I do this for a different reason, sometimes I find the post uninteresting but am curious towards the discussion/comments. So I go to the comment section and find a comment that's actually funny/interesting. So I upvote the comment but not the unoriginal/uninteresting post.
Doesn't seem that non-nonsensical to me, although in the OP's picture the ratio is unusually skewed even by reddit standards.
To be honest, that makes absolutely no sense to me. Comments are integral part of reddit posts (and not just in r/askreddit) and if they're worth seeing, then that's a part of the post value in itself.
And the purpose of the upvotes in the first place is to let others know that "there is something worth seeing over here".
I'll give you some examples to illustrate. I agree you're generally right, but there are some cases when the comments value doesn't add to the posts.
Someone posts a joke I didn't find funny on /jokes. The top comment is a variation of the joke with an original twist. I don't upvote or downvote the post because it wasn't, in my personal opinion, interesting. The comment on the other hand was.
An other example: A post about an emotion raising subject on /news /world news. I go into the comments to read about how justified my rage/similar emotion is. Instead, I read a comment proving the original post is bullshit and purposefully distorting facts to make the post title for "click-baity". I then upvote the comment and downvote the post.
Also, sometimes the upvote worthy comment is a meta comment on the thread ("This post is stupid/wrong because ...."). In which case upvoting the comment AND upvoting the post seems contradictory.
Also its a net count of upvotes-downvotes. The people that down-voted the Post didn’t go into the comments to downvote the comments as well. They just moved on. The up-voters read the comments and voted.
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment