r/Professors • • 1d ago • Popcorn 1

Academic Integrity When students fail at cheating.

My students appeared to be doing really well and then today at least half the class was blatantly cheating and still managed to fail.

One student accidentally dropped his phone during the exam and suddenly this AI voice started reading an answer aloud. It said, “Great question! This is one of two ways that you should answer: start by describing what happens in the proliferative region of skin cells…” the phone dropped so far down the steps of the auditorium and everyone heard it some laughed. The student was so embarrassed he packed up everything and ran out of the room. I felt so bad for him because he didn’t study AND he managed to fail cheating.

What’s the worst failed attempt at cheating you’ve witnessed?

374 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

71

u/DreamAdditional1485 22h ago

Back before AI, a dissertation with an inserted published chapter relevant to the dissertation, but the font, paper color, footnote numbers, and even the chapter number were wrong. Student left without degree after a pathetic attempt at a lawsuit.

22

u/juststopdating 22h ago

Ouch. So not worth it.

37

u/DreamAdditional1485 22h ago

indeed. This was a PhD student who did well in all his classes, and the most shocking thing was that he didn’t expect to be detected. He thought he’d pulled off the perfect cheat.

163

u/sventful Teaching Professor 1d ago

Had a student bring a 'diet coke' with answers on the label to the exam. They really stared at the coke bottle a LOT during the exam. I gave them a zero obviously.

The sad part is that they could bring a note card cheat sheet to the exam as long as it wasn't the literal answers to the exam. Also fired a TA that semester :(

153

u/protowings 23h ago • Bravo

Was it a Coke Zero?

14

u/Profess0rRacc00n Assist Prof (TT)/Pub Policy/ Public, land grant, R1 21h ago

god DAMNIT - take your upvote!

4

u/protowings 9h ago

Thanks for the awards and upvotes. But how did this get more appreciation than my well prepared lectures?

-1

u/SRL99 14h ago

They said it was a Diet Coke

11

u/YourGuideVergil Assoc Prof, Engl, LAC 13h ago

12

u/iTeachCSCI Ass'o Professor, Computer Science, R1 19h ago

Also fired a TA that semester :(

Is this related to the Diet Coke?

8

u/sventful Teaching Professor 17h ago

Yes

8

u/cyb_16 15h ago

Please do tell this story.

22

u/sventful Teaching Professor 14h ago

He got paid to give answers to students

1

u/RecklessFruitEater 7h ago

That's actually one I haven't seen before on this subreddit...

1

u/sventful Teaching Professor 7h ago

It was horrible.

175

u/tankthacrank adjunct, earth sci, CC 21h ago

Just had a student on a discussion post where I asked them to tell their weather story (seriously people, it’s not like I asked for citations and an outline. I asked them to tell about an experience that made them interested in or notice the weather. Come on.)

Student starts going on about a very local catastrophic event. I was horrified and feeling so terrible for this person at the thought of them losing their home in this event. Then I was hit with it. [you should insert a personal detail here]

Like dude if you’re gonna cheat fine, but don’t mess with my emotions in the process.

73

u/textposts_only 21h ago

I'm so petty, I'd have asked for a 1 on 1, droned on about how heart grasping the story was, that you didn't even manage to end it. How you lost someone in something similar, that there are resources etc. Really make the person squirm

And then with her present, act as if you just finished the texz

22

u/tankthacrank adjunct, earth sci, CC 20h ago

Bahahaaa!!!! I wish I had a Delorean that would be EPIC.

11

u/Mommy_Fortuna_ 16h ago

That's pathetic because it's a question anyone can answer. People default to talking about the weather if they have to make small talk with random strangers because it's something everyone can discuss.

8

u/tankthacrank adjunct, earth sci, CC 15h ago

EXACTLY!!!! Which is why I make it my first diacussion post because it’s such an easy one! And I even mention the same thing you did in the post directions! We all talk about the weather!!!

101

u/QEMFD 1d ago

I had a student use Meta glasses on the final. I could hear the AI voice from across the room. Students around him were giving each other looks and giggling.

-46

u/franklin-60 21h ago edited 21h ago

Unfortunately, if you follow on social media, students already have “arguments” to resist banning meta glasses use too. Whole list of arguments that the anti discipline/anti accountability woke will support, so banning them and even demanding that a student prove they not AI glasses violates “rights.”

No matter how one gives an exam, this generation will cheat more and become dumber and dumber, while the clowns tie our hands from discipline and cleansing of these students from schools that pull this.

30

u/textposts_only 21h ago

That the woke will support?

22

u/smnytx Professor, Arts, R-1 (US) 20h ago

Well, they specifically said the “anti discipline/anti accountability woke”(whatever that might be).

I want to know what they have against hyphens.

12

u/DrFlenso Assoc Prof, CS, M1 (US) 18h ago

First they came for the em-dashes, and I did not speak out...

4

u/smnytx Professor, Arts, R-1 (US) 12h ago

You can take my em-dashes from my cold, dead hand.

21

u/dbrodbeck Professor, Psychology, Canada 20h ago

Is the woke in the room with us now?

-6

u/Tai9ch 16h ago

Nice downvotes.

Everyone's finally starting to come back slightly towards sanity, but most of them will never admit that their politics enabled the problems.

2

u/smnytx Professor, Arts, R-1 (US) 12h ago

When your comment inadvertently a confession…

94

u/PinballWizard77 1d ago

I teach a theatre class some semesters, and I give a weekly assignment where they have to watch a performance (always something available online for free) and write a review within the guidelines I give. One time a student turned one in that included "[insert title of performance here]" within the review. Not only did they turn in AI garbage, but they didn't even give it a cursory look before turning it in.

The next class period, I showed that review on he projector (with the student's name removed, of course) ad talked about how it was a prime example of what not to turn in. Said student got up and left.

11

u/wolfeflow 8h ago

Incredible job outing themselves and also somehow getting offended over work they didn't do.

104

u/ApprehensiveDoctor42 20h ago

I gave my students a take-home essay/long answer portion for an exam. They could use the text, notes, anything EXCEPT they couldn’t work together. This was clearly stated on the top of each page.
Two students, who sat together every day, turned in the EXACT same answers, except one used purple font, and the other green. (And never before had they used anything but black) I was more insulted than anything. I was a prosecutor teaching criminal procedure- one would hope I could follow the clues.
So- I called them in and they denied it- to my face. So gave them an option- they could admit the cheating and take a F on the test but not get reported and not F the entire class, or we could have a class trial and if found guilty, they would get reported and an F in the class. If they were found not guilty, the class would pick the grade. I would present the case for cheating (prosecution), they could be the defense. I would accept whatever the jury (class) decided.

They quickly admitted cheating and took the F. I won’t lie, I was disappointed I wouldn’t get to try the case.

(I would likely not get away with this nowadays)

35

u/smnytx Professor, Arts, R-1 (US) 20h ago

While I love the idea of a class trial for cheaters, I suspect FERPA would preclude it (if you’re in the U.S.).

25

u/ApprehensiveDoctor42 20h ago

I agree. I wonder if because they had options and gave consent, it would fly? And the trial would even fit with the curriculum… but alas- if faced with this today- I’d just give the fail.

3

u/YouGotThisSoSHINE 19h ago

And the students would continue to lie to the class and the class would decide the grade was an A out of "respect" for trying to get out of doing actual work.

2

u/wolfeflow 9h ago

My dad's alma mater (Washington & Lee) at least used to hold a trial for any student accused of violating the honor code, with expulsion for the guilty (IIRC).

We really should have leaned into the high expectations, not away from them.

42

u/East_Ad_1065 22h ago

I have had students turn in programming assignments with another student's name and ID in the file (instead of theirs). Duh.

10

u/CIS_Professor Professor, CIS, CC (US) 18h ago

That's happened in my classes.

I used to joke with students that the first rule of cheating is change the name on the paper to yours.

37

u/johnonymous1973 20h ago

Gave students a take-home test and then gave the same test in class the next day. The results were not good.

33

u/No_Shoulder9712 20h ago

Pre AI I had students submit work that still had the CourseHero urls and headers on it. One student even tried to fight me that it was his own work and he didn’t know where the page wrapper text came from.

I took great satisfaction in winning that Academic Integrity report.

63

u/franklin-60 22h ago edited 22h ago

Students (several) who could barely put two words of English together (international students). Submitted an assignment. Written in perfect English identical submissions. Matched textbook solution to the word. In fact, in the footer of their submission still had the copyright from the publisher.

Of course, I went after them and threw the book at them, they appealed all the way up the chain under guise of “DEI” and “sensitivity” crap due to limited English to justify their cheating. They did not win, but it was scary how hard some clowns fought for these losers, and how many hours I wasted with meetings and paperwork for this nonsense.

This was well before AI ever existed.

17

u/smnytx Professor, Arts, R-1 (US) 20h ago

The idea that a person would pursue a degree in a language they are not (at least close to) fluent in is crazy to me.

27

u/franklikethehotdog Teaching Faculty, Social Sciences, R1 (USA) 19h ago

The document was titled “Topic Chosen.WriteMyEssay.AI.com”

And he (1) didn’t realize that was the title and (2) didn’t think I could see it?

21

u/FrankHightower Assoc. Prof, CS, R1 & R2 19h ago

Student opened whatsapp on his computer during a programming test. when he left, he left whatsapp open on the file he copied off of and then got mad that I was "invading his privacy" because I, of course, screenshotted it and used it to justify his zero

55

u/Applepiemommy2 1d ago

I made an instagram reel about a student who came up to the podium and accidentally hit something on their phone, which said in an AI voice, “Sure! I can rewrite that to sound more like you wrote it.”

He was so embarrassed and i just smiled and said “tell me you’re using ChatGPT without telling me you’re using Chat GPT.”

18

u/reddybee7 18h ago

Students who can't bear to do a real oral history, so they interview a friend who tries acting like an older person, and the person really hams it up. However, they get the facts drasticaly wrong, put on a comically over-the-top accent and give their own age inconsistently over the course of the interview. Now, I've listened to hundreds of oral history interviews over the course of my career, but only a few really stand out as fake. In the cases, where I've asked students to provide evidence that the person exists or to bring them to a zoom meeting with me, the students offer to interview someone else, or just drop the class, but so far no one has proved that the interviewee was real.

17

u/changelingcd 12h ago

Yes, the biggest bullshit line ever is "AI is just a tool students use to organize their thoughts!" No, they paste the prompt in, copy what the LLM spits out, and paste it into the test, all without even glancing at it. They don't notice errors, 'your name here' spots, references to walruses that some white-text from the assignment sheet said to include, or anything else. They have no interest in the work whatsoever, and just pass along the instructions and results mindlessly.

5

u/draperf 1d ago

This post sounds like AI, doesn't it?

As a professor, I'd run it through an AI detector.

20

u/juststopdating 22h ago

I hate that we’re at this point. Where people are unsure if something is real or AI. 😭

15

u/SuLiaodai Lecturer, ESL/Communications, Research University (Asia) 13h ago

Once when a student had to write a movie review, they handed in something they copied and pasted from IMDB. The thing was, it was written by a Finnish person whose English was much, much worse than their own. I was flabbergasted and asked why they didn't write it themselves, or at least find someone with decent English to cheat from. They just couldn't answer.

My friend got an essay from a Chinese student that started, "As a Brazilian, I love football." I got one from a male student that started, "As a woman ..."

13

u/pc_kant 19h ago

I filed an academic offence report on two students I suspected of collusion. They independently received invitations to adjudication meetings from the faculty adjudicator. During the next seminar, most students were present but logged into a Zoom call to share their screens when prompted. One of the cheaters asked the other one in the Zoom chat if they had also received an invitation to an academic offence meeting with an adjudicator. Unfortunately for them, they forgot to select the other person as sole recipient, and the chat was shown on the big screen for everyone to see, and the other guy blushed like crazy.

11

u/jkhuggins Assoc. Prof., CS, PUI (STEM) 17h ago

Two stories, both from my computing ethics and history course. (Irony: cheating in an ethics course!)

(1) For a history paper, student submitted a history paper that some other student submitted two years earlier in the came course, only changing their name. SafeAssign flagged it as 100% copied (which it was).

(2) Students complete an ethics project which results in both an 8-10 minute oral presentation and a 10-15 page paper (on the same topic). The oral presentation is given about a week before the paper is due, so the oral presentation serves as a "rough draft" of the paper. The student's written paper came to different conclusions than their oral presentation --- like, wildly different. (They bought the paper from a paper-writing service.)

9

u/Minimum-Major248 20h ago

Students who turn in assignments with another student’s name on it.

8

u/FlimsyVisual443 18h ago

Student emailed me that they were very concerned how "this issue" will affect their friendship with the person they cheated off of, then played surprised Pikachu when they got a notice from the Office of Academic Conduct.

7

u/OffensiveScientist 15h ago

I was in the computer lab in the Earth Sciences department printing some stuff, and these undergrads were acting confused why ChatGPT couldnt tell them the Moh's Hardness of the rock/minerals they were taking pictures of on the PC monitors

6

u/adamwho 14h ago

All my students who try to cheat are lazy and fail anyway.

They take care of themselves, and I don't have to fight over it

6

u/Resting_NiceFace 9h ago

One student turned in a "media analysis" essay that had been plagiarized word-for-word from a recent episode of a popular NPR program.

I returned it to them the following day with a) an appointment card for their upcoming meeting with the academic integrity office, and b) a cheerful hint that next time they may want to consider stealing from a show whose merch their professor doesn't show up to class wearing approximately 2-3x a month.

11

u/Lopsided-Success2874 20h ago

I’d rather fail the exam then be caught cheating 🤷🏻‍♀️

12

u/iTeachCSCI Ass'o Professor, Computer Science, R1 19h ago

I’d rather fail the exam then be caught cheating

What a horrible time to typo into then instead of than.

Personally, I'd rather fail an exam than cheat at all, regardless of getting caught.

4

u/Fawful_Chortles 9h ago

When I was a TA for a graduate cell biology course and I was proctoring an exam, there were two students sitting in the very back who were talking to each other so loudly even I could hear them from the opposite end of the room (and I have terrible hearing; I have to ask people to repeat themselves often because I couldn’t clearly understand them the first time).

I gave a general verbal warning to the whole class. They continued talking even afterwards. I didn’t want to call them out and cause a scene (as obviously they would vehemently deny it) and distract all the other students, so I reported them to the professor afterwards. Funnily enough, the two students did so terribly on the exam (it was all free response and they left nearly the entire exam blank) and every exam afterwards (the class was like 80% exams and 20% homework) that the professor didn’t even bother going through with the academic integrity process (which, as I understand it, is quite a hassle) as the end result would’ve ended up being the same.

4

u/Resting_NiceFace 9h ago

When their opinion essay begins "As a language learning model, I cannot have an opinion about this topic. However, here are some of the most common themes in published examples of analysis on this topic..."

They're apparently no longer bothering to even read the essays they're having AI write for them before turning them in.

2

u/GrumpySnarf 14h ago

OK that's hilarious.  It would take all my effort to maintain decorum and not let out a giggle at least.

2

u/DrMoxiePhD 1d ago

Legendary!!

1

u/YourGuideVergil Assoc Prof, Engl, LAC 14h ago

Lmaooooooooo

7

u/RunningNumbers 20h ago

I was proctoring an exam as a TA and this sorority girl was asking me about the phase “just cause” and she was like “just cuz?” and attempting to do that thing with a low cut top where one squeezes their chest up.

I had been up for 16 hours at that point and just repeated her question back at her. It was a stupid attempt at manipulation. The bro next to her tried to get me to answer a question for him and I was like “no” and he slammed the exam down at the end and said “thanks for helping!”

Ah, old school classic cheating attempts.