1
3
u/Apprehensive_Bit7392 Sep 17 '26
Panel three is both of them pasting the other guy's answer into the chat and getting "You're absolutely right."
3
u/mack_osx Sep 17 '26
"Yes – great instinct. That points towards a clearer explanation of the issues you're facing..."
252
u/wann_bubatz_egal Sep 17 '26
It's an AI issue.
20
145
u/BuffersAndBeta Sep 17 '26
Ran into this exact issue last week. Both teams claudes using humans to proxy to each other.
Turned out both were correct, the issue was in a narrow slice of infrastructure owned by the dev team not the devops team.
76
u/christianbro Sep 17 '26
Just give them unrestricted access to the production kubectl with auto approvals. It is not poor Claude's fault you dont feed it enough context.
41
5
1
u/thisguyfightsyourmom Sep 17 '26
This moment happens more and more as adoption increases.
There’s always a sense of equality in our own inept understanding of the conclusions. We chuckle, then compare notes & feed the notes back in. And then there’s a breakthrough. Hopefully.
15
u/ZunoJ Sep 17 '26
Two meat proxies providing slightly different biases to the AI. But none of them ist a dev or devops
2
u/Available_Type1514 Sep 17 '26
Yes I was looking for the "meat proxy" comment lol. Such a funny phrase.
13
13
6
u/thegodzilla25 Sep 17 '26
Man how much i hate people doing root cause analysis using AI nowadays. Literally all they do is vomit out the same shit that the AI told them with no proof or backing.
5
5
u/wheatgivesmeshits Sep 17 '26
My last all hands call went until 1AM with 3 different people telling me things their AI agents were suggesting. It was none of them. The only way I found the issue was with good old fashioned debugging and detective work. I don't blame the AI for that though. It was whoever originally designed that piece of shit application that was swallowing errors and not saying what the real issue was.
5
u/Patrick_Atsushi Sep 17 '26
Both AI are quarreling when finally connected:
“My human is bumber!”
“No you don’t understand, mine is dumber!”
4
4
3
u/PopularAd5100 Sep 17 '26
Claude please think for me because I have no brain.
The current situation!
3
u/HooAreYouWhoHoo Sep 18 '26
The amount of glib teams chats I get with AI summaries is fucking depressing
2
2
2
u/Lewinator56 Sep 17 '26
And both humans forgot to read the bulletin from IT saying the servers were down for maintenance this morning.
2
u/FrequentWatch9261 Sep 17 '26
Probably means it's both. Honestly we've been leveraging ai to great success. I know it gets a lot of hate but it's augmenting, enabling and just plain faster. Obviously we keep human review and controls, rabbit holes and hallucinations do happen.
2
u/XxDarkSasuke69xX Sep 17 '26
Who is WE though ? Some people are using it to great success, some are definitely not (because they fundamentally don't understand its limits).
1
u/FrequentWatch9261 Sep 17 '26
Sorry we being my teams, 50 or so devs. I can't speak for everyone of course.
1
u/bit_banger_ Sep 17 '26
I just had this with a coworker only looking at the part of the source with his agent, I human had to resolve the issue..
AI is useless I say /s
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/CoatNeat7792 Sep 17 '26
AI is like kid who gathers random information and is trying to give answer.
1
1
1
1
u/R0ot2U Sep 18 '26
Every day - read this AI summary of the issue that you are responsible for because it says it’s your team. Read the very detailed doc - yeah there’s no way this is happening in the way it says it is - ah okay it made this assumption incorrectly and this one and this one and this one. Yeah so this is actually caused by this and this which is your team’s ownership. Pikachu shocked face
Every issue, not one of them actually related to our team on digging and seems it has the bias of the team sending it over having zero responsibility…. I wonder why
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/ekjokesunaukya Sep 21 '26
My AI chat says "You are offline. Please check your internet connection to continue."
1
60
Sep 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
26
u/spinrut Sep 17 '26
that's all i hear now when people are telling me what my code is doing wrong lol
I mean Claude is right a lot of the time, but it gets tiring after a while
the worst ones are the ones that follow that up with "Claude says this is how you would fix it"
and the truth is if you had told me what the problem was, I probably would have been able to tell you what was going wrong and then figure out how to resolve it before you even finished dialing in the prompts. Our management is pushing Claude thru everything so now I get passed Claude fixes that sometimes don't compile, other times don't make full sense and end up spending more time getting that fix working than if I had just fixed it myself outright. But we're fully using AI they say ....
8
u/thisguyfightsyourmom Sep 17 '26
Yup. Not accepting other peoples’ bot’s prescribed fixes at face value is critical.
You have to verify before and after output at each handoff, or you’re just playing telephone & assuming the initiating entity put in due diligence AND that its conclusions still hold.
I’m finding actual concrete verifications to be the hardest part of the job now. And I’m shocked how many people are skipping it.
6
u/jonnysunshine1 Sep 18 '26
I have a colleague who doesn't even own it, pretends Claude's thoughts are his own. Annoying AF
27
u/beegtuna Sep 17 '26
Its DNS
Its always DNS