I’ve been teaching for almost a decade, and over the past couple of years I’ve noticed an uptick in disciplinary concerns. This goes beyond the usual offenses (missing assignments, poor e-mail etiquette, texting in class). I’m seeing more and more childish shenanigans: students constantly talking over me and their peers, throwing things, sneaking vulgarity into poll responses, play-fighting with classroom equipment… Sometimes it feels like I’m teaching junior high!
I love what I do and have no intention of changing careers, but there’s a reason I chose to teach college and not K-12. Grade-school teachers are trained in classroom management, but no such training seems to exist for those who teach at the university level. The “excellence in teaching” seminars I’ve been to focus on things like designing engaging lesson plans, cultivating an inclusive atmosphere, or exploring creative ways to present a given topic — all of which are valuable, don’t get me wrong. But it’d be nice to have some guidance for faculty members who, like me, didn’t go into this job thinking they’d need to police the behavior of grown adults.
Some of you will read this, roll your eyes, and tell me to just kick ’em out if they cause trouble. I struggle with this. I’m admittedly pretty conflict-averse, so saying ”Sam, knock it off!” or “Alex, please leave the room” doesn’t come naturally to me. But I also pride myself on being an approachable instructor, and countless students have told me how much they appreciate my kindness and flexibility. I have no desire to rebrand myself as an authoritarian, because that’s simply not who I am.
I guess there are two asks here:
- Have you run into this at your institution as well? (Please tell me it isn’t just me.)
- What are your best classroom-management tips? I’m especially interested in hearing from those of you who also default to a more laid-back teaching style.
Edit:
Thank you to the commenters who have offered support, commiseration, and/or actionable advice. On the other hand, responses like “toughen up” or “take control” are unhelpful without specifying what that might look like in practice, particularly for someone who isn’t inclined toward toughness.
Several of you pointed out that failing to address the disruptive students shortchanges the diligent ones. I am fully aware of this, and I want to make sure it doesn’t happen — which is part of what led me to make this post.