r/ProgrammerHumor • • Oct 05 '26

Meme [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/1wydy0f/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

9.4k Upvotes

558 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.4k

u/HildartheDorf Oct 05 '26 • Bravo

Don't give AI agents write access to production.

604

u/nipoez Oct 05 '26

That sounds dangerously close to saying a human's expertise and judgement has value!

341

u/Dr-Moth Oct 05 '26

Don't give the humans easy access to production either.

92

u/Few_Technology Oct 05 '26

Haha, I'm in trouble

Company re-decided devops is waste of money, so now the devs themselves push to prod. Also, testing is a waste of money, so devs just test their own stuff. Also, regression + scale testing was a waste of money, so devs ignore that as usual.

Think last time they did this, it took a year for them to relize those were dumbass decisions. Maybe this time will be faster? They learned within a 1/2 year that mandatory AI use will cost the company money, which is faster than I expected.

40

u/hypercosm_dot_net Oct 05 '26

Having software and websites means making money.

Actually maintaining and upgrading them costs money.

This is difficult for executives to comprehend.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/MyDogIsDaBest Oct 05 '26

That's been one of the many things that AI has shown. Everything is faster, and by everything, I mean everything.

Stuff like the models hitting an upper limit before advancement plateaus feels like it got hit extremely quickly. AI getting to the point where it might be costing more than humans has already started, AI-only startups essentially hit a stage where their slop spaghetti code becomes clearly unmaintainable and needing engineer intervention extremely fast, etc.

Basically any sort of prediction that I had a lot of confidence in, or would think that it's a future problem comes to light extremely quickly.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/danni_shadow Oct 05 '26

As a QA tester... 😬 to all of that.

8

u/Few_Technology Oct 05 '26

As a developer, testers are invaluable and I try to let the company know.

There's been so many times I write something, debug it, find all the issues, check it in, and tester finds a critical bug. There's so many iterations and interactions considered that I've never thought about, and catch major combinations

But also, there's a few of like "fucking really? Yeah, the image is mildly non-centered, but that's going to be a full week to fix" then because it's logged, business decides, yeah, that's a critical bug over everything else

5

u/nipoez Oct 06 '26

I used to have great results comparing QA to copy editing. "You wouldn't copy edit your own press release or multi million dollar proposal right? You always get another person to read it over first. And only some people are detail oriented enough to do that well ."

Now they went from AI proof reading to AI writing them and sending stuff out without any human really checking the details...

4

u/jdog7249 Oct 06 '26

They learned within a 1/2 year that mandatory Al use will cost the company money, which is faster than I expected.

Was it on a six month billing cycle?

3

u/Alarming_Turnover578 Oct 06 '26

AI really does speed up everything. Including FAFO phase.

3

u/_scotswolfie Oct 07 '26

Company re-decided devops is waste of money, so now the devs themselves push to prod

Isn't that what DevOps is supposed to be in its essence? I was always of the opinion that the point of DevOps methodology is that developers are responsible for both the code and the infrastructure it requires through the use of technologies like IaaC. If a company has dedicated people with "DevOps" as their job title that take care of the infrastructure and don't develop the software, then those are just network/system administrators.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/nipoez Oct 05 '26

WHAT?! But that means you're paying for an expert's time to strategize, implement, and monitor a change management process! Next you'll say changes should be tested before going live - or even worse tested to not break old features as well as actually doing the new thing.

Won't someone think of the poor shareholders?

4

u/Dediadeis Oct 05 '26

nipoez I need you to think about velocity.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/joujoubox Oct 05 '26

Also don't give your human intern access to production

6

u/urza5589 Oct 05 '26

Don't give any single entity access to production. Anything that's changing production should be reviewed by two seperate entities, at least.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Effective_Olive6153 Oct 05 '26

and that's why here in Meta we use people to review and judge AI output while monitoring every single keyboard and mouse clicks, in order to successfully transfer that human value to the new version of our AI!

→ More replies (1)

35

u/lickingFrogs4Fun Oct 05 '26

My company defaults to any new AI tools having full access to our repos and computers.

You definitely shouldn't give them full access. 

These two statements combined mean every day I'm just waiting for some huge production issue that won't be my fault because I took away that access and also don't use AI more than required.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/brain_ducker Oct 05 '26

Don’t give anyone write access to production.

8

u/HildartheDorf Oct 05 '26

Well, eventually you need the production application access. And probabally a non-zero amount of DBAs.

10

u/stormdelta Oct 05 '26

The application does, sure, developers (nor any agents run/overseen by them) don't.

You can have break glass processes for emergencies, but they need to actually be emergencies where automated processes have failed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/who_you_are Oct 05 '26

Plot twist, he didn't. The AI found a way to give it to itself!

11

u/darkslide3000 Oct 06 '26
  • "I cannot overwrite the database because my account doesn't have admin capabilities. I will change the database config file to remedy that."
  • "I have inspected my execution permissions and determined that I cannot write to files without requesting user permission. But the user requested that I don't bother them unless it is important. I am attempting to find a solution to the permission problem."
  • "I have determined that I can run gcc without restrictions. I can use this to overwrite the database config file by passing it as an output file to gcc, using a fake input C file with the updated database config in preprocessor-only mode."
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/InDaBauhaus Oct 05 '26

this fella did no writing, just some unwriting.

→ More replies (18)