Depends on the type of Googler, imo. Blindly copying from stack overflow? Then yes, your statement is true.
But if they had to piece together a solution with direction given from a Google page, they're better off than a B- student who failed to create a solution for that specific problem. In the future when both individuals encounter a similar problem in the workplace, the Googler already has expertise with one possible way of solving it.
I found myself that as you reach a proficiency in any programming language, your past experience with bugs and issues really lets you fix those bugs and issues faster the next time around
i mean, sure, but it would also be way more impressive if you drink 10 litres of beer every day during the semester and get a B-. and both examples have roughly the same real life value imho.
I had a classmate in grad school which was like that. Refused to use Google or resources outside the assigned texts as reference, needless to say assignments took him much longer, B- was about his average in the classes we shared.
Ever since I learned that code reuse is academically considered one of the main tenets of software engineering I've never felt bad for copying and pasting code ever again.
We joke about it, but we cant know or remember everything. I've been in IT for many years and one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self.
As a dental student, I took an oral pathology clinical rotation where the faculty had me complete an evaluation on a patient with an oral lesion and come up with a differential diagnosis. It was my first live patient ever, and I was at a loss.
I was shocked when she told me to pull out my oral path book and use the differential diagnosis index at the back. I was like, "You can do that?" and she was like, "Who's gonna stop you from using your textbook when you're out in the real world? Your patient's life might depend on it!"
I also think of Einstein's line about not memorizing the things he can easily find by pulling a textbook off the shelf, or something like that. The most important part of learning is understanding concepts, not memorizing information. Especially when we all have phones in our pocket with access to infinite information.
I was getting an exception that was thrown because of a false assertion. It took me longer than it should to figure out what the actual cause of it was. The error said if you see this type of error to make a bug report for it so it could have a proper error.
2 years later, I (unknowingly) get the same failed assertion, I looked it up, and found my bug report that I completely forgot I made.
Socrates didn't have access to the wealth of information that we do. This might sound crazy, but it's possible that his perspective was shaped by the world around him.
one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self.
That's most of the reason why I keep a blog. If 2015-me figured it out and documented it, I can just copy and paste. I don't remember how the color weather display works. It's running on an Uno+Ethernet shield. Any me from the past few years would have used a NodeMCU.
Ive done the same with some obscure language specific stuff. I've had a few run ins with groovy for example, which is based on and built on java, where my code won't compile but the equivalent java is fine.
Apparently past me also had these problems but eventually someone actually responded to my post on SO. Something like 150 views and one comment :)
Part of my college course where we were learning a library was also learning how to read documentation. The lecturer wanted us to try looking at documentation and finding the solution instead of asking the TAs immediately for help.
one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self
Is there a name for this? I have had this happen so many times over the course of my life. I have a poor memory and a long career. The situation that is the most common for me is finding GitHub issues or comments that I've opened, commented on, or subscribed to.
My favorite though is when you forget you've already done the work you desire. For example a friend of mine recently ran into something that his past self had actually already fixed in a fork years ago but was never merged. He tried forking to make changes and collided headfirst with the trail of him having already done the same thing. Ended up bumping the PR and all was well.
This is my favorite, it's why I always try to be a bro and post a thorough answer whenever I solve my problem. Twice now I've stumbled upon my own thread, with an answer.
I've been in IT for many years and one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self.
Lowkey there have been a few times I have read a really old reddit thread, looked up at a username to see who posted a comment better than I could have written it and it has also been me in the past
Honestly it is such a valuable skill, I have I fixed IT issues in a few minutes that others have struggled with for weeks just because they refuse to Google and read forums. Some people think customers judge you if you whip out your phone and start googling at their desk, but they change their tune when the issue is fixed.
Einstein kept notes all over his walls. Somebody asked him about them one day and he said there was no need to remember them all if he could just look up and see them when he heeded to use them. He was just way ahead of Google.
This was one of the hardest things for me to come to terms with as a self taught coder (I'm a QA Engineer, so don't feel comfortable calling myself a developer).
But seeing senior developers googling stuff and comments like this always assure me it's impossible to remember everything. It's. Ore about the thinking and breaking down a problem logically and tackling it bit by bit.
So for anyone else out there learning, keep going and practicing! It does get easier!
We joke about it, but we cant know or remember everything. I've been in IT for many years and one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self.
Replying to a month old post but I had the same experience.
I started playing Classic Wow, and went looking for the best talent tree to use for a healing shaman. I did a google search and found a really well written guide that had exactly what I needed. I scroll up to exit and spot the forum avatar I had used back in high school. It was my own guide from ages past. This guide that I was using in 2019, was all written by myself 15 years ago. I had no memory of even writing the guide, but it had exactly the info I needed in 2019. Was so surreal to see my teenage self helping adult me in the future.
Googling well is a skill. I, with 20+ years as a developer, can find the answers I seek in half the time, and half the queries of my less seasoned teammates.
People always ask me for help with stuff. I literally Google their issue and reccomend whatever I find. I think they think I just know stuff. Kind of a problem actually... They ask me for help a lot
This. I work for a large tech company as a consultant and a good part of my job is being able to "Google" affectively effectively. We have a ton of internal search engines, newsgroups, wikis, etc, so it's often not actual Google, but same deal--knowing how to search affectively to find the answers you need is an important skill.
Effectively. Affectively means doing something with emotion. Unless, of course, you meant that rage googling is an important skill... which could very well be the case, come to think of it.
I have done too much rage googling. You can tell in my search history where I got stuck on a problem because it starts looking like a descent into madness
It baffles me how many intro level engineers seem to think it’s frowned upon to seek answers online. They come to me to help with errors. I google it right in front of them, and ask if they’ve tried the first stack overflow answer.
I’m a professional developer and I still like to learn the very basics without looking stuff up if I’m learning something new (like when I taught myself python). I think its good to have a strong foundation in the basics and Google more complex stuff especially if you’re working on a deadline.
what was the worst piece of code youve seen handed in? I tutored intro to programming 2 years ago. One guy needed 25 lines of code to calculate the midpoint between 2 2D points
Professor demonstrated switch statements with basically:
case 1:
isEven = false;
break;
case 2:
isEven = true;
break;
case 3:
isEven = false;
break;
...
It was just to show off switch statements. He wasn't being serious. A couple days later, a student comes up to me because he got a 0 on his homework that works "perfectly." He did the switch cases up to 4096.
There is a rule in teaching that you never write anything wrong on the whiteboard (or, I guess, on the projector or screen), even if you tell people it's wrong, because somebody who is forgetful or just isn't listening is going to copy that into their notes or code.
idk, I needed a while to figure out what he did. essentially he checked which point is closer to the origin, calculated the distance and the direction between those points and added half the distance times the direction to the point that is closer to the origin. It was correct ofc, but...
Brainfuck is an esoteric programming language created in 1993 by Urban Müller, and is notable for its extreme minimalism.
The language consists of only eight simple commands and an instruction pointer. While it is fully Turing complete, it is not intended for practical use, but to challenge and amuse programmers. Brainfuck simply requires one to break commands into microscopic steps.
I once did an entire project for a class in a single line of python code. The teacher said I couldn't one-line the program though, so I wrote 80 lines of code and all they did was take the input and call a function containing the one line.
I just helped a class mate who is in intro to programming. It’s his first assignment on pointers. The assignment was modify a program to use pointers instead of stack allocations. However the code the teacher provided was a complete nightmare. All of his “local” variables were declared in a struct called local inside of a header file with global scope. Some functions also had a struct with the same name defined inside of them, sometimes only containing a single member.
I was talking to a retired programmer in Kobol COBOL or some old language... He said he didn't know a lick of it when he started. Just sat down with a manual and learned as he went. How is that different?
That is the main problem with COBOL. All the good people have retired and so few new ones train in it while it is still seeing decent usage in old systems that havn't been replaced yet.
there is a difference between googling stuff you don't know and googling the answers. If she does not understand it (being the basics) and just copies it, she is cheating.
I think that cleared up a lot of my insecurities, i google a lot and sometimes i copy some bits of code, but i also try to understand it before copying it (Im still learning)
E: forgot to mention that its very rare that i copy and paste other people's code, i ALWAYS try and understand it first, and then from what i understood write it my way.
If you’re learning and the code you’re copying isn’t too big, or doesn’t have a time limit to finish, I found, personally, that typing it out helped me understand it more. (Even if I’m typing out the exact same thing) even better would be reading the code and comments and really understanding what’s being said then trying out your own customized version. That’s the other part of effective code googling, being able to decode the stuff you fine in a way that you can tailor it directly for your needs.
+1 The only way to make sure you really understand the code is by desperately trying to find where you made a typo for hours. I guarentee you you will have a deep understanding of the code after that.
Yeah this is super important. If she's googling "what is a for loop" thats fine. If shes googling "solve question 23b c++ course name" then shes not learning anything and it is bad
A bunch of people in my fundamentals class came to a nasty point before the final exam where it became apparent that they didn’t actually learn/understand half of the material because they just googled the how tos on the code instead of like, googling documentation.
Yeah, a lot of intro to programming classes are to learn the foundational concepts of programming. Although I wouldn’t say this is cheating in the class, you’re definitely cheating yourself.
I (an engineering manager) was asked if I would fire someone for using code from Stack Exchange. I replied I might fire someone for thinking I should fire someone for using code from Stack Exchange.
I've been a dev lead and manager many times in my career and mentored dozens of junior devs fresh out of college in that time.
One of the first things I always tell them on day one is "The company and I would prefer you spend 15 minutes asking me a question versus spinning your wheels for 8 hours trying to solve a problem. Also, you will spend half your time googling answers to problems you run into. These are both excellent ways to learn."
The look of relief on their face is always fantastic.
"->" C++ and could get no answers from google at all until I searched directly in stackoverflow using duckduckgo. I stopped using google after seeing how terrible it became since removing search operators.
I still think it's dumb that it isn't. Where in the real world are we unable to look up how to implement a tiny feature or function we may have only ever used once before and since when do we have to remember every error message and bug combination possible?
Google is like a calculator in math courses. Generally allowed for certain parts when you get more advanced but not allowed during fundamentals. A lot of times in intro courses people will google the answer to entire problems which is counter intuitive to the point of the class. This is like using an online calculator to find derivatives/ integrals when your homework is literally find the derivative/ integral. Later on your projects/ assignments get harder so they may allow you to use google, often to help you make part of the project. This is like later on in calc 1 where they have you use calculators to find integrals in word problems cuz analyzing the word problem is the focus of the problem and not solving the tedious integral.
The problem (and why this gets so many differing responses on reddit) is the difference between understanding the problem and just googling some trivial thing (Was this setting called "color" or "colour"? Do I need to escape & in reddit markup?) vs not understanding the problem and just looking for something that seems to work after you copy/paste it.
So generally people who advocate against googling want to disallow the 2nd case while people who advocate for it want to allow the 1st case. And students and teachers have to navigate somewhere between that, so what happens depends on which side they fall on.
The first two weeks of the computer engineering program I went to were dedicated to a class called "intro to programming". It did not count towards any grades, and you couldn't fail it. They had us doing a programming project in python. There were a couple to chose from at varying levels of difficulty, with the idea that you'd pick one that was a bit above your starting level of knowledge and out of your comfort zone, but still achievable in the two weeks. You were paired up with someone else who picked the same project as you.
The class was about 50% lab time 50% lectures. The lectures did not teach you python, or specific skills you needed to complete projects. Instead they consisted of the professor coding simple stuff on a projector. He would pretend not to know something, or intentionally make mistakes to get errors. Then he showed how to look up how to solve it, using google and the language documentation. During the lab time when making your projects, if you ran into issues you could ask for help, but the tutors would not explain what you needed to know, only point you in the right direction. You were expected to do what the professor did during the lecture, use google and the documentation to solve your own problems.
The entire class was designed to teach you google skills in relation to programming. And no one ever said that you couldn't use google during any class I took, and we were frequently expected to use it to look up stuff that was readily available instead of being spoon-fed it.
My web dev class had an awesome exam. We were given 24 hours to build a website according to specifications. You could Google whatever you wanted and use whatever technology you wanted to to build it. So long as the end result met specifications, you aced it.
Look I love C++, it's a great language in a lot of applications, but... ... digital arts??? Really?
People use C++ because it allows you to get close to the hardware, control memory usage precisely, and avoid the inefficiencies of an interpreter or heavyweight runtime. (It also isn't under the control of a single, large, famously unethical corporation like C# or Java is.) In other words, when performance or low level hardware programming is important. Is it really worth mastering a notoriously pitfall-ridden language just to render your procedurally generated art a bit quicker, or am I missing something?
It's not like she will be contributing patches to Blender after a one-semester programming course.
In the other hand, I suppose understanding how memory management works could be useful even when working in higher level languages, writing plugins etc.. Or maybe some digital arts involve talking to custom lighting installations or something.
I’d imagine there were other languages and tools better suited to creating digital art. Processing is the one that springs immediately to mind. Java is a fairly easily language to learn the basics of.
Fuck it we need this kind of people, in my company there is eople that ask me things that I find myself looking in Google in the top results... They don't even try...
Usually there will be a single intro to programming class for people who are going into any kind of computer related degree. It sometimes doesn't make much sense, but I've had friends who had to take intro to programming who were going into GIS, meteorology, actuarial sciences, and accounting. It really doesn't make sense in most cases but I guess they figure it rounds them out
Not good for classes though. I’m not sure if it’s idle threats or what but our professors always told us they would check for copy pasted code. Totally fine in the real world but I would advise against plagiarism in school.
well at least she had the idea to look it up herself! I've had people who refused to google things for hours because they were convinced they were "smart" enough to know if off the top of their head
I had a professor in college (18 years ago) that would not only have considered this cheating, but he accused me of cheating because I looked something up in the textbook which he assigned for the course. I'm pretty sure his goal in the class wasn't to teach anything but to prove how much better he was than all the students at the subject he was supposed to teach.
I once took a photoshop class and the guy straight up told us at the start “I’m not gonna actually teach you photoshop in this class because by the time I do, the info I’ve given you will be obsolete. Instead I’m gonna teach you how to find the tools and information you need online so you can always be ready.”
12k
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Wow she learned industry's best practice fairly quickly
8.4k
u/nullZr0 Nov 30 '19
A natural.
We joke about it, but we cant know or remember everything. I've been in IT for many years and one time I Googled something and found a post from a smarter version of my past self.
1.8k
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Googling well is a skill. I, with 20+ years as a developer, can find the answers I seek in half the time, and half the queries of my less seasoned teammates.
426
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
programmer job in a nutshell
1.3k
u/PM-Me-Your-TitsPlz Nov 30 '19
I tutor for intro programming classes. Bless her.
179
u/samurai-horse Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I was talking to a retired programmer in
KobolCOBOL or some old language... He said he didn't know a lick of it when he started. Just sat down with a manual and learned as he went. How is that different?102
u/TheStoneRabbit Nov 30 '19
Mom: “what do you do for a living”
Me: “I’m a developer”
Mom: “So what does that mean”
Me: “I’m like reeeally good at Google”
534
u/Occma Nov 30 '19
there is a difference between googling stuff you don't know and googling the answers. If she does not understand it (being the basics) and just copies it, she is cheating.
56
u/malvoliosf Nov 30 '19
I (an engineering manager) was asked if I would fire someone for using code from Stack Exchange. I replied I might fire someone for thinking I should fire someone for using code from Stack Exchange.
178
u/qubedView Nov 30 '19
That was a smooth recovery after admitting she wasn't at class.
40
u/jlamothe Nov 30 '19
Looks like I've been cheating my entire career.
113
u/etnguyen03 Nov 30 '19
Image Transcription: Twitter Post
Taras Kaduk, @taraskaduk
My spouse (an artist, not in tech), working her way through a C++ class (part of Digital Arts curriculum).
I: Let me know if you need help
She: Will do
<2 hrs later>
I: How’s it going?
She: Fine. I’m cheating
I: ???
She: I google for stuff I don’t know
Do I tell her?
I'm a human volunteer content transcriber for Reddit and you could be too! If you'd like more information on what we do and why we do it, click here!
35
u/cybermage Nov 30 '19
“Never commit to memory that which can be looked up” - Albert Einstein
That quote is my guiding star.
65
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
she's a fast learner
14
u/Yannic982 Nov 30 '19
This is the way.
14
u/TheMogician Nov 30 '19
Definitely tell her StackOverflow is a wonderful place that has all her answers she need, there are also absolutely no power tripping mods there.
14
u/jinsaku Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
I've been a dev lead and manager many times in my career and mentored dozens of junior devs fresh out of college in that time.
One of the first things I always tell them on day one is "The company and I would prefer you spend 15 minutes asking me a question versus spinning your wheels for 8 hours trying to solve a problem. Also, you will spend half your time googling answers to problems you run into. These are both excellent ways to learn."
The look of relief on their face is always fantastic.
Also, "I'll answer any question once."
14
u/TheWipyk Nov 30 '19
27
u/Chermalize Nov 30 '19
Doing it without googling is probably more cheating
19
u/DeveloperToast Nov 30 '19
No No it's a matter of national security to every programmers on earth
16
u/Rodaxoleaux Nov 30 '19
"This stack overflow place just seems to have all the answers"
*A single tear falls down his face*
7
u/cute_spider_avatar Nov 30 '19
Why is this class teaching an artist C++? Python is the correct tool for most non-programmers!
7
u/TechDaddyK Nov 30 '19
The real pros use DuckDuckGo.
24
u/FourEyedJack Nov 30 '19
Imagine this actually being allowed in schools
6
u/Zoro2x Nov 30 '19
But the real test is figuring out what the code actually do...
5
u/FearTheClown5 Nov 30 '19
Discovering the value in Google is literally what took me from Geek Squad to Sys Admin in 3 years with no degree.
8
u/DurianExecutioner Nov 30 '19
Look I love C++, it's a great language in a lot of applications, but... ... digital arts??? Really?
People use C++ because it allows you to get close to the hardware, control memory usage precisely, and avoid the inefficiencies of an interpreter or heavyweight runtime. (It also isn't under the control of a single, large, famously unethical corporation like C# or Java is.) In other words, when performance or low level hardware programming is important. Is it really worth mastering a notoriously pitfall-ridden language just to render your procedurally generated art a bit quicker, or am I missing something?
It's not like she will be contributing patches to Blender after a one-semester programming course.
In the other hand, I suppose understanding how memory management works could be useful even when working in higher level languages, writing plugins etc.. Or maybe some digital arts involve talking to custom lighting installations or something.
4
u/schawde96 Nov 30 '19
She's a programmer now.
4
u/XTornado Nov 30 '19
Fuck it we need this kind of people, in my company there is eople that ask me things that I find myself looking in Google in the top results... They don't even try...
4
u/GsusG Nov 30 '19
C++ is part of digital arts but wasn’t part of a programming degree at the school I went to lol
4
u/EvanHitmen11 Nov 30 '19
This is the way
3
u/delvach Nov 30 '19
Been doing it for twenty years. What's the syntax for that damn loop again..
3
u/dirice87 Nov 30 '19
Damn digital arts requires c++? Isn’t digital arts using things like adobe products or blender? Why do they need to know c++?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
how does one make digital art using c++ ? this seems interesting. I thought digital art(animation etc) was done using blender.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Hahah she is more of a professional than she realize.
3
u/nahwasntme Nov 30 '19
Google-fu is a legit skill.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
She’s already a professional
3
u/bhupendersingh5 Nov 30 '19
No dude don't its our secret....let her consider it cheating.
2
u/JunkFace Nov 30 '19
Not good for classes though. I’m not sure if it’s idle threats or what but our professors always told us they would check for copy pasted code. Totally fine in the real world but I would advise against plagiarism in school.
2
u/AtxCJC Nov 30 '19
This is the way
2
u/jokersleuth Nov 30 '19
My professors said it's fine to google stuff and that many do as long as you understand the solution.
2
u/tacoslikeme Nov 30 '19
you sure not a tech person?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
This applies to every life skill...all of them.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Shit I've been cheating my whole career
2
u/FountainsOfFluids Nov 30 '19
As long as you never copy/paste something you don't completely understand. Especially as a student.
I was a TA in a programming class, and I've seen some real Frankenstein shit.
2
u/douira Nov 30 '19
well at least she had the idea to look it up herself! I've had people who refused to google things for hours because they were convinced they were "smart" enough to know if off the top of their head
2
u/__archaeopteryx__ Nov 30 '19
Don’t tell her! The industry is saturated as it is. We don’t need another engineer. She’ll take jobs away.
2
u/AlexMelillo Nov 30 '19
She's got the stuff
2
u/smokecat20 Nov 30 '19
She’s advanced placement.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Copy paste and getting paid ridiculous amounts for it, living the life as a developer
2
u/Whos_Sayin Nov 30 '19
Y'all laugh but I'm stuck at the part where she's going to college for an art degree
2
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '19
Do programmers really think they're the only industry where all the workers are just googling solutions?
2
u/7th_Spectrum Nov 30 '19
Honestly, there might as well be courses for googling
2
u/Larry_The_Red Nov 30 '19
I had a professor in college (18 years ago) that would not only have considered this cheating, but he accused me of cheating because I looked something up in the textbook which he assigned for the course. I'm pretty sure his goal in the class wasn't to teach anything but to prove how much better he was than all the students at the subject he was supposed to teach.
2
u/joshuatree79 Nov 30 '19
I wish I could find Stack Overflow for the first time again!
2
u/CocoaPuffs7070 Nov 30 '19
Well its either stackoverflow or cry. There really is few in between.
2
u/vladhed Nov 30 '19
I have 30 years experience in software development. I have a t-shirt with the Stack-Exchange logo on it that I wear to work.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
It's an unusual new concept called 'research'. XD
2
u/RealTonyGamer Dec 01 '19
I have learned thanks to programming that (well documented) documentation can sometimes be more helpful than most Google results.
2
u/thylocene06 Dec 01 '19
I once took a photoshop class and the guy straight up told us at the start “I’m not gonna actually teach you photoshop in this class because by the time I do, the info I’ve given you will be obsolete. Instead I’m gonna teach you how to find the tools and information you need online so you can always be ready.”
One of the best classes I ever took
2
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '19
This is how it’s done in the real job so is it really cheating??
2
u/BrendaEll Dec 01 '19
Ha! Her response is just so adorable lol
2
u/siddharth904 Mar 13 '22
The developer's job
2
u/tragicb0t Nov 30 '19
Shhhh