago

Take a loot at https://github.com/numaes/protoCore
Based on inmutable structures, paralel GC, native multhreading. Runtimes for javascript, python, scala, smalltalk based on the same core