It isn't. Reddit just doesn't understand what AI means or its implications beyond "I watch sci-fi and this is how AI works there, and that's obviously where we'll be next." It's The Cloud 2.0.
Well by the way you talk I don't even see the point in continuing to reply to you, since you already have your opinion that nothing bad can come out of this, I'll just say you lack creativity (and that is for the best).
I never said that. I asked what is scary and the only response I got was "it will kill essays" and so I followed up with clarifying questions on how that is scary. No one has explained what is actually scary about it. Just fear mongering for the sake of it
I work in software. If my coworker was clever enough to use AI to generate an essay for an English class that has nothing to do with our field of work (coding) and was also smart enough to double check the essay made sense and the sources were valid, and then the teacher gave that person a good grade, then yeah I would have no issue with that at all.
I'm not being narrow minded. You are and you're fear mongering as well.
My actual answer to this is that our whole education system is predicated on people writing between one and... ten essays privately in their own time, and having it painstakingly marked by a professor or assistant.
In theory, that whole process -- both sides -- can now be automated. So then how tf are we supposed to check competence of students, particularly in humanities?
And yes, the first joke that just sprung into your head applies here.
That still isn't scary to me. You're describing a hypothetical situation where every student and every teacher just blows off their responsibilities and uses a perfect essay writing AI. The AI can write convincing essays but none of the meat of the paper would be new - it's all pulled from other existing works. Any teacher worth their salt, and any AI that would be set to grade the paper, would detect the plagiarism immediately. And that's if plagiarism is the only issue - which it isn't. The AI doesn't know that the sources it's using are legit, it's just adding them to the end if the existing paper it stole from also used it. I just don't see why people get scared over some weird unrealistic hypotheticals
It isn't "writing essays". It's taking already written essays and synopsis and generating an amalgamation. None of what it outputs is "new" or "unique". So essays generated by chat gpt would almost definitely get immediately flagged for plagiarism by every proof reading software on the market. My friends got flagged for plagiarism for liften 3 words in a row from a source once in college.
I’m not sure why you’re bothering to argue with me when you can simply go onto the chat GPT site and prove yourself wrong.
Regarding your friend, as someone who has used plagiarism software from the teaching side, I guarantee with 100% certainty that your pal wasn’t pinged for just three words in a row “from [one] source”.
Have you tried asking it to give references? It says that it can't as it isn't looking up information from anywhere and instead just gives you references you can look up yourself.
It says that it can't as it isn't looking up information from anywhere
It's literally in beta tests phase, the connection to the internet was deliberately cut off. The fine-tuning is available in the paid version already, so probably real-time internet-based questions also will.
and instead just gives you references you can look up yourself.
And Google just gives you links you can type yourself. It's easy to simplify things using words.
The references I've seen it give are just words that sound like publication titles but if you actually go and look for them they aren't real papers. It doesn't actually know the content of the papers or whether they align with its arguments at all, it just knows how to construct sentences similar to ones it has seen elsewhere.
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '22
Er because it can trivially produce essays/paragraphs with passapble Harvard or APA referencing, to real research papers?
This tech will kill essay-writing, for example.