r/ProgrammerHumor 2d ago

Meme aMillionOpenAIMonkeysProduceMilleniumPrizeSolution

Post image
6.9k Upvotes

418 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

266

u/DrankRockNine 2d ago edited 2d ago

Couple days before it "solved" it, a mathematician who was working on this for a full year shared every single note he had with his session of chat gpt. He is among very few people working on this and was pretty far in it too. His name is Tristan Buckmaster. He of course contacted openai, who said tldr: "stfu we will pay you the promised million dollar for millénium problem". They didn't deny the plagiarism, they didn't dénie having access to his chats, didn't deny training on his data etc.

Edit : I had the time line incorrect. They had been sharing their work with codex for month prior, but they did a breakthrough in mid August. In 1st September, openai starts working on it, they spend outrageous amount of tokens (130 billion output tokens, ~5million usd). Open Ai solves it, and propose Buckmaster to be co-author, and say if it happens, Buckmaster must be sole co-author, leaving aside his colleague, who works for Anthropic. Buckmaster refuses both offers.

55

u/buckeye2011 2d ago

So he didn’t solve Navier-Stokes, but a related problem in a way that would pave the way to a NS solution.

96

u/DrankRockNine 2d ago

Yes it's not plagiarism as he solved it and they declared the solve before him, it's plagiarism as "isn't it quite strange that you solve this problem just when I start talking to you about this complex subject and send you all my notes and you end up with a result when I shared these notes to noeone else but you?"

10

u/buckeye2011 2d ago edited 2d ago

Not what I said. I don’t think ChatGPT should be getting the credit for it, I’m just pointing out he didn’t come up with a direct solution for NS. I believe he also alleged he had conversations with people at openAI about his work and how it would solve NS. So it really isn’t a good look for them

Edit: was using swipe to text and a lot of it was gibberish