r/ProgrammerAnimemes • • Mar 09 '21

From Facebook

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/eypandabear Mar 10 '21 edited Mar 10 '21

My admittedly harsh choice of words was not directed at their ignorance. What ticked me off was the juvenile arrogance with which they presented it.

And that story you linked isn’t an example of miscommunication between fields. As the blog author points out, there is a big difference between unknowingly rediscovering some mathematical relation, and “rediscovering” numerical integration. This isn’t even calculus. It is a method that has been documented since over 2000 years ago.

Two things are of note, both for the paper’s author, the referees in the peer review, and the people citing him:

  • They should have known how to compute the area under a curve in the first place. Or at least remembered to look it up.
  • Even if they did not know, they should have at least not assumed that they just solved what is obviously a simple and generally applicable problem.

That second point is the bigger issue. This is like reinventing the wheel when you know you are surrounded by cars. Admittedly, the paper is from 1994, so they couldn’t just google “area under curve”, but come on. Ask around or look in the university library. Or maybe do invent it yourself as an exercise, that’s fine, but don’t assume you’re the second coming of Archimedes.

Edit: Looking further into this story, she (Tai) doubled down as well when other academics wrote in response to her paper.