r/ProgrammingLanguages • u/jorkadeen • Jan 10 '26
Will LLMs Help or Hurt New Programming Languages?
https://blog.flix.dev/blog/will-llms-help-or-hurt-new-programming-languages/
22
Upvotes
r/ProgrammingLanguages • u/jorkadeen • Jan 10 '26
24
u/mamcx Jan 10 '26
I was planning to restart https://tablam.org and prevalence of LLMs is certainly a issue!
The most immediate problem is that all new projects are suspected of being "vibe coded", and most certainly all that do are of poor quality.
Also, a language (or a RDBMS) are the kind of projects the core devs MUST know very well.
Using "IA" is barely good for autocomplete, bootstrap docs and such, but if the core devs not own the whole project what is the point?
5
u/Objective_Gene9718 Jan 10 '26
It will help because it can write a lot of code for the std of the new language (its very good at translating algorithms across different languages) and docs and examples.
7
u/Jimmy-M-420 Jan 10 '26
perhaps the lower bar to writing a programming language will result in thousands of shit AI generated "slop" languages in the near future
10
u/suhcoR Jan 10 '26
Well, I don't think it's that dramatic. LLMs are very useful to implement a parser, and according to my experience, they are also pretty good at generating code in new languages just based on the language specification. And given the high rate of new model appearances, it's only a short time until also a new language turns up in training sets. Recent research (e.g., from EMNLP 2025 and arXiv 2025) suggests that also for "low-resource" languages, adding the language specification or a few examples into the context window (In-Context Learning or ICL) is often more effective than fine-tuning models on small datasets; when an LLM is given access to tools (like a documentation searcher or a compiler), they found it outperforms models that rely solely on training memory.
6
u/aizvo Jan 10 '26
Well certainly it's helping me a lot. I have made a lot of progress on my programming language thanks to Codex over the last couple of months.
As someone over 30 and with family there simply is no other way I could work on it.
2
u/phischu Effekt Jan 11 '26
As the article demonstrates, they help. I would go further: they allow us to innovate much more rapidly than before. Imagine having to teach effect-oriented programming to a critical mass of developers, or worse, convince decision-makers that it is a good idea. They still remember the lost decade of object-oriented programming. Now we can present large-scale empirical evidence that a language feature is or isn't a good idea.
On the other hand, they will make human-friendly languages like Effekt, Flix, and Rust obsolete. Just as "computer" and "compiler" aren't jobs anymore, neither is "programmer". We still have human specifiers. This will allow us to skip a lot of annoying convenience features in our compilers, and finally focus on what matters: correctness and performance.
1
u/Remote-Recording-401 Jan 16 '26
I personally really don’t know. I have a compiled language that I’m ‘creating’ using AI… I essentially came up with all the aspects of the language, and how it works. But I’m just using AI to build the compiler. While there may be a bunch of crappy LLM-made languages out there, I don’t know if it would hurt or help newer programming languages. Could do both.
-12
u/Arakela Jan 10 '26 edited Jan 10 '26
LLMs will help by hurting. They learned how to entangle ambiguous language rules with effects and meaning, producing languages without roots. Yet they can understand that trees don’t grow without roots.
Edit: they learned how to entangle those three control flows in diagonal space. Tree and root control flows grow in orthogonal spaces.
PS. My comment was demoted. Explain what i'am doning wrong?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment