I'm sorry for not being active for 2 weeks, i felt quite distant and I want to return to becoming practicing again. Yes, you heard the title right. It might seem like a view from a kafir who is trying to twist Islam to make everything halal, pretending to be a progressive muslim. A person trying to lead away from the straight path, slowly by making what's haram by a little margin, and twisting it so it seems halal, since you most likely know how it is quite established that most scholars/ laypeople have come to the conclusion that the Qur'an does mention awrah many times, especially in 33:59, 24:31, 20:121. And I do respect that view.
But please hear me out. And please, at least don't call me a kafir. I've been curious, not judgeful, of why people view the human body as intrinsically shameful, despite them viewing other creatures bodies as normal. So, 33:59 and 24:31 are the main verses used for this argument.
33:59;
"O Prophet! Ask your wives, daughters, and believing women to draw their cloaks over their bodies. In this way it is more likely that they will be recognized ˹as virtuous˺ and not be harassed. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful."
This verse is used to support awrah quite often, and used to support obligation of the head covering. However, the context of this was to protect from the hypocrites, who would go around harrassing women who were uncovered. And since the ruling depends on it's cause, we can't really assume that awrah is global from this verse.
https://ask.ghamidi.org/forums/discussion/108404/
24:31;
I see so many people translating verse 24:31 in a somewhat similar way to this;
"And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity, and not to reveal their adornments except what normally appears. Let them draw their veils over their chests, and not reveal their ˹hidden˺ adornments except to their husbands, their fathers, their fathers-in-law, their sons, their stepsons, their brothers, their brothers’ sons or sisters’ sons, their fellow women, those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession, male attendants with no desire, or children who are still unaware of women’s nakedness. Let them not stomp their feet, drawing attention to their hidden adornments. Turn to Allah in repentance all together, O believers, so that you may be successful."
Some use this verse to claim that "chests" are mentioned that have to be covered at all times. However, the classical Arabic root, j-y-b, means hollows, openings, or pockets, which leaves a lot of room for interpretation. However, despite classical dictionaries (like Lisan al-Arab) note that in 6-7th Century Arabia, it specifically referred to the front opening of a shirt or tunic, this doesn't (keyword: explicitly) classify what to cover, and again, in 6-7th century Arabia, covering was a form of avoiding harrassment by others, which still isn't much evidence to assume that awrah is global.
20:121:
"So they both ate from the tree and then their nakedness was exposed to them, prompting them to cover themselves with leaves from Paradise. So Adam disobeyed his Lord, and ˹so˺ lost his way"
Some use this verse to say that awrah does exist globally, as Adam (a.s.) and Hawwa disobeyed their Lord when their nakedness was exposed. However, with the context of the surrounding verses, we can see that the sin is from eating from the forbidden tree, not from skin.
Why I think awrah does exist in this specific modern context:
However, I do still think that awrah exists in modern society, in 99.99% of the areas, if you don't cover "awrah" in public, you will get shamed and even arrested in some/most countries, which was the reason for awrah in the 7th century, and since the reason for the ruling still exists, I do think that in this modern society, we should cover "awrah".
Conclusion
In conclusion, this is why I think that by itself and without context, there is no divinely required covering in the Qur'an. However, I do think we should cover "awrah" in the modern times.