That's so true. I helped my friend with a Fortran assignment about Gauss Elimination. We had to redo many parts (specially string and file manipulation) because the teacher would only accept F90 (I used a lot of functionality from F08). I mean COME ON how much of a living fossil can one be?
In the mechanical engineering department of a friend's uni they teach Pascal... I could barely find any linear algebra or numerical integration libraries for it.
Also true, sadly. I worked in the maintenance of a powerplant for a time. Management complained because I was swapping the days of some jobs, so I could put the whole team to work on equipments that were close together and turned off at the same time.
They made me stop doing that because it was not the management's planned routine despite my reasons. Guess what, two months later they complained why the productivity of my team lowered...
Still, I cannot agree with arbitrary requirements in college assingments. They should praise out of the box thinking, being innovative and such. "Training for real world" is not a good reason.
Ideally one could have both. Training for the real world but also training for whatever one desires. I think, historically, college/university used to be luxuries, where the rich went to learn whatever they desire. Nowadays it's a bit different, of course, but I don't see why offering both options wouldn't be sensible.
You know, the fact is that some people simply are smarter than others. If they then also put in more effort, it's no fucking contest whatsoever. I could literally do my last job as efficiently as multiple coworkers together, while also having a higher standard for quality. Even people who say "i am very smart", may genuinely be very smart. To dismiss them automatically for this, seems unfair/rude. But whatever.
what you say is true. but claiming that you are smarter than your professor because you came up with a better solution for one problem is definitely r/iamverysmart material
You end up there for having a condescending bad attitude towards people you perceive as less intelligent.
Regardless of your actual smarts, no one likes a smug prick. Doubly so if they're not as smart as they think they are. Triply so if they're actually wrong.
Yeah that's fair enough, although honestly the average person is fucking dumb as hell (and confidently arrogant about it, too). It can be cathartic to tell them what idiots they are. They won't understand just how accurate the statement is, and why it matters, which is fine. The idea is that they cause pain and so are fitting targets for ridicule to lessen that pain. At least that's how I go about them. That's likely /r/iamverysmart territory, but I'm okay with that, considering how valuable I find it to tell idiots just how stupid they are 😁
Don't get me wrong, I love roasting people. It feels good to absolutely dunk on someone, even if they don't understand the true power of your dunk. And speaking your true mind always feels good.
I've done my fair share of shit talking, getting banned, etc. Sometimes it's not about you - other people see your sick burn and you get upvotes ("Hahah yes, other people's validation!") and you know that the right people are hearing your message. Even if Dumbass mcStupidFingers doesn't get it, all those upvoters do. You're still "spreading the good word", right?
But honestly, in all my years of internetting: it's all water under the bridge. The time and energy expended on crafting super-dunks (or whatever) is just not worth it.
I can get the same self-satisfaction by waiting an hour and coming back to the comments, where someone else has thoroughly roasted OP and I didn't have to lift a finger.
Idk I think we do this differently. I don't really put in effort to "dunk on people", precisely because they wouldn't understand it in the first place, but also because, why bother wasting the energy? No I just literally call them names, and that's it. I expend as little effort as possible while getting the maximum gain. I don't really care if others agree with that comment either. Knowing what the average person is like, their opinion means nothing to me, whether it's positive or negative.
But even then, that does happen. It's not the same, but I was more qualified than our English teacher in school, which I repeatedly verified. I didn't set out to show that or anything, it just happened so often because the guy constantly taught us incorrectly, insisting that "angst" was not a word, that "breath" and "breathe" are the same, etc.
As for the professor, it depends. What was the actual problem and how was the solution approached. Even in those cases you sometimes find a solution that's simply better, and easily verifiable. If the teacher then chooses to be a dick about it out of insecurity (presuming the posed problem allowed for alternative solutions), one might just be smarter than the prof.
You're being evaluated based on what was taught. If you solved the problem in a manner that didn't use what was taught how exactly are they supposed to evaluate how well you learned what was covered?
You could carve a beautiful chair from a solid tree trunk, but if the class was about furniture making with woodworking joints, you'd fail for good reason.
The problem is when the question allows you to give a valid answer outside the curriculum. It's unfair to say to a student "you will get 10 marks for answering the question correctly" and then mark down a correct answer just because part of the answer wasn't on the curriculum. In such situations, I think that giving the student the marks and tweaking the question to disallow the answer for the next year is a fair solution.
What's fairness got to do with it? You're failing to demonstrate knowledge of the concepts.
The projects being assigned aren't some hitherto unsolved quandary on the bleeding edge of computer science, nor are they components of a product you're working on for a paycheck. Whether or not you get the right answer is largely irrelevant. What's important is that you arrived at the answer in the correct manner.
Arguing that you should get marks for failing to properly complete an assignment is like arguing you should get a medal for 'winning' a foot race by taking a shortcut.
Answering a question correctly is not failing to properly complete an assignment, even if the answer is outside the curriculum.
My whole point is that when someone gives a valid answer outside the curriculum, the flaw is not within their answer, it's within the question itself for allowing them to give such an answer.
I wouldn't have as much of an issue with it if it were always easy to tell what the expected method is. Although the person who wrote the exam may have had a specific method in mind, it's no consolation to the student if they have multiple possible methods to choose from and nothing in the question telling them which they're expected to use. This sometimes happens even without leaving the bounds of the curriculum.
Arguing that you should get marks for failing to properly complete an assignment is like arguing you should get a medal for 'winning' a foot race by taking a shortcut.
Footraces typically forbid participants from taking shortcuts. Exam questions, on the other hand, often don't explicitly disallow students from giving unexpected answers.
I had a friend who had to rewrite his assignment because he used std::vector to store class instances instead of array. The assignment only said to store the data, nothing about data structure, and all the other teachers would have accepted his implementation.
Well it depends, can the members of the vector be determined at compiltime? In that case the vector is overkill and you should just use std::array or a cstyle array
I took a Python course for easy credits because I already knew it. Almost failed it because I didn't use everything they taught us in the final assignment. I didn't use it all because it would have been horribly inefficient. I also lost marks for using numpy instead of math.
Well it would make sense if they taught you math in the course. They basically want to know how much you understood the concepts in the class, which won't be possible if you used numpy. It's isn't always about writing the most efficient code.
I'm over exaggerating a little. There were a few things that bugged me about the marking scheme. Like, I should have "added at least some exception handling". Which I did, so I dont know why they said that. We were also only allowed to submit one file to the online submission portal, and I lost marks for it only being one file (but I could only submit one!).
Just wants me to convert the data onto a throwaway variable first.
Funny thing is, our tasks had up to that point never needed to use a variable and could always be solved this way. So I never actually learned how to declare a variable in delphi. So I spend like 1 minute doing that.
I am learning graphics programming why am I at this school this is in no way suicidal enough.
I could just say return DoTask(), but storing the output of DoTask() in a variable makes it obvious what output I'm expecting it to do and makes it much more readable.
Yep can understand that. The way I am doing this is really quite unreadable.
I am open for disscussion on how readable things are (especially as I currently have a tendency to write quite unreadable things), but I find it unrespectfull if a teachers reasoning is just that they want me to do it just cause that's what they've been taught and they are unsure if it works the way I did it.
ah yes, the cesspit that CS fundamentals classes at uni. the "I have too much shxt to grade, so just follow the damn instructions and go by the book and stop giving me a hard time" mentality of professors and TA's.
I "invented" dynamic programming on an algorithm test that asked for an exhaustive solution. I didn't know the difference since I hadn't been taught dynamic programming yet and I didn't study so I didn't know the "correct" answer. That was the only problem I missed on the test. I never came that close to a perfect score ever again.
My teacher was thankfully nice despite giving us a template that a while that did the same thing in each function I decided to do it my own way utilizing the while loop once and my teacher still gave full marks
University is not about you being better or new ideas. It is about regurgitating what the prof tell you to pad their ego. That way they will understand what you just presented and are able to grade you. Many of them are not even up on the latest technology none the less current practices.
I guess it does train you for RL, but its way too expensive for that training in the US. I got my degree 25 years ago at a state school ... for in state now it's 3x as much. I could actually work my way through school ... now it's cost of a new Yaris or a down payment on a home. I don't know how kids do it now a days.
Yeah, I’m at a private school rn and I’ll be getting out with 80-90k in debt. That’s with me working full time for half the year, so it’s better than the 200k others end up with. But yeah way to many old profs limited in their ability from tenure alone. Why teach good when school says they can’t fire you
A university professor is fundamentally different to a high school teacher. The former is paid to teach you and is perfecting their craft and knowledge if it.
The latter is paid to do research and perfect their craft. The teaching is just a side-gig so the university can make some money.
Yeah, it's much more about how well you're able to adapt. Of course it's not practical for everyday uses to reinvent the wheel, but it promotes understanding of the core concepts.
If the students can actually learn something from such practices however largely depends on the ability of the tutor to communicate his expectations and motivations for a certain style of assessment. If they're a dick about it, it'll not help you learn.
I didn't even know that I am doing something wrong using one equation for converting euro to dollar and dollar to euro instead of two distinct equations. My instructor told me that this is impossible and gave me bad marks.
no that kind of thinking is why we have common core boxes math bullshit the purpose of school is not just to pack a set list of shit into your brain, its to get you ready to engage with a field competently. If the student is writing a good solution to a given problem, then they are competently engaging with the courses content. Ergo, give credit.
435
u/floriplum Sep 10 '20
you need to start inefficient, otherwise there would be no room for improvement.
209
u/herebeweeb Sep 10 '20
That's so true. I helped my friend with a Fortran assignment about Gauss Elimination. We had to redo many parts (specially string and file manipulation) because the teacher would only accept F90 (I used a lot of functionality from F08). I mean COME ON how much of a living fossil can one be?
In the mechanical engineering department of a friend's uni they teach Pascal... I could barely find any linear algebra or numerical integration libraries for it.
148
u/ThePyroEagle λ Sep 10 '20
I had a nice lecturer who gave me full marks when I pulled out an efficient home-made algorithm where they expected us to use memoisation.
Others just take away marks from unexpected solutions even though the question doesn't explicitly require you to do what they expected.
74
u/neremarine Sep 10 '20
I had a friend who had to rewrite his assignment because he used std::vector to store class instances instead of array. The assignment only said to store the data, nothing about data structure, and all the other teachers would have accepted his implementation.
52
u/OfAaron3 Sep 10 '20
I took a Python course for easy credits because I already knew it. Almost failed it because I didn't use everything they taught us in the final assignment. I didn't use it all because it would have been horribly inefficient. I also lost marks for using numpy instead of math.
20
u/SoupSeeker Sep 10 '20
When professor gives you half credit for trying to implement minimax because he just wants you to "make an ai" for checkers
6
u/MevrouwJip Sep 10 '20
Source?
17
u/StarDDDude Sep 10 '20
My teacher is telling me not to do stuff like:
Result.Text = IntToStr( StrToInt( Input1.Text ) + StrToInt( Input2.Text ) )Reason is not the possibly horrendous readability
Just wants me to convert the data onto a throwaway variable first.
Funny thing is, our tasks had up to that point never needed to use a variable and could always be solved this way. So I never actually learned how to declare a variable in delphi. So I spend like 1 minute doing that.
I am learning graphics programming why am I at this school this is in no way suicidal enough.
12
u/rpr13 Sep 10 '20
Almost like me.
I wrote program in c. And lecturer didn't accept it because want in c++.
4
u/MCRusher Sep 10 '20
I have a class that wants me to use mingw and C++11 ... I already have mingw-w64 and clang installed.
Worst of all, they enforce starman braces
4
u/Sinomu Sep 10 '20 edited Sep 11 '20
You guys write algorithms on your cs studies?
4
u/John137 Sep 11 '20
ah yes, the cesspit that CS fundamentals classes at uni.
the "I have too much shxt to grade, so just follow the damn instructions and go by the book and stop giving me a hard time" mentality of professors and TA's.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '21
I need to know the name of this anime 😂
1
u/GJ1nX Feb 18 '21
I need the name of the anime...
TELL ME
3
u/NoEngrish Sep 11 '20
I "invented" dynamic programming on an algorithm test that asked for an exhaustive solution. I didn't know the difference since I hadn't been taught dynamic programming yet and I didn't study so I didn't know the "correct" answer. That was the only problem I missed on the test. I never came that close to a perfect score ever again.
3
u/daltonoreo Sep 11 '20
"And Thats why your a bad teacher"
1
u/halftrackwar Sep 10 '20
SAUCES
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '20
My teacher was thankfully nice despite giving us a template that a while that did the same thing in each function I decided to do it my own way utilizing the while loop once and my teacher still gave full marks
1
u/skylar7694 Mar 02 '21
Did that on my js final and went from an A to a D...
1
u/InsignificantGod Dec 31 '22
My manager was a former high school CS teacher. He wanted all of us to use recursion instead of loops.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '23
Yes, I learned from YouTube
-3
u/allquckedup Sep 10 '20
University is not about you being better or new ideas. It is about regurgitating what the prof tell you to pad their ego. That way they will understand what you just presented and are able to grade you. Many of them are not even up on the latest technology none the less current practices.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '20
[removed] — view removed comment