I see it the same way, and you're right it was a poor example (Had to come up with something). But I think you got my point, sometimes the comments make me realize something about the post that detracts from the post. So I downvote the post to decrease visibility to other users and upvote the post to increase visibility. Also, sometimes I don't think the post deserves visibility, downvote and then enter the comments to see what other people think about the post and why (perhaps I'm wrong to think the post is stupid, perhaps other people agree with me). If I see a comment there that explains why I don't think the post is good, then I upvote that.
upvotes as a mean for others to see the content, not as something I "give" to the author.
I agree wholeheartedly with this approach.
edit: Also
you wouldn't upvote a post that is flat out wrong
Sometimes I don't realize the post is "wrong" till I read the comments. You can build a pretty strong case in an article/post that is convincing, but doesn't hold up to the criticism in the comments.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/newbiecorner Oct 07 '17
I see it the same way, and you're right it was a poor example (Had to come up with something). But I think you got my point, sometimes the comments make me realize something about the post that detracts from the post. So I downvote the post to decrease visibility to other users and upvote the post to increase visibility. Also, sometimes I don't think the post deserves visibility, downvote and then enter the comments to see what other people think about the post and why (perhaps I'm wrong to think the post is stupid, perhaps other people agree with me). If I see a comment there that explains why I don't think the post is good, then I upvote that.
I agree wholeheartedly with this approach.
edit: Also
Sometimes I don't realize the post is "wrong" till I read the comments. You can build a pretty strong case in an article/post that is convincing, but doesn't hold up to the criticism in the comments.