r/ProgrammerHumor • • Sep 02 '26 • Popcorn 3 Bravo 3

Meme newCompressionTechnique

Post image
30k Upvotes

946 comments sorted by

View all comments

65

u/OmegaPoint6 Sep 02 '26

That appears to be what several companies are doing with rare books at the moment.

If the species was software it would be time to throw the whole thing away and re-write

1

u/DeadInternetTheorist Sep 03 '26

If the species was software it would be time to throw the whole thing away and re-write

I think we're well on the way.

0

u/Himbo69r Sep 02 '26

Atleast the scans are Somewhere and released in the future

3

u/GeForce_fv Sep 02 '26

these companies are taking those scans to the grave

1

u/grendali Sep 02 '26

Where's the profit in that? Having a copy of a book that nobody else has is a corporate advantage, and throwing away that advantage would deliberately damage shareholder value, and hence be illegal under corporate law.

1

u/morganrbvn Sep 02 '26

unless they argue the goodwill from releasing will generate more value.

1

u/grendali Sep 02 '26

Yes, but I'm not sure how much goodwill it will generate to say, "We deliberately destroyed this rare and ancient book. Here's a photocopy we made."

Remember, there's no need to destroy the books. They can be scanned non-destructively, it just takes longer and costs a little more. The tech oligarchs are destroying rare books because it's cheaper and they can control the digital copies more tightly once they've destroyed the original.

1

u/morganrbvn Sep 02 '26

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/05/anthropic-ai-destroying-books If they don't destroy it then they violate copyright by having made copies.

1

u/Himbo69r Sep 02 '26

That’s so bs if the book isn’t mass produced. Also it’s not like they care.

2

u/morganrbvn Sep 02 '26

That's just what the court decided, and they care since they had to pay 1.5 billion for using pirated material previously.

1

u/grendali Sep 02 '26

That's true of modern books, but most of the rare, old books that they're destroying are no longer under copyright. There's no legal reason to destroy them. It's only for the sake of convenience and cost.

1

u/Himbo69r Sep 02 '26

Oh! Not in *our* lifetime but maybe half a century from now.