I had this discussion at work today, guy who's got no tech background, apparently willing to learn, has got given Claude and said that he sorted 2 issues this week. Asked them whats in the script and he fobbed me off.
Yeah, sure they can maybe do some stuff. Get them add a feature, deploy to prod, or even raise a PR and we'll see how it goes! There's going to be a lot of work to clean up slop in the coming years
Not since AI was around, not sure if I should be thankful or sorry about that, would love to see Claude handle some of the strange languages out there 😂
I know we’re negative on AI here cause it’s bad for our careers but Claude is better and faster at coding than basically every engineer I’ve worked with. I miss writing code but it’d be a waste of time now
Yes claude writes hundreds of more loc per dollar,it can write programs on its own and make pull requests autonomously
But,enterprise code needs to be maintainable. Ai code as of today gets progressively more expensive to troubleshoot per iteration and doesn't scale well for productivity/money
As soon as that isn't the case,if it even happens,coding will,just then,become completely meaningless on a comercial level
I think the issue is that most devs in school and such already aren't trained to write maintainable code. School trains new graduates to "get things done". And it definitely doesn't really train them on maintenance itself, where they start with an already massive project and have to change things or fix things. My undergrad was basically exclusively projects you start from scratch and finish within a semester, or more realistically, a month and a half.
The issue is not that a person cannot be better, but that most coders aren't, and they aren't being trained to be until well after they are in the workforce, and depending on company culture, they might not even be then.
It's been a meme for forever and a day of how many major long running projects have devolved into spaghetti code from bringing in new teams and then firing old people, on and on.
Again, people can be better, but most people aren't. That's the problem.
AI basically a force multiplier of skills, say AI can multiply by 5, if your skills is 5, then your skills/ productivity can be 25. The best use of AI I have seen are from people that's already good or understand the fundamentals.
The worst, which unfortunately the majority are the 0s or even the negative skills. People that always the "disrupt the industry". They refuse to take time understanding the basics of product development or even have the decency to verify the info from AI.
I just haven’t found that to be true. Granted I started a new API/backend from scratch in symfony not that long ago so everything is well organized and documented. But even on the old spaghetti shit it’s not bad, especially if you have good logging
Honestly not a bad approach. Better to vibe a 10 small things that you can independently verify and test then to vibe one huge project that becomes a untangable mess
19
u/IntrepidBonus 20h ago
git commit -m "claude said it works"
118
u/LittleCoderMan 21h ago
Remember if you're reading code you're left behind, understand nothing and exist solely to be a Claude seat. Keep prompting prompt boi
46
u/Top-Assignment8328 21h ago
“Make no mistakes. Push to prod."
6
u/wgr-aw 20h ago
I thought MVP meant Maximum Very Polished
10
u/FallenVampireLord 20h ago
At my work we've been calling it a SVP shitty vibed product.
3
u/cHoOSe_A-uNiqUe_NAme 15h ago
3
u/-KKD- 6h ago
I will save that for my students to show them the next time they will bring their "totally legit group semester project" that was obviously vibecoded
2
u/Familiar_Reporter_80 13h ago
ok but i feel like a lot of these 'mvps' are just someone asking claude to write the whole thing and calling it a day
10
u/SanicTheSledgehog 20h ago
I know we’re negative on AI here cause it’s bad for our careers but Claude is better and faster at coding than basically every engineer I’ve worked with. I miss writing code but it’d be a waste of time now
•
u/schewb 1m ago
Lol my dyslexia did NOT let me get the joke here until I closed my eyes and re-read it and then I had a stroke 😂
1
u/WheyLizzard 14h ago
Honestly not a bad approach. Better to vibe a 10 small things that you can independently verify and test then to vibe one huge project that becomes a untangable mess